One of the first three books to be released in Routledge's new “Modern and Contemporary Dramatists” series, Susan Glaspell and Sophie Treadwell by Barbara Ozieblo and Jerry Dickey provides a concise introduction to the lives, works, and criticism of these important American dramatists. The publisher's stated goals for the series are to provide “primary materials on contemporary dramatists who are under-represented in secondary criticism,” and Ozieblo and Dickey have condensed a broad range of information in efficient service of that intention.
The book's introductory section provides brief coverage of the historical and theoretical backgrounds relevant to a study of Glaspell and Treadwell. Seven sections, ranging from “The Little Theater Movement” to “Feminist Critical Theory and the Theater” provide a useful if abbreviated historical and critical background. The succinctness here is characteristic of the book as a whole, and is one of its strengths, as Ozieblo and Dickey provide a thorough overview in a relatively small number of pages.
Part I of the book covers Glaspell and begins with a “Life and Ideas” chapter in which Ozieblo draws from a variety of resources—her 2000 work Susan Glaspell: A Critical Biography key among them—to paint a concentrated theoretical and biographical picture of the playwright. Much of the subsequent material is framed as a demonstration of the conflicting ideologies in Glaspell's life. Ozieblo contrasts the playwright's “firm belief in individual freedom of choice” with her “obligations and responsibilities to friends, family, and society” (13). This first chapter moves freely among Glaspell's biography, her place in the American dramatic canon, the Provincetown Players, and thematic analysis. Although the arrangement of these topics is not always intuitive, the result is a solid overview of the playwright that prepares a reader for the play summaries and production histories that follow.
The next two chapters cover twelve of Glaspell's major plays (six shorter works and six full-length pieces). The approach and sources vary slightly, but a great deal of information is packed into a small space here. In the discussion of The Outside, for example, Ozieblo begins by situating the play in its historical and geographical setting, using Glaspell's own words to indicate her vision for the piece. After a summary of the plot, Ozieblo then touches briefly on production history, contemporary reviews, and a few paragraphs of critical analysis and thematic investigation to situate the play within Glaspell's larger body of work. This methodology is expanded in Chapters 4 and 5, which delve into plot summary, production history, structural analysis, and criticism of Trifles and The Verge. As in the preceding chapters, the combination of brevity and density provides an excellent survey of the existing literature on Glaspell and these two quintessential works.
The structure and methodology of Ozieblo's coverage of Glaspell is mirrored almost identically in the section on Treadwell, and Dickey similarly draws from his own longer works on the subject. In “Life and Ideas” (Chapter 6), he begins by addressing Treadwell's position of relative obscurity within the canon, arguing that her larger body of work deserves the same level of attention focused on her masterpiece Machinal. Dickey's biographical essay charts Treadwell's feminist activism and contradictory attitude toward Broadway, a lifelong “outspoken condemnation of the very venue to which she aspired” (107), citing the latter as a likely reason for her historical erasure. The subsequent brief summaries, histories, and critical analyses of individual plays are usefully divided into “Early Plays” and “Broadway and Later Plays” (Chapters 7 and 8). The “Key Plays” discussions offer more in-depth coverage of Machinal and Imitations for Saxophone (Chapters 9 and 10, respectively).
This volume does not break substantial new scholarly ground regarding either playwright, but that is clearly not the intention of either the authors or the publisher. Instead, Ozieblo and Dickey effectively corral and summarize existing perspectives to create a useful handbook, covering the lives, careers, works, production histories, and existing criticism of these two women. The resulting work is a dense, well-considered, and valuable starting point for interested scholars, directors, or instructors unfamiliar with the existing body of scholarship on Treadwell and Glaspell.
