In this extensive work, Taylor-Gooby rejects the idea of a crisis of the welfare state and instead offers a plausible and coherent account of how the notion of social citizenship has been reframed as politicians and policymakers have mapped a particular path when responding to the challenges of the late modern era. A central argument of the book is that the essentially social democratic values that underpinned social citizenship, as the classic welfare state developed in the decades following the Second World War, have been undermined and replaced by a different set of values that prioritise individual rather than collective responsibility for welfare. A new world of welfare has emerged, one in which economic efficiency and value for money dominate above and beyond more vertically redistributive mechanisms designed to meet the needs of vulnerable citizens. In offering a critical assessment of this ongoing reconfiguration of social citizenship, the book focuses on what Taylor-Gooby refers to as the ‘second order pressures’ on welfare states that emerge from the welfare policies enacted in response to social, political and economic changes, such as an ageing population, changing gender roles, globalisation and the demands of a more ethnically diverse and less deferential citizenry. The central elements of each of these challenges and the implications that they have for social citizenship are outlined and discussed in a scholarly and comprehensive manner throughout part 1 of the book, and I would happily recommend these chapters to any capable third year undergraduate or postgraduate student who is seeking an informed discussion of the social changes contemporary governments need to take into account as they engage in the process of welfare reform.
From the outset Taylor-Gooby highlights two themes that he believes are central to the ongoing process of welfare reform. First, he argues that a new public management approach – which looks to bring the discipline of the market to collectivised systems of public welfare (by championing competition and choice) – dominates governments’ thinking in relation to the delivery of welfare. Second, at the level of the individual citizen, he notes that the responsibility for meeting welfare needs has been increasingly transferred from the state to the individual. Allied to this, Taylor-Gooby detects less of a willingness among the general citizenry to collectively support those in poverty. This is related to the comforting belief, prevalent among many within what has become, overall, a more affluent and assertive population that poverty is largely the outcome of irresponsible, individual behaviour rather than circumstances beyond the control of individuals. More and more, only those citizens who are willing to actively engage in self improvement and make the right rational choices are deemed worthy of support.
Three key values – that is reciprocity, inclusion and trust – are identified in the book as central to social citizenship. ‘Reciprocity concerns willingness to support horizontal redistribution between groups among the mass of the population . . . inclusion is the acceptance of vertical redistribution between the mass of the population . . . The third component . . . [i.e. trust] operates in a different way. Rather than legitimising particular directions of redistribution it nourishes the legitimacy of the system as a whole. Trust in this context is the belief that the “services and provisions that make up the welfare state will actually work when you need them”’ (pp. 5–6). In his exploration of the ways in which each of these three key values may be sustained or undermined as a new kind of social citizenship unfolds, Taylor-Gooby draws on a wide range of academic disciplines and a multitude of studies. Overall, he constructs a cohesive and persuasive set of arguments. However, I must admit that I struggled to accept some of the insights that are drawn from psychology in his attempt to make a convincing case for ‘bridging the gap between individual rationality and the development of a norm of reciprocity that facilitates cooperative behaviour in society’ (p. 75). On reflection, I suspect that my reticence to buy into such arguments has more to do with my own limited views about the value of psychological explanations within social policy settings. Indeed, on a personal level, one positive spin off from reviewing this book is the fact that it has challenged me to think again about what the discipline of psychology might offer as I attempt to understand the ongoing processes of inclusion and exclusion that are an inherent part of citizenship.
Part 3 of the book offers a worked through case study of reframed social citizenship via a detailed discussion of UK welfare reform. Chapter 7, which contains a detailed critical discussion of New Labour's welfare project, provides the backdrop for Chapters 8 and 9 where the reforms of the British National Health Service (NHS), and citizens’ experiences of them, are described as ‘an exemplar of the impact of the new policy agenda in the welfare state’ (p. 158). I particularly enjoyed the second of these two chapters as it presents original qualitative data from a study into public perceptions about the values that should underpin the NHS and also the authors’ views about the positive aspects (a broad commitment to a publically financed universal service) and the more negative managerialist aspects (target driven agendas, a preoccupation with extending choice) of the healthcare reforms enacted by the New Labour administrations.
Overall, I find it hard to disagree with Taylor-Gooby's main conclusion that ‘the individual rational actor welfare state’ which now predominates is ‘weakened in the resilience and scope of reciprocity, the reach of social inclusion and the vitality of public trust (p. 186). This is an excellent book that should be read by all those who are interested in how the drive to deliver more individualised and efficient public welfare undermines the vertical redistribution and collective commitment that more substantive notions of social citizenship require.
