Debates about slave rebellion in the Americas have tended to focus on English-speaking regions, Haiti and Brazil, which gives a false impression of the quiescence of the enslaved in Cuba and the rest of the Iberian Atlantic world. In this account of a virtually unknown rebellion that occurred in 1825 in Guamacaro, a coffee-growing region in western Cuba, Manuel Barcia provides an important new contribution to the scholarship. In Cuban history, the two most widely known slave revolts are the Aponte rebellion (1812) and the insurgency and violent repression known as La Escalera (1843–4). These two incidents have received the most scholarly treatment and have led to numerous generalisations about the propensity of the enslaved in Cuba to rebel. Barcia's new book, together with his prior monograph Seeds of Insurrection: Domination and Resistance on Western Cuban Plantations, 1808–1848 (Louisiana State University Press, 2008), makes a compelling case that the enslaved in Cuba were actively contesting their status before, during and after these better-known incidences of revolt and response.
The first in-depth study of the Guamacaro rebellion, drawn primarily from fascinating new research in the Archivo Nacional de Cuba, The Great African Slave Revolt of 1825 suggests important ways to reframe our understanding of rebellion in nineteenth-century Cuba. The author goes against the predominant thinking that links Cuban slave revolt to the inspiration of the Haitian Revolution, rumours of British abolitionism or the pressures of the Spanish American independence wars. While Barcia acknowledges these forces, his account instead argues for the relevance of contemporaneous West African warfare. Indeed, Barcia links the Guamacaro rebellion to others in both Cuba and Brazil between 1820 and 1845, in turn precipitated by wars associated with the collapse of the Oyo kingdom in West Africa and the sale of its veterans into American slavery. Unlike the Aponte and La Escalera movements, which were interwoven with urban networks and entailed significant participation, if not leadership, of free people of colour, this 1825 rebellion was a rural-based affair led by African-born slaves. Neither free people of colour nor urban dwellers were among the plotters, despite the authorities’ (clearly biased) suspicions. As Barcia sees it, the Haitian Revolution did not play a decisive role either. The very fact of enslavement, combined with the presence of charismatic leaders with likely military experience, was enough to catalyse the coordinated actions of approximately 200 insurgents. Barcia makes a compelling case that this event initiated a cycle of ongoing plots and rebellions in western Cuba, led primarily by slaves born in Africa and culminating in the wider-ranging Escalera rebellion almost two decades later. Indeed, it is hard not to see this as one continuous struggle. One of the main ringleaders in Barcia's account, an African-born coachman named Pablo Gangá, was later arrested and executed as an accused leader and ‘sorcerer’ during the events of La Escalera. This crucial finding casts events that historians thought they knew in a fascinating new light.
Barcia contextualises his narrative of the rebellion within the story of ‘the Atlantic colonization of Guamacaro’, a region experiencing rapid demographic and economic change in the early nineteenth century. Recently brought under the cultivation of sugar and coffee, this area was being populated by arrivals from other parts of Cuba, Spain, the United States, England, Ireland and Germany, under a conscious ‘whitening’ policy of the Spanish colonial government. Ironically, as both white authorities and Barcia concur, it was the more relaxed treatment of slaves on the coffee plantations, as opposed to the surrounding ones devoted to sugar, that facilitated the effective organising and implementation of the rebellion. In its aftermath, officials instituted a local slave code which sought to curb the mobility of the enslaved. This code even sought to mandate, for the first time, the construction of barracoons across Cuba to keep the enslaved locked in their quarters at night.
Barcia uses rich source material to demonstrate the importance of African experience to the leadership of the rebellion. For example, drumming and dancing played a central role, plotters spoke West African languages, and they apparently drew upon kin relations to coordinate the rebellion across multiple plantations. On this point, Barcia pushes back against an older historiography of Cuban slave rebellion that tended to overlook the African component and project proto-nationalist motivations back into the early nineteenth century. His interpretation instead has more in common with the work of such scholars as David Barry Gaspar, John Thornton and João José Reis, who have foregrounded African religious, cultural and military experience in their studies of rebellions in other parts of the Americas.
To the extent that it is possible, given the limitations of existing sources, a more specific mapping of particular ‘African’ cultural practices, combined with somewhat more demographic data on the population of African descent in Guamacaro and its environs, would have further strengthened Barcia's argument. Additionally, and perhaps for understandable reasons, the intensity of Barcia's stated historiographic commitment to demonstrating that this revolt represented ‘an extension of West African warfare in a New World setting’ may at times risk short-changing the complexity of his own riveting account. As he demonstrates, enslaved individuals of the same ethnic group as the leaders not only joined the rebellion but also informed on it. Some even put their own bodies between those of armed rebels and their white masters and mistresses in order to prevent the latter's murder. As Barcia points out, one of the key plotters was not African-born but a creole slave, and another leader, Pedro Lucumí, was a coachman described as having somewhat higher status. Reducing these individuals solely to creole versus African ethnic labels would essentialise their identities of origin, or at least flatten the complex and dynamic social worlds that framed their actions. Indeed, Barcia's important new book provides a tantalising window on events previously unknown.
The Great African Slave Revolt of 1825 marks an exciting advance in our understanding of the cycle of rebellions affecting Cuba and the broader Atlantic world during the Age of Revolutions. All studies of the era, of African diaspora and of Cuban history will need to reckon with its significant new findings.
