This is a fine collection of essays demonstrating that Populism remains a vital field for historical study. These essays focus on the Populist movement in the southern states and, as suggested by the title, indicate new avenues of investigation and the potential for new frameworks and methods of research.
Until recently, the study of labor and urban Populism has mainly focussed on the Mid-west and Rocky Mountain states to the neglect of the South. But three excellent essays in this collection suggest that that is no longer the case. Alicia Rodriguez breaks new ground with her essay on the part played by urban labor organizations in the formation of the People's Party in Dallas, Texas. Matthew Hild's study of the political activity of the Knights of Labor in Georgia explains how labor facilitated Populist politics. And Michael Pierce's essay on the Georgia Populist leader Tom Watson's attitude towards organized labor in the Mid-west suggests just how fraught were the Populist efforts at a farmer–labor alliance in the South and nationally.
Several of the essays revisit the more familiar territory of the racial dimensions of Populism in the South. Joel Sipress offers a case study on the local overtures of white Populists to black voters in Grant Parish, Louisiana, posing provocative questions about the meaning of such overtures. Lewie Reece explores the particular racial obstacles to Populist coalitions in the Deep South states. In his treatment of Populist thinking about debt in North Carolina, David Silkenat draws striking insights about the distinctions between black and white agrarians. In terms of innovative use of sources, the most impressive essay is James Beeby's study of the decline of Populism and African American disfranchisement in North Carolina based on the use of court records from contested-election testimony. Meanwhile, Omar Ali, in an essay that is more of a historiographical manifesto than new research, makes his case for a new analytical framework with his contention that black Populism represented a significant yet mainly ignored African American political tradition.
Most of the essays in the collection are either local or state case studies, and in that regard follow in the best traditions of recent generations of Populist research. Much of the scholarship of the 1970s and 1980s focussed on what was distinctive about Populism in the given locale, state, or region: piedmont versus tidewater, Texas versus Nebraska, South versus West. Along similar lines, Jared Roll's essay on the Populist legacy argues that southern Populist ideology embodied “a particularly southern agrarian tradition” (202). This gave rise in the early twentieth century to a mainly white southern socialism and to a southern Garveyist movement of African American uplift in specific rural places such as the lowlands of southeastern Missouri. But the essay raises more questions than it answers about what was ideologically specific and southern about these socialists and Graveyists. More generally, it stresses the notion of a distinctly southern Populism without explaining what that might mean. The other essays in the collection mainly avoid the issues of local or regional particularism. Given the emphasis placed on these questions in earlier studies, perhaps more attention should have been given to revisiting the earlier claims, and evaluating what they add or subtract from historical understanding.
The essays all have the mark of expert historians, who have done a good job framing intriguing questions. It should be noted that some of the authors in this volume have recently published monographs that cover similar material. Nonetheless, readers may appreciate this collection as an introduction to these authors and to other dimensions of their work. The writing quality meets a high standard throughout. The essays tend to be written in clear, accessible, and effective language. The book will be of special value to readers interested in late nineteenth-century race relations, farmer and labor reform movements, and the extraordinary Populist moment that continues to attract the attention of scholars and the public alike.
