From the outset of World War I to the beginning of World War II, the French and British empires in North Africa and the Middle East can best be characterized as intelligence states. In the unequal and at times oppressive regimes of European imperialism, the chief consideration of colonial governments was how to pacify and appease subject populations. Such pacification entailed a comprehensive security policy, one that was predicated upon the gathering of sound information to provide “advance warning of any threat to imperial authority” (p. 2). If the intelligence provided by security services was good, colonial authority could be upheld; if bad or ignored, colonial authority was imperiled. Ultimately, “intelligence and empire were inextricably linked in a symbiotic relationship, the growth of one nourishing the consolidation of the other” (p. 13). This, at any rate, is the argument put forward by Martin Thomas in his exhaustive Empires of Intelligence: Security Services and Colonial Disorder after 1914.
Thomas is well qualified to address such a topic. A reader in colonial history at the University of Exeter, he is the author of three previous books on 20th-century French imperialism and one book on Anglo–French relations in the late 1930s, as well as editor of a volume on the diplomatic consequences of European decolonization. Although Empires of Intelligence is, strictly speaking, his first foray into the British Empire, his research methodology and experience of imperial history is tried and tested.
Empires of Intelligence is divided into an introduction, nine chapters, and a conclusion. His introduction addresses the theoretical problems of intelligence and empire and the processes of state surveillance and control more generally. He shows that in the world of colonial-intelligence collection, imperial governments relied upon a patron–client relationship that, although contingent upon the colonized for cooperation, was “ultimately a system of the rulers and the ruled rather than a genuinely collaborate partnership” (p. 3). Within this system, state surveillance and information gathering of colonial subjects was an outgrowth of larger norms of social classification that came hand in glove with scientific modernism. It was not, in other words, strictly an imperial practice. Nevertheless, it reached its highest stage in the interwar British and French empires because of the added security concerns of dissent and potential outright rebellion. The “intelligence states” that were created in the North African and Middle Eastern colonies were a necessary response to the dwindling ability of imperial governments to use outright force: “Put crudely, the use of unrestricted state violence against colonial civilians was increasingly intolerable to domestic opinion in Britain and France. Greater restraint was called for. In these changed circumstances, intelligence agencies had to ensure that force was targeted efficiently, either to prevent the outbreak of more widespread violence or to ensure that order was restored as quickly as possible” (p. 7).
Chapter 1 offers an account of the types of intelligence employed by colonial authorities between the two world wars (environmental, human, signals, and image) and gives an overview of the structure and methodology of British and French intelligence collection, dissemination, and analysis. Central to this system were imperial police forces, the nature of which changed during the interwar period from indigenous upholders of law and order to active participants in colonial rule. Chapter 2 addresses the past precedents of intelligence use in the colonial order before looking more closely at the specific problems of desert intelligence and wartime developments throughout North Africa and the Middle East. Chapter 3 examines the threat perception of colonial authorities in France's Muslim colonies, particularly French fears of a Pan-Islamic movement and an international Communist plot. Chapter 4 turns from the French Empire to the British, taking an in-depth look at the response of the security services to unrest in Egypt, Iraq, and Sudan in the immediate aftermath of World War I. Chapter 5 mirrors the fourth by comparing and contrasting similar responses in the French holdings of Morocco and Syria.
Chapter 6—the most interesting in this reviewer's opinion—examines the unique challenges of policing bedouin desert communities in southern Syria, Iraq, and Transjordan. Chapter 7 follows with a discussion of the intelligence state in the urban environs of France's Arab territories. The final two chapters offer case studies of the evolution of the intelligence state in the 1930s, looking at the British Mandate in Palestine (Chapter 8) and the various territories of North Africa (Algeria, Tunisia, and Morocco) in the French case (Chapter 9). In these chapters, Thomas concludes that whereas “the outbreak of World War II signaled the end of the intelligence state in Britain's Arab territories,” in the French territories it “marked the transition to the more intensive surveillance and expanded police powers characteristic of the Vichy years” (p. 292). His conclusion reiterates the points made in the introduction before closing with the rather bland sentence that “[t]he central contention of this book has been that the North African and Middle Eastern territories studied here shared a fundamental characteristic: at root, they were intelligence states—shaped by the process of information gathering about the populations they claimed to control” (303).
Thomas's concept of the intelligence state is fascinating as a theoretical proposition. It seems clear, both from the original research Thomas has conducted and from previous studies on empire and intelligence, that information gathering and analysis were central to the maintenance of colonial order. Where Thomas's argument falls short, however, is his implication that these intelligence states were a phenomenon unique to the North African and Middle Eastern colonies in the interwar period. Enough has been written to classify India as an intelligence state according to Thomas's model (in particular post 1858). Recent research has also shown the same for Ireland in the first decades of the 20th century. It is hard to imagine this not to be the case in other colonies outside Thomas's geographic focus. The model put forward in Empires of Intelligence is novel and has great explanatory power. There is no reason why it could not be expanded beyond the scope of this book.
The information contained within Empires of Intelligence is impressive, the research undertaken thorough and complete. Six English-language archives were consulted together with eight French-language archives. The bibliography is comprehensive and the index detailed. Numerous references to the work of other historians demonstrate a deep knowledge and familiarity with the historiography. Access to this notable body of research is, however, somewhat impaired by the clumsy and at times inefficient nature of the prose. For this reviewer's tastes, there was, ultimately, too much theory with not enough narrative to elucidate. Despite this, Empires of Intelligence is an essential work for the scholar of intelligence as well as for British and French imperial historians of the 20th century; it should find its way to the bookshelves of each. Although not always an easy or particularly enjoyable read, it is nonetheless an important and original contribution to the field. For this, Thomas should be applauded.
