I belong to the generation of ethnomusicologists which has not personally met John Blacking. However, I have experienced Blacking's inspiring writings and (particularly during conversations with ethnomusicologists) gained a sense of his influential persona and vision. Almost two decades after his death, Blacking's ideas have here inspired nine authors to bring together different aspects of his thinking in a single volume, while exploring new areas beyond the boundaries of ethnomusicology in the 21st century.
In this edited book, which has grown out of papers around the theme of ‘John Blacking's Legacy’ presented at the Meeting of the European Seminar for Ethnomusicology (2000), the contributors take Blacking's writings as a departure point for discussions that are based on a rich range of sources, including their own fieldwork experiences. An elegant introduction is supplied by Suzel Ana Reily, which gives biographical data and lists academic outputs by and about Blacking, and introduces him as a politically aware ethnomusicologist and anthropologist, music-maker, performer, man of ideas and meticulous ethnographer who inspired ‘most of us’ to ‘believe that ethnomusicology can make a difference in the world’ (p. 2).
Keith Howard's subsequent chapter focuses on Blacking's ‘exemplary model of fieldwork practice’ (p. 18), evident in the sheer quality and quantity of Blacking's research which was firmly rooted in experience and understanding. While Howard critiques Blacking's Venda-grounded grand statements on humanly organised sound (p. 17), he acknowledges Blacking's contribution to the application of ethnomusicological methods to European art music.
Jaco Kruger departs from ethnomusicological fieldwork and instead takes Blacking's cultural analysis of music as a point of departure for discussions on the role of music amongst subaltern Venda communities within the broader context of globalisation. Noting the ‘glocalisation’ processes at play in African musics (pp. 38–39), Kruger's review of other writings (including Blacking's) on the various (and especially sonic) means of cultural resistance to globalisation aptly acknowledges the methodological challenges that emerge from such scholarly interpretation. He then continues this approach to investigate structural meaning in Venda guitar songs so as to show how Venda guitarists often creatively localise foreign musical styles by way of resistance.
This is followed by Deborah James’ account of ways in which the music of women's childhoods shapes their later musical experiences, a focus that closely resonates with Blacking's interest in music's role in socialising children and young women in the context of Venda society. To this end, James’ research is informed by and extends Blacking's argument about music's transformative and transcendent power in certain settings, yet the main focus here is on representing the complex interweaving of young female migrants’ life histories and musical experiences in South Africa based on James’ field research in the 1990s.
John Baily offers an accessible contribution on the relationship between the morphology of the Afghan lutes rubab and dutar, the motor patterns used during performance, and the structure of the music produced (p. 112). This chapter extends Blacking's interest in the biology of music making, that is, the relationship between music structures and the human body as influenced by the morphology of a musical instrument. Noteworthy is Baily's emphasis on the distinctiveness of his approach to learning to perform, claiming that his analyses were (in contrast to Blacking's etic approach) ‘conducted from the inside’ (p. 117). He also notes a general absence across ethnomusicological studies of similar focus on the human/musical instrument interface.
Dance anthropologist Helena Wulff takes Blacking's writings on dance among the Venda as a point of departure, specifically the transcendental state reached through the unity of body and mind. This chapter aims to explore ‘what it feels like to dance’ (p. 138) by illustrating the disciplining of Euro-American classical ballet dancers; the role of pain in ballet; and the transcendental states of flow while dancing. Wulff's writings are illustrated with examples concerning not just the performance itself (the focus in Blacking's work), yet also the preparation for a career as ballet dancer and the rehearsal process.
Rebecca Sager takes as a starting point Blacking's contribution to identity studies and his belief in music's semantic power as being determined by experiences of the ‘other self’, ‘a transcendent state of self’ in a world of ‘virtual time’ (p. 143). A somewhat lengthy, yet in-depth examination of Blacking's transformative theory of personal and sociocultural identity is provided here, followed by brief discussions on the transition into transcendental states of the ‘other self’ in Haitan Vodou singing and spirit possession, drawn from Sager's own fieldwork research. This then leads to illustrations of music's non-referential qualities, and concludes that more research is needed that focuses on the interplay of both referential and non-referential meanings in music.
In the final chapter, Britta Sweers draws on a wide array of academic sources (both in German and English) to investigate points of overlap between ethnomusicology and historical musicology. Noting the paradoxical coexistence of ethnomusicology's fascination with the other – that is, a fascination with cultural difference, also evident in teaching curricula and textbooks (p. 174) – and a broader concern among ethnomusicologists with humanity, Sweers argues that historical studies of Western music may benefit from an ethnomusicological (and specifically Blacking's) approach by viewing their subject matter through the eyes of the other (p. 191). Yet while an awareness of the ‘historical other’ has been slow to emerge within historical musicology (p. 183), Sweers suggests that European early music is an exception, and illustrates this with reference to early music performance studies.
The only contribution to deal directly with school music education is Fumiko Fujita's chapter (the fifth in the book), which extends Blacking's ideas about universal musicality to the ‘intrinsic’ nature of Japanese musicality. Fujita thus suggests that ‘all normal Japanese children are musical’ (p. 91), which she seeks to understand through research into early musical acquisition. On the basis of Blacking's Venda work, Fujita similarly argues that musical expression among Japanese children is deeply connected to their speech patterns (p. 91). She presents insights gained from substantial longitudinal research into Japanese nursery school children's development of musical competence. The breadth and depth of the examples presented by Fujita serve her well in suggesting that Japanese toddlers learn music intentionally through their interaction with the environment, and that this (informal) acquisition of musical competence is largely informed by their language acquisition. To prove her point, Fujita describes the development of musical competence at different stages in children's early life, and notes that two-year-olds in their musical learning typically disregarded the melodic contour of Western-style songs, yet more easily learnt those songs that followed Japanese speech patterns (particularly Japanese traditional songs). In conclusion, Fujita points to the increased importance of research that extends Blacking's belief in human musicality and predicts a significant impact on current thinking in music education.
The preponderance of ethnomusicologists and anthropologists contributing to the volume suggests that the book is aimed at a predominantly ethnomusicological readership. This does not come as a surprise, yet Blacking's work is also well-known for a concern with musical transmission and music education (p. 5; p. 23; p. 152), as demonstrated in Fujita's chapter. To music educators and pedagogues who have little experience with ethnomusicology, the conceptual complexity and specificity that at times dominate the discussions may therefore be of limited use for their work in the school music classroom.
Yet to music educationalists wishing to learn more about ethnomusicology – including the fieldwork approach; the cultural analysis of music; the role of music in socialisation; the impact of speech on musical competence; the biology of music making; the dynamics of moments of transcendence; the study of music through the eyes of the other; and the basic premise of universal human musicality – the book provides a rigorous introduction to the discipline. It is important to note, however, that the book's overall concern with ‘Blacking's ethnomusicology’ points towards a selective, rather than comprehensive representation of the current state of ethnomusicology in the 21st century. With this in mind, the book presents much stimulating material that is of relevance to ethnomusicologists and educationalists alike.
