This superb, slender and elegant volume is a kind of study that is much-needed in the field of monetary history. Numismatic evidence is often shunned by historians who feel ill-equipped to engage with it, while numismatists occasionally engage in insular debates that lose sight of wider relevance. In the era of the Oxford Symposia on Coinage in Monetary History, which provided forums for interdisciplinary discussions, Professor Michael Metcalf characterised the problem thus: “Many numismatists have in the past verged towards antiquarianism; and historians have sometimes felt nervous about exposing their numismatic inexperience in the face of what they imagined to be an impenetrable craft mystery”.Footnote 1 Increased cooperation has marked numismatic scholarship over the past quarter of a century. Jere L. Bacharach's study belongs to this tradition and advances further, advocating the usefulness of numismatic evidence to historians who are unacquainted with it. His study provides an innovative and accessible approach to the value and use of numismatic material for Islamic history. This achievement was recognised by the award of the Samir Shamma Prize for Islamic Numismatics of the Royal Numismatic Society in 2007.
An underlying problem for appreciating the value of pre-modern numismatic material for historical scholarship is that coins are perceived as prosaic material artefacts. In fact coins are an exceptional form of evidence. Coins were mass-produced – or, more properly, batch produced – under the direct authority of the state and remain largely impervious to taphonomic processes. As intrinsically valuable objects, coins that survive have done so by chance and represent a sample of the vast numbers once in existence. The function of coinage was to provide a convenient means of exchange. It was usual for a state to act as the provider and guarantor of that means of exchange, through the provision and supervision of mints, hence coins are a securely dated source for political information. The diplomatic formulae that appear on coins can be analysed alongside other information such as the name of the issuing mint and date. This is the thrust of Bacharach's book, which examines the use or appearance of a wide variety of names (birth names, teknonyms, patronyms) and honorific titles on Ikhshidid coinage for political history. The study also examines the names and titles on Ikhshidid coinage in the context of those found on other surviving artefacts. Other methodologies are also impressively employed; among a diverse range are, for example, analysis through die links (pp. 31–33) and examination of the metallurgical composition of alloys (pp. 45–54).
The relative brevity of the Ikhshidid dynasty (ah 323–358/ce 935–969) allows the study and its conclusions to be focused and for the wider theme of the usefulness of coins for Islamic history to predominate. The Ikhshidid numismatic corpus is not overwhelming and unmanageable – an occurrence that can distress even the most seasoned numismatist – and the book is evenly divided into two separate parts. Part One presents the analysis Ikhshidid numismatic material; Part Two is a catalogue.
The analysis in Part One runs to just over one hundred pages. It is highly readable and written and structured in an approachable style: endnotes are used instead of footnotes and illustrations are provided in-text rather than as separate plates. There are four sections of analysis: “On Coinage”; “Coinage from the Reign of Muhammad ibn Tughj al-Ikhshid”; “Post Muhammad ibn Tughj Coinage”; “Conclusion”. Following the fourth section and concluding the first half of the book there are two appendices and a glossary containing numismatic terms and Islamic names and titles.
The second part of the book is a catalogue of Ikhshidid numismatic material. The arrangement is intelligently presented to aid the non-specialist reader interested in the analysis presented in the first part of the book. The standard coins types are transcribed and illustrated (pp. 110–117), a principal section that has a marginal device so that the reader can easily locate it at any time by looking at the fore edge of the book. It is possible that a collector of Ikhshidid coins would be disappointed by the lack of illustrative plates, but the general reader will not face a daunting and confusing array of illustrations. Thereafter are the detailed catalogues of numismatic material, which are precise citations of individual specimens in institutional and private collections. The book concludes with a useful index.
Bacharach aims his analysis of the usefulness of coins for Islamic history at non-specialists. He begins with first principles, offering an overview of the how medieval coins were made. He observes, quite correctly, that “numismatists assume that their colleagues in other fields know how coins are made” (p. 10). As already stated, individuals actively engaged in numismatic research sometimes fail to remember how opaque structural and analytical work on coins can appear to those unfamiliar with the approaches. More subtly, throughout there is a gentle prodding of the technical terminology used by numismatists. For example, he states “presentation piece is a catchall for all other numismatic evidence” (p. 91) and “numismatists have never fully agreed what constitutes a coin type” (p. 107). It is precisely the combination of technicality and ambiguity that non-numismatists are likely to find disconcerting and frustrating. Thus, although Bacharach uses numismatic parlance he directly draws attention to the ambiguities that prevail; his willingness to be so candid is refreshing and to be commended.
The book is well-illustrated throughout with coins, tables, a graph, and a genealogical table of the Ikhshidid family. The in-text illustrations of coins are high-quality black and white images with an accompanying caption. Some illustrations show coins enlarged but without an indication of the actual diameter of the coins. For example, Byzantine gold solidus of Constantine VII Porphyrogenitus (Fig. 2.7) is shown twice actual size. It is somewhat disappointing that the book does not contain any maps. As one of the more ephemeral Islamic dynasties, a map of the Ikhshidid state and the location of its mints would have been useful, especially because the location of mints is unquestionably a topographical matter. A map of the region would also have been useful given that standard Ikhshidid coinage affected by political events in the 'Abbasid Caliphate and irregular Ikhshidid coinage with human representations was inspired by Byzantine models.
The final “Coda” in Part One speculates about a scholar in the far future encountering twenty-first century coinage, in particular the one dollar coins minted in the United States of America. In doing so, questions are raised about correspondence of the study to other coinages. The approach presented by Bacharach could be applied to the majority of Islamic coinages of the first millennium ah, after the reforms of 'Abd al-Malik which introduced epigraphic designs. Such coins have on them diplomatic formulae, which are the centrepiece of Bacharach's study of Ikhshidid coinage, the year of issue and the location of the issuing mint. The inclusion of a year date according to an era (anno Higirae) is not found on contemporaneous coinages from the non-Islamic world.
Islamic History from Coins states a clear argument for regarding Islamic coins as a major primary source for political history through an excellent case study on Ikhshidid coinage. To a certain extent it is sui generis, providing a precise study of numismatics for a particular branch of historical scholarship, rather than making the case for the value of numismatic material in general. The title of the book is very exact and defines the particular analysis presented. Contemporary historians of medieval Islamic states will find much food for thought in the pages of Bacharach's study, which may encourage them to consider numismatic evidence as directly relevant to their own fields of study. This book should also be read by numismatists dealing with pre-modern coinages, whatever their specialist field. More studies of the nature of Bacharach's will demystify numismatics for contemporary historians. Numismatics has in the past been called an “auxiliary science”, a label that suggests an opaque subject with little relevance; Bacharach's study demonstrates that it is not.
