In 1874, Narayan Vasudev, a prominent Bombay citizen, died when his newly constructed mansion on Malabar Hill collapsed. Inspection revealed that the sturdy-timber beams that had appeared to support the upper stories were, in fact, plank boxes filled with quicklime. Without adequate support, the structure as a whole collapsed. Inadequacies of Indian architects and engineers could be lethal.
This anecdote came to mind while reading Preeti Chopra's engaging new study, A Joint Enterprise: Bombay Elites and the Making of British Bombay which analyzes the sponsors, designers and builders of Bombay's emergence in the late nineteenth century as a major colonial city. Chopra, an architectural historian, revisits the conventional wisdom that Indians and the colonial regime developed Bombay jointly. Her analysis concentrates on the setting and processes by which the city's monumental structures were conceived, funded and realized, and how a new “public space” was created. The designs of these new buildings—whether commissioned by government or by private philanthropists—were informed largely by a Gothic Revival style, much favored at the time in Britain. Chopra emphasizes the conjunctions of a rise in the practice of philanthropy among Indian (Chopra prefers “native”) elites with the growth of the architectural profession. Colonial architecture was frequently commented on in London by the professional journal The Builder—whose comments on India are cited frequently. The new monumental buildings, she argues, created new public spaces which might function to emphasis the greatness of the Raj, but which also declared the significance of the charity, agency and public spirit of leading Indians of the city. Throughout the book, these propositions are supported by illustrations and architectural drawings.
The architectural history of colonial South Asian history has, in recent times, been advanced by, among others: Anthony King, Thomas Metcalf, Philip Davies, and Gavin Stamp. Chopra consciously relates her research to this existing body of literature while offering critical insights within the context of Bombay's history. A chapter on “Anglo-Indian Architecture” clarifies how the emerging architectural profession perceived the relative virtues of Indo-Saracenic and Gothic styles. She also examines relations between the architects and engineers in India.
A further chapter, “The Biography of an Unknown Native Engineer,” examines the career of Khan Bahadur Muncherji Cowasji Murzban, who rose to the rank of Executive Engineer in the Bombay Public Works Department and retired as the Executive Engineer of the Bombay Municipality. Here Chopra, while documenting the life of an “intermediate” man in a colonial order, also reveals his role in conceiving of, and promoting, residential colonies for his own Parsi community. This is followed by a study of the building of hospitals and lunatic asylums, both in terms of architectural design and as demonstrations of how philanthropists might promote institutions reserved for their own community, and how designs frequently emphasized “dividing practices” within the Indian communities, as well as between the Indian and European clientele.
“An Unforeseen Landscape of Contradictions” explores how the “joint enterprise” was complicated by European expectations of separate facilities, but more significantly by the fact that the Indian elites were wealthier than the European community. Nationalism generated fresh initiatives for institutions that were entirely Indian in character, although not in architecture.
The final chapter “Of Gods and Moral Heroes: Conundrums of the Secular Landscape of Colonial Bombay” raises the question of “religion” in the “secular” institutions of the city and its environment, including the old Government House at Parel and the caves of Elephanta island in the harbor. Special notice is taken of the Cornwallis monument on Elphinstone (now Horniman) Circle, to which Indian laborers, in spite of official remonstrances, offered garlands and gifts—reflecting a view of the former Governor-General's powers quite in excess of those he had actually possessed. The author concludes that the cited examples show us that “to occupy space is to reimagine it” (p. 230).
Chopra's monograph is a true contribution to bringing architectural practice and perception into the history of Bombay city. It does have some shortcomings that must be acknowledged. Some resources appear to not have been consulted, including the four volumes of The Bombay Builder, a colonial avatar of its metropolitan original. “Reimagination” may generate new hypotheses about the city's past, but even that cannot capture the mental maps of Bombay's inhabitants respecting the monumental buildings planted there during the colonial period. Each of the book's six chapters explores interesting aspects of architecture and/or philanthropy, yet the study remains only weakly connected by the metaphorical “joint enterprise.” We really need to know as much about those “Indian elites” as the “making of British Bombay.” Just as Narayan Vasudev's mansion needed sturdier timbers, so A Joint Enterprise could have been strengthened by the addition of a conclusion that drew together the narrative and interpretive threads of its individual parts.
