The Child as Musician is a multi-disciplinary exploration of the development and acquisition of musical skills from conception to adolescence. The latest challenge to Deliège and Sloboda's (Reference DELIÈGE and SLOBODA1996) Musical Beginnings, it contains 24 chapters discussing biological, environmental, social, cultural and historical influences on musical development, by 30 international authors representing a range of disciplines including music, psychology, sociology, education, philosophy and medicine. The book is divided into five sections: Development, Engagement, Differences, Skills and Contexts. Given the impressive number of contributions, it is impossible to critique them fully here. However, a summary is offered as an illustration of what the reader can expect to find.
The first section begins with an excellent chapter on prenatal development that sets a high standard for the rest of the book. Richard Parncutt discusses the idea that infants' musical skills may be learned, at least to some extent, before birth. He starts with a comprehensive overview of the fetal sound environment and the prenatal abilities and behaviours that could be described as ‘musical’. Parncutt's dichotomy between ‘scientific-conservative’ and ‘romantic-progressive’ research provides a useful context for understanding the literature on prenatal psychology. He goes on to define the terms ‘talent’, ‘music’ and ‘consciousness’ in relation to prenatal development, and ends by considering prenatal music education. The second chapter, by Sandra Trehub, is equally intriguing. While she is unable to demonstrate infants' awareness of musical conventions as such, Trehub nevertheless makes a strong case for describing infants as ‘musical connoisseurs’. Chapter 3, by Donald Hodges, explores the development of the musical brain, examining the differences between the brains of children who had formal musical training when very young and those who did not, while Jeanne Bamberger, in Chapter 4, ‘What develops in musical development?’, suggests that irregularities tell us more about development than more common occurrences. Susan Hallam concludes this section of the book with a chapter on ‘Musicality’, looking at theories of intelligence and the social construction of musical ability.
Section 2, ‘Engagement’, opens with E. Glenn Schellenberg's chapter, ‘Exposure to music: the truth about the consequences’. This offers an interesting account of claims associated with the non-musical effects of exposure to music. Schellenberg challenges the so-called Mozart effect, while arguing that music lessons have an indirect influence on cognitive abilities. Chapter 7, by David Hargreaves, Adrian North and Mark Tarrant, looks at musical preference and taste in childhood and adolescence. Using the reciprocal feedback model of musical response, they offer three approaches to understanding musical preferences and taste in young people: experimental aesthetics, developmental approaches and social identity theory. In Chapter 8, Janet Mills and Gary McPherson draw the comparison between speaking and reading before discussing the acquisition of musical notation. They believe that the term ‘musical literacy’ is often misunderstood, and encourage the reader to think in terms of multiple literacies. Margaret Barrett argues in Chapter 9 that the child is an ‘aesthetic agent’, constructing and performing an identity through musical engagement and experience. This section of the book ends with Emery Schubert and Gary McPherson offering their view on how children and adolescents perceive emotion in music, in contrast with the literature that focuses on emotional responses to music.
Section 3, ‘Differences’, discusses individual differences in musical development. James Austin, James Renwick and Gary McPherson provide an excellent, concise overview of various motivation theories, describing and explaining children's achievement goals, conceptions of ability, ability self-perceptions, interests and values, and attributional beliefs. Their summary of motivation from childhood to adolescence shows that motivation is very much a developmental process. In Chapter 12, Gary McPherson and Aaron Williamon use Gagné's differentiated model to define and discuss giftedness and talent in music. The section concludes with two chapters on children with disabilities. Judith Jellison reflects on social and educational policy and considers the ways in which children with disabilities are often excluded from musical activities, and the implications of such exclusion. Leslie Bunt then explores the role of music therapy for children, providing a valuable account of the many ways in which music can help children with profound communication difficulties and emotional and behavioural problems.
Section 4, ‘Skills’ begins with Kathryn Marsh and Susan Young exposing the gap in research investigating play in musical contexts. They emphasise that musical play is a form of expression and argue that it should not be confined to educational settings. In Chapter 16, Graham Welch looks at the development of singing from infancy to adolescence and examines the factors that can support and hinder it, such as activities promoting vocal play and exploration, and the appropriateness of singing tasks assigned to children. Chapter 17, by Gary McPherson and Jane Davidson, provides an overview of studies examining the key influences on instrumental playing, and includes a useful table summarising age-related learning principles in formal learning settings. While the authors make some reference to the negative experiences associated with learning an instrument, further consideration of these issues is necessary if we are to understand fully why so many children stop playing. In Chapter 18, Pamela Burnard challenges the idea that creativity develops in age-related phases, arguing that it is influenced and framed by the individual's social and cultural context. To end this section Peter Webster and Maud Hickey document the history of the use of technology – specifically computers – in musical domains, and show how it can help advance our understanding of musical development in children and adolescents.
The final section of the book examines music in five different contexts. In Chapter 20, ‘Historical perspectives’, Gordon Cox provides an overview of music education from mediaeval English song schools through instrumental instruction in 18th century Britain and school music teaching in late 19th century Europe to musical childhoods in the 20th century. Patricia Shehan Campbell, in Chapter 21, ‘Global practices’, discusses the roles of music in different societies and describes how children acquire musical knowledge in different environments. Focusing on children and music in Ireland, Japan, the Philippines, Thailand, North American First Nations, West Africa and East Africa, she concludes that it is essential to explore children's musical engagement cross-culturally if we are to deepen our understanding of children's musical development. Robert Walker then looks at the musical practices, beliefs and behaviours of a variety of cultures, and highlights some of the problems associated with defining terms such as ‘music’, ‘musical development’ and ‘musical ability’. Chapter 23, by Susan O'Neill, provides a new approach to looking at young people's musical engagement by putting forward the theory of positive youth development: the idea that ‘all young people have the potential and capacity for healthy growth and development’ (p. 463). The final chapter of the book is by Jane Davidson and Karen Burland and looks at identity formation in musicians as they make the transition from childhood to adulthood.
While this handbook makes a significant overall contribution to the musical development literature, some contributions are inevitably stronger than others – a perennial problem with edited books. Continuity is also an issue; even though there is some cross-referencing from one chapter to another, it is tempting to treat the book as a collection of stand-alone articles. The reader who wishes to read it all the way through must rely on a brief explanation in the preface and the assignment of each chapter to one of the five thematic sections in order to appreciate the structure of the book and its cohesion. This could have been achieved better, perhaps, by providing a longer introduction and a concluding chapter reflecting on the key issues raised. In this way the thematic and developmental progression of the book could have been made more obvious and implicit strands – such as the theme of social musical development, which runs through the whole book – could have been highlighted and discussed in more detail.
The Child as Musician is referred to as a ‘handbook’. As such, ‘key readings’ and suggestions for further recommended reading in addition to the lists of references provided by each author would not have gone amiss for students and researchers new to the field. And despite Campbell's and Walker's chapters on global practices and cultural traditions, respectively, and McPherson's acknowledgement that there is still much to learn from cross-cultural studies, The Child as Musician still focuses mainly on Western musical traditions and formal rather than informal musical contexts.
Despite these shortcomings, The Child as Musician certainly works well as a collection of diverse chapters on musical development, some of which are excellent, providing detailed literature reviews and references to current research. I would recommend it as a resource for both students and researchers in the fields of music psychology and music education in particular, and also to those interested in medical, philosophical, and sociological perspectives. By the editor's own admission, this book does not attempt to address all possible aspects of musical development, but does bring the reader up to date not only with classic but also current international approaches that consider children as musicians.
