No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 November 2004
This monograph is a well-researched study of the Mudejar community in Xàtiva, a town south of Valencia in the Crown of Aragón during the unsettling and transitional decades of the 13th and early 14th centuries. O'Connor's thesis is evident in the title, for very little detailed work has been done to date on this particular Muslim community on the frontier between the Islamic Kingdom of Granada (all that remained of al-Andalus) and newly conquered Christian territory. She justifies the dates of her study based on “the [Mudejar] community's evolution and its response to acculturation” (p. 2).
In a preliminary chapter, O'Connor gives detailed historiographical background into Mudejarism and Arabic studies in Spain, including discussions of the long-standing debates between Castro and Sánchez Albornoz and between Robert Burns and Pierre Guichard. In addition, she describes the evolution of Mudejar studies, which shifted over time from an emphasis on Christian tolerance, largely for financial and tax incentives, to issues of minority studies, discrimination, and segregation of the Muslim communities throughout the later medieval Christian Mediterranean world.
In earlier chapters, O'Connor contributes to the debate over when the Christian conquest of Xàtiva actually occurred (preferring the earlier date of 1244 to 1248 or 1249). She writes that the situation for the Mudejars was almost unchanged for a number of years after the initial conquest because of an ongoing Mudejar revolt in the kingdom of Valencia that kept King Jaume I preoccupied with military matters rather than with the Xàtivan surrender treaty (carta-puebla) or the accompanying efforts to attract Christian settlers to newly conquered territories vacated by Muslims emigrating to Islamic lands, whether Granada or North Africa.
The author also deals with the internal organization of the aljama in Xàtiva, including such issues as the local and regional economy, aspects of taxation, and legal and judicial matters. She argues that the Mudejars have traditionally been portrayed by historians “as a group of poor farmers and artisans who lived in the same town all their lives and who had a difficult time surviving economically” (p. 80). She suggests that this view needs to be revised, noting that the Mudejars were a valuable economic resource to the Christian king, the Catholic church, the nobility, and even to the Christian settlers who owned the fields and farms where the Mudejars worked. Nevertheless, the Mudejars had to be constantly vigilant to increasing restrictions and loss of rights and privileges originally granted to them, and O'Connor cites multiple documents from the Christian archives (the only documents available for studying these Muslim communities) that describe the growing legal and religious curtailment of Mudejar activities in Xàtiva throughout the early 14th century.
Also included in the monograph are topics of resistance or of acculturation to an increasingly organized and confrontational Christian community. O'Connor discusses how, with the solidification of the Christian presence in Xàtiva and the rest of the kingdom of Valencia by the early 14th century, Mudejar officials in the aljama gradually lost power in legal, religious, and economic aspects of the community. During this period, the Christian population was growing, and the Mudejar population was decreasing because of emigration and increasing political and social pressures exerted on the Muslim community in Xàtiva. Christian officials were increasingly involved in the activities of the Mudejar community for several reasons: the substantial revenues and taxes generated by the Mudejar legal system; the considerable trade the aljama merchants carried out with the Islamic kingdom of Granada as well as with other areas in the Crown of Aragón; and the long-standing fears of Islamic religious contamination and revolt. O'Connor states that by the early 14th century, for example, Christians had greatly increased their intervention in Mudejar criminal cases, which were supposed to be subject to Islamic law, with the result that Mudejars at times appealed to the king when Christian officials became too involved in such affairs. However, she also mentions that such involvement could at times work to the advantage of the Mudejars and cites several examples from the early 14th century. Such an approach substantiates O'Connor's thesis that the Mudejar community of Xàtiva remained flexible in such troubled times as the decades examined in this monograph and that the community adapted and adjusted to changing circumstances to the best of its ability. Nevertheless, the trends of depopulation and growing economic dependence on the Christian community gradually lessened the freedom of action of the Mudejars in all spheres of life in the aljama of Xàtiva.
The work is intended for graduate student and professional academic use. The author relies very heavily on the primary source material and at times does not offer a great deal of analysis of the documents. Although she has produced an extensively researched study, O'Connor makes observations throughout the monograph that leave the reader hoping for a more complete explanation in a more detailed study in the future.
Finally, the monograph needs more detailed regional maps. The map provided at the beginning of the work does not include many of the small towns and regions mentioned is the study.