Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-15T21:36:51.355Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Homogenization-based design of microstructured membranes: wake flows past permeable shells

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 September 2021

Pier Giuseppe Ledda*
Affiliation:
Laboratory of Fluid Mechanics and Instabilities, École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, CH-1015 Lausanne, Switzerland
E. Boujo
Affiliation:
Laboratory of Fluid Mechanics and Instabilities, École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, CH-1015 Lausanne, Switzerland
S. Camarri
Affiliation:
Dipartimento di Ingegneria Civile e Industriale, Università degli Studi di Pisa, 56122 Pisa, Italy
F. Gallaire
Affiliation:
Laboratory of Fluid Mechanics and Instabilities, École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, CH-1015 Lausanne, Switzerland
G.A. Zampogna
Affiliation:
Laboratory of Fluid Mechanics and Instabilities, École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, CH-1015 Lausanne, Switzerland
*
†Email address for correspondence: pier.ledda@epfl.ch

Abstract

A formal framework to characterize and control/optimize the flow past permeable membranes by means of a homogenization approach is proposed and applied to the wake flow past a permeable cylindrical shell. From a macroscopic viewpoint, a Navier-like effective stress jump condition is employed to model the presence of the membrane, in which the normal and tangential velocities at the membrane are respectively proportional to the so-called filtrability and slip numbers multiplied by the stresses. Regarding the particular geometry considered here, a characterization of the steady flow for several combinations of constant filtrability and slip numbers shows that the flow morphology is dominantly influenced by the filtrability and exhibits a recirculation region that moves downstream of the body and eventually disappears as this number increases. A linear stability analysis further shows the suppression of vortex shedding as long as large values of the filtrability number are employed. In the control/optimization phase, specific objectives for the macroscopic flow are formulated by adjoint methods. A homogenization-based inverse procedure is proposed to obtain the optimal constrained microscopic geometry from macroscopic objectives, which accounts for fast variations of the filtrability and slip profiles along the membrane. As a test case for the proposed design methodology, a cylindrical membrane is designed to maximize the resulting drag coefficient.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.(a) Fluid flow configuration considered in the present work and its typical structure past the cylindrical permeable shell ($\varGamma _{{int}}$, in red) of diameter $D$, where we denote the length of the recirculation region $L_R$ and its distance $X_R$ from the rear of the body. The angle $\alpha$ is measured counterclockwise starting from the rear. The superscript minus sign indicates that the generic variable $f$ is evaluated in the outer fluid region while the superscript plus sign refers to the inner fluid region. (b) Zoom on the shell to highlight its microscopic structure in cylindrical coordinates, made by replication of solid inclusions denoted by $\mathbb {M}$ with boundary $\partial \mathbb {M}$ and sketch of the elementary unit cell in dashed line, whose tangential-to-surface size is $\ell$. The fluid domain within the unit cell is denoted by $\mathbb {F}$ while its upper and lower boundaries are indicated, respectively, with $\mathbb {U}$ and $\mathbb {D}$.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Computational domain considered in the present work. The regions denoted with $N_j$ represent the different mesh refinements used when approaching the permeable shell. At the inlet $\varGamma _{{in}}$ a free-stream condition with a Dirichlet boundary condition of the form $u^*_1=U$ and $u^*_2=0$ is imposed, while on the lateral boundaries $\varGamma _{{lat}}$ and at the oulet $\varGamma _{{out}}$ the stress-free condition $(-p^*\delta _{ij}+\mu \partial ^*_j u^*_i)n_j=0$ is used. On the interface $\varGamma _{{int}}$ conditions (2.3) are imposed.

Figure 2

Figure 3.(a) Generic workflow to efficiently analyse a flow configuration via homogenized models integrated in classical analyses like, for instance, parametric studies, stability analysis or adjoint-optimization finalized to identify configurations of interest. The retrieval of the full-scale physics for the identified configurations is done in a last step leading to a substantial reduction of the complexity of the optimization problem. (b,c) The generic workflow has been specialized in the present paper for the design of permeable membranes. Colours and red numbers are used to correctly place each step of the procedure adopted in the present paper in the generic workflow. A homogenized model is used to characterize a specific flow configuration in a direct formulation. This allows one to identify a set of objectives and the corresponding values of the macroscopic parameters realizing these objectives. Homogenization is then used in an inverse formulation to associate the values of the macroscopic tensors with a specific microscopic geometry.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Streamlines of the flow past the cylindrical permeable shell at $Re=50$ for $\mathcal {L}=10^{-4}$ and four different values of $\mathcal {F}$: (a) $\mathcal {F}=10^{-4}$, (b) $\mathcal {F}=10^{-3}$, (c) $\mathcal {F}=10^{-2}$ and (d) $\mathcal {F}=3 \times 10^{-2}$.

Figure 4

Figure 5.(a–d) Streamlines identifying the recirculation region past the cylindrical permeable shell at $Re=50$ for different values of $\mathcal {F}$. Each panel corresponds to a single value of $\mathcal {L}$.

Figure 5

Figure 6.(a–d) Streamlines identifying the recirculation region past the cylindrical permeable shell at $\mathcal {F}=10^{-2}$ and for different values of $Re$ and $\mathcal {L}$. Note that for $\mathcal {L}=3\times 10^{-2}$ and $Re=110$, recirculation is suppressed.

Figure 6

Figure 7.(a) Length of the recirculation region past the cylindrical permeable shell $L_R$ for $\mathcal {F}\in [10^{-3} , 2\times 10^{-2}]$ and $\mathcal {L}\in [10^{-3} , 2\times 10^{-2}]$. Each cluster represents a single value of $Re$. From top to bottom: $Re=100,75,50,25$. (b) Distance of the recirculation region from the rear of the body $X_R$ for the same values of the parameters. From bottom to top: $Re=50,75,100$.

Figure 7

Figure 8.(a,b) Variation of the drag coefficient $C_D$ with $\mathcal {F}$ for different values of $\mathcal {L}$. Each cluster corresponds to a different value of $Re$, as denoted in the figure.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Pressure (a) and viscous stress (b) contributions to the drag following the cylinder surface. The angle $\alpha$ is measured counterclockwise starting from the rear. The colours denote different values of $\mathcal {F}=10^{-4}$ (blue), $\mathcal {F}=5 \times 10^{-3}$ (orange), $\mathcal {F}= 10^{-2}$ (yellow), $\mathcal {F}=5 \times 10^{-2}$ (purple). The slip number is kept fixed to $\mathcal {L}=10^{-4}$. (c)–(e) Streamlines (black bold lines) and iso-contours of the pressure for the steady flow around and through the permeable circular membrane, for different values of $\mathcal {F}$ and $\mathcal {L}=10^{-4}$.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Marginal stability curves in the plane $(\mathcal {F},Re)$. Each curve is associated with a different value of slip number $\mathcal {L}=10^{-4}$ (blue), $\mathcal {L}=10^{-3}$ (orange), $\mathcal {L}=10^{-2}$ (yellow), $\mathcal {L}=2\times 10^{-2}$ (purple). The inset shows a zoom in for large values of $\mathcal {F}$. The coloured circles represent the values of the Strouhal number along the marginal stability curve in the region depicted in the inset.

Figure 10

Figure 11.Real part of the eigenvector $\hat {u}_1$ associated with the marginally stable eigenvalue for $Re=46.7$, $\mathcal {L}=10^{-2}$ and $\mathcal {F}=10^{-3}$ ($a$) and for $Re=87$, $\mathcal {L}=10^{-4}$ and $\mathcal {F}=1.075\times 10^{-2}$ ($b$). The velocity eigenvectors are normalized by their $L_2$ norm.

Figure 11

Figure 12.Iso-contours of $C_D$ for $Re=100$ in the $(\mathcal {F},\mathcal {L})$ plane. Symbols identify the configurations listed in table 1. The marginal stability curve for the value of $Re$ considered is represented by a bold solid line (all cases on the right-hand side of the curve are stable).

Figure 12

Figure 13.(a) Sketch of the membrane (red dashed line) with a zoom on the microscopic elementary cell used to calculate $\bar {L}_t$ and $\bar {F}_n$. The tangential- and normal-to-interface axes of the solid inclusion are respectively denoted with $l_t$ and $l_n$ and normalized by $\ell$. Iso-contours of $\bar {F}_n={\mathcal {F}}/{\varepsilon }$ (b) and $\bar {L}_t={\mathcal {L}}/{\varepsilon }$ (c) on the plane $(l_t,l_n)$, in logarithmic scale. Blue-to-red colours indicate positive values of $\bar {F}_n$ and $\bar {L}_t$ while grey-scale refers to negative values of $\bar {L}_t$. The lines identify the iso-contours of the possible couples $(l_n,l_t)$ whose symbols correspond to different couples $(\mathcal {F},\mathcal {L})$ of figure 12. Each point on those lines is a good candidate to realize the desired value of $\mathcal {F}$ and $\mathcal {L}$, upon adjustment of the value of $\varepsilon$. The selected values of $l_t$ and $l_n$ are labelled with white arrows for each case.

Figure 13

Table 1.Relevant geometrical and physical parameters for the cases chosen in figure 12; $N$ indicates the number of inclusions forming the membrane, the superscript $^{EQ}$ denotes quantities calculated using model (2.7) on $\varGamma _{int}$ while the absence of superscript denotes quantities evaluated from the full-scale solution.

Figure 14

Figure 14.Comparison between full-scale and equivalent model for cases $\star$ and $\square$ identified in figure 12. The microscopic geometry forming the cylindrical shell, sketched for each case in the grey insets on the left, is the result of the inverse procedure explained in § 4.2. (a,d) Flow streamlines for the full-scale case (black dashed lines) and for the macroscopic model (blue solid lines). (b,c,e,f) Horizontal and vertical velocities $U_1$ and $U_2$ sampled on the cylindrical shell using the angle $\alpha$ measured counterclockwise starting from the rear. Dashed lines represent the full-scale model, blue lines the macroscopic model and red stars the average of the full-scale model, calculated applying a discrete version of the integral in (4.3), based on a 1-point Gaussian rule, to the velocity profile in each microscopic elementary cell forming the membrane. Numerical values of $\epsilon$, $\mathcal {F}$, $\mathcal {L}$ and other representative values of the fluid flow ($C_D$, $X_R$, $L_R$) are listed in table 1 for each case.

Figure 15

Figure 15.(a,b) Comparison between the homogenized and full-scale results of the stability analysis. The crosses and the circles denote the eigenvalues obtained from the full-scale structure and from the homogenized model, respectively, for the two reported cases.

Figure 16

Figure 16.$(a)$ Variation of the drag coefficient with $\mathcal {F}$, for $\mathcal {L}=5 \times 10^{-3}$, directly evaluated from macroscopic model (2.6), (2.7) (black circles) and predictions of the gradient via the sensitivity approach (coloured lines) carried out around the configurations identified by coloured circles. $(b)$ Distribution of sensitivity with respect to $\mathcal {F}$ along the $y>0$ part of the cylinder, i.e. $0<\alpha <{\rm \pi}$, for the configurations denoted with colours in $(a)$.

Figure 17

Figure 17.$(a)$ Variation of the drag coefficient with $\mathcal {L}$, for $\mathcal {F}=0.03$, directly evaluated from macroscopic model (2.6), (2.7) (black circles) and predictions of the gradient via the sensitivity approach (coloured lines) carried out around the corresponding coloured circles. $(b)$ Distribution of sensitivity with respect to $\mathcal {L}$ along the $y>0$ part of the cylinder, $0<\alpha <{\rm \pi}$.

Figure 18

Figure 18.Results from the gradient-based optimization. Final distribution of $(a)$$\mathcal {F}$ and $(b)$$\mathcal {L}$, when both $\mathcal {F}$ and $\mathcal {L}$ are optimized for different initial guesses (coloured lines) and when only variations of $\mathcal {F}$ are considered with initial guess $\mathcal {F}^{(0)}=0.0125$ and $\mathcal {L}^{(0)}=0.005$ (red dashed line). The various initial guesses are $\mathcal {F}^{(0)}=0.0125$ and $\mathcal {L}^{(0)}=0.005$ (blue), $\mathcal {F}^{(0)}=0.005$ and $\mathcal {L}^{(0)}=0.0125$ (orange), $\mathcal {F}^{(0)}=0.0025$ and $\mathcal {L}^{(0)}=0.0025$ (yellow), $\mathcal {F}^{(0)}=0.005$ and $\mathcal {L}^{(0)}=0.005$ (purple), $\mathcal {F}^{(0)}=0.01$, $\mathcal {L}^{(0)}=0.01$ (green).

Figure 19

Figure 19.$(a)$ Variation of the drag coefficient during the optimization procedure, for different initial guesses, as a function of the iteration number rescaled by the total number of iterations required to reach convergence. $(b)$ Variation of the drag coefficient during the iterative procedure of the gradient-based optimization, when both $\mathcal {F}$ and $\mathcal {L}$ (blue dots) and only $\mathcal {F}$ (orange dots) are varied, with initial guess $\mathcal {F}^{(0)}=0.0125$ and $\mathcal {L}^{(0)}=0.005$. In the insets, we report the distributions of $\mathcal {F}$ for different iterations, the horizontal and vertical axes of the insets corresponding to $0<\alpha <{\rm \pi}$ and $0<\mathcal {F}<1.55\times 10^{-2}$, respectively.

Figure 20

Figure 20.$(a)$ Example of a cylindrical shell formed by variable microscopic inclusions, corresponding to distribution D1 in Appendix C. $(b)$ Sketch of the microscopic domain, $\mathbb {F}_{tot}$, built by ‘unrolling’ the cylindrical shell (red and blue unit cells correspond to their ‘rolled’ counterpart in $a$). In order to deduce averaged profiles of $F_n$ and $L_t$, the solution is averaged within each cell over the green dashed line.

Figure 21

Figure 21.Values of $\mathcal {F}$ and $\mathcal {L}$ along $\mathbb {F}_{tot}$ (blue stars) and corresponding values computed within each cell $\mathbb {F}_{i}$ (light-blue circles) for distributions D1 (a,b) and D2 (c,d) described in Appendix C.

Figure 22

Figure 22.Comparison between the full-scale solution and the macroscopic model for distributions D1 (a,b) and D2 (c,d). All quantities are evaluated over the equivalent membrane $\varGamma _{int}$. Dashed lines represent the full-scale model, blue lines the macroscopic model where the values of the effective tensors have been calculated in $\mathbb {F}_{tot}$, light-blue dot-dashed lines correspond to the macroscopic model where the values of the effective tensors have been calculated in each periodic unit cell $\mathbb {F}_{i}$ and red stars represent the average of the full-scale model.

Figure 23

Figure 23.Variation of the optimal $\mathcal {F}$ profile with $\alpha$. Blue lines correspond to the values of $\mathcal {F}$ found in § 5.2 while red squares to the values of $\mathcal {F}$ reconstructed from the microscopic problems in $\mathbb {F}_{tot}$. Black dashed lines correspond to the profiles reconstructed via a piecewise cubic interpolation of the red-square profile. (a) A total of 23 inclusions have been placed on the cylindrical shell ($\epsilon =0.1369$); (b) 47 inclusions have been used ($\varepsilon =0.0667$). A larger number of inclusions allows us to better reconstruct the $\mathcal {F}$ profile.

Figure 24

Figure 24.Flow past the optimal cylindrical structure deduced from the profile of $\mathcal {F}$ computed in § 5.2. A total of 23 solid inclusions (sketched in dark grey in d–f) have been placed on the cylinder leading to a value of $\varepsilon$ equal to $0.137$. (a–c) Comparison between full-scale and macroscopic solution. (a) The flow streamlines for the full-scale simulation (black lines) and for the macroscopic model (blue lines). (b,c) The horizontal and vertical velocities over $\varGamma _{int}$. Black dashed lines represent the full-scale solution, blue lines the macroscopic model, where $\mathcal {F}$ and $\mathcal {L}$ are evaluated using the reconstructed profiles (see figure 23), and red stars the averaged full-scale profile. Iso-contours of pressure (d), horizontal velocity (e) and vertical velocity (f) around the cylindrical shell. In (d) also flow streamlines within the shell have been represented to better appreciate the flow behaviour.

Figure 25

Figure 25.Same as figure 24 for a total number of 47 solid inclusions on the cylinder, leading to $\varepsilon =0.066$.

Figure 26

Table 2.Results of the mesh convergence. The edge densities are denoted with $N$, for different regions as depicted in figure 2.

Figure 27

Figure 26.Overview of the mesh denoted by M1 in table 2 used for the macroscopic computations. In each coloured inset recursive magnifications approaching the cylinder are shown. In the light-blue inset prismatic layers adjacent to the fictitious interface $\varGamma _{{int}}$ can be noticed; they have been added in order to well evaluate the normal-to-membrane fluid stress and integral quantities like the drag force acting on the cylinder.

Figure 28

Figure 27.Adjoint field for $Re=100$, $\mathcal {F}=1.25\times 10^{-2}$, $\mathcal {L}=5\times 10^{-3}$. $(a)$ From top to bottom: $u_1^{\dagger}$, $u_2^{\dagger}$, $p^{\dagger}$; $(b)$$u_1^{{\dagger} {\dagger} }$ (blue curve) and $u_2^{{\dagger} {\dagger} }$ (orange curve) evaluated over $\varGamma _{{int}}$ for $\alpha \in [0,{\rm \pi} ]$.

Figure 29

Figure 28.Visualization of the whole full-scale membrane geometry for configurations (a) D1, (b) D2, (c) D3 and (d) D4.

Figure 30

Table 3.Values of the radius of the $i$th solid inclusion, non-dimensionalized with the microscopic length, for $i=1,\ldots ,24$ for distributions D1, D2, D3 and D4. Note that, in distribution D4, 47 solid inclusions are present and the radius of the $j$th inclusion for $j=25,\ldots ,47$ is equal to the radius of the $i$th inclusion, satisfying the formula $j=47-i+1$.