Whither the Jews? So asks Ross Kraemer in this landmark study. Her starting point is the diminishing evidence for Jews living in the Roman Empire outside Palestine as Late Antiquity progressed. This, it is usually assumed, stems from their mass conversion to Christianity under the twin pressures of acculturation and (legislative) violence; only Palestinian Judaism resisted, hence the rabbis’ subsequent domination. From this universalising and homogenising model K. demurs. Instead, she has attempted a detailed history of Jewish experience in the diaspora from the fourth to the seventh centuries. Since there is no identifiable literary evidence authored by diaspora Jews from this period in any language, this story of vast scope must be told from evidence of meagre extent: inscriptions, Christian-authored texts and laws — each with their own interpretative complexities. This partly explains why such a history has not been previously attempted, but, as K. elucidates, the lacuna also stems from multiple modern historiographical trends: efforts to prove Judaism a unified ‘nation’, the desire to present the diaspora as unwilling aberration, and the lingering influence of Christian supercessionism. That K. defies such inauspicious beginnings speaks both to the archival diligence and lasting importance of her project.
After an initial chapter discussing these issues and those of evidence, ch. 2 offers a close reading of the most detailed account of the forced conversion of late antique Jews, the fifth-century letter of Severus of Minorca. As this episode encompasses the book's topics — threats of and actual violence, synagogue-burning, looting, conversion, church construction and emigration, all against a (possible) legislative background — so, too, K.'s treatment is a microcosm of her overall approach: simultaneously sensitive to the distorting rhetoric of the letter, but keen to elicit what it might reveal about Jewish experience.
Chs 3–9 proceed chronologically, covering 312–363 (Constantine, his sons, and Julian), 363–395 (Valentinian, Gratian and Theodosius I), 395–408 (Arcadius, Honorius and Gamaliel VI), 408–423 (Honorius and Theodosius II), 423–450 (Theodosius II) and 450–604 (after Theodosius II), with this last split geographically into east and west. They are characterised by painstaking discussion of (mostly) legal material, informed by our improved understanding of both the law codes and the ‘situational and strategic’ laws they contain (81). Legislation pertaining to Judaism has traditionally been treated as evidencing either imperial ‘tolerance’ or ‘intolerance’, a simplification facilitated by the codes themselves, where laws are stripped of much contextual data. Here, instead, each law is revealed as singular, contingent and capable of multiple explanations. K. uncovers laws resulting from intra-factional court tensions; laws designed to harmonise earlier legal contradictions; laws responding to natural disasters; laws born of individual piety or influence; laws aimed at the issuer's self-protection or self-enhancement; laws drafted ambiguously to limit their efficacy while appeasing stakeholders; laws intended for one purpose harnessed for another; laws ostensibly concerning one group in fact targeting another; even laws requested by one Jewish faction against another. From this emerges a richer picture in which the Jews take their proper place, not as passive victims, but active agents whose fortunes waxed and waned alongside the other diverse stakeholders of late antique life.
The book concludes in ch. 10 with an overview of Jewish responses to these pressures — ‘conversion’ (with all the baggage implicit in that term), emigration, resistance, adaptation (including a discussion of whether female agency increased — a nice link to K.'s earlier work), retrenchment and death. A brief Epilogue, thirty-seven-page bibliography and three indices — of persons, places and subjects, of ancient sources and of modern authors — complete the volume.
Much of this book's value is in its close readings of individual pieces of evidence. But an overall corrective to the traditional narrative also emerges. First, while Jews were subject to a strengthening series of legal, economic, and physical restrictions, this was a slower and more uneven process than usually envisaged. Things were better in the fourth century than the fifth, and in the fifth than the sixth. But a model of linear decline hides the texture of real Jewish experience, which included protections and restrictions, and depended on all the fluid dynamics of local late antique life. Second, these restrictions were one strand of a programme of orthodox Christian homogenisation which also targeted Samaritans, ‘pagans’ and ‘heretical’ Christians. And in fact the Jews fared better than the latter groups, since legislation pertinent to them largely aimed at delineating and preserving community boundaries rather than eradication.
A work of such scope will naturally provoke objections or disappointment from some specialists. There are, for example, questionable assumptions concerning Constantine, and both Julian and John Chrysostom receive short shrift. But this is a seminal work precisely because it represents not the last word in the subject, but virtually the first. It also showcases three key methodological principles for writing the histories of religious groups. First, in repeatedly embedding incidents in their local context, it avoids assuming that religion was the prime explanatory factor. Second, in rejecting the traditional binary division of ‘diaspora’ and ‘rabbinic’ Judaism — which has tended to reinforce the uniformity of each category — it gives due consideration to the diversity of ancient life. Third, and most important, while never losing sight of the rhetorical sophistication of its materials, and the concomitant dangers of reconstructing the reality they purport to convey, it remains committed to empathising with its subjects’ real experience. It thus exhibits not just rigorous scholarship, but deep humanity.
