In this book Daniel Marković goes against the grain of recent scholarship and argues that, rather than being unorthodox or from non-Epicurean sources, much of Lucretius’ rhetorical and argumentative strategy can be traced to the influence of Epicurus himself. This is a brave and worthwhile undertaking but quite difficult given the fragmentary nature of what is generally agreed (since David Sedley's Lucretius and the Transformation of Greek Wisdom (1998)) to have been Lucretius’ main Epicurean model, the first fifteen books of Epicurus’ On Nature. Accordingly, in ch. 1 M. looks more broadly around Epicurus at Hellenistic education and Epicurean educational theory and practice. Epicurus rejected the traditional syllabus based heavily on Homer as unnecessary, or even harmful, but Epicurean practice was in some ways similar, also stressing memorization and passive internalization, but of Epicurus rather than the Iliad. The section here on Lucretius as a teacher seems oddly one-sided; it is clear that M. wants to concentrate on factors beyond the well-studied didactic tradition of the pupil-teacher constellation but it would be helpful if that tradition was outlined here so that it could be established more clearly what features of Lucretius’ teaching persona and teaching style owe more to the influence of the Epicurean school, or to Roman education than to the influence of, say, Hesiod or Empedocles.
Ch. 2 is concerned with, ‘how the structure of the poem is connected with its content and purpose’ (51). M. seeks to show that aspects such as the addressee Memmius’ tendency to want to participate in a dialogue with the teacher rather than being an entirely passive recipient of his instruction is influenced by the philosophical tradition, especially by Epicurus. M. first looks at the poem as a whole and its cyclical structure, and then goes on to look at the structures of individual books. He argues that both DRN and Epicurus’ On Nature are formally organized as lectures: Lucretius’ distinctive proems, repetitions, and formulae have their counterparts in Epicurus, where they are part of his technique of instruction. Lucretius has achieved a synthesis of Homeric epic and Epicurus’ works. This is an intriguing and tempting argument but to be really persuasive needs far more extensive examination of On Nature than appears here. Mentioned briefly are Epicurus’ addresses to Metrodorus in his lectures (55), but more could be made of them to support M.'s argument: making allowance for the differences in the dramatic settings of the instructions (i.e. one to one tutorial vs. lecture hall presentation), one could argue that Epicurus is highly Lucretian in the different positions he takes with respect to Metrodorus and his audience.
The third and longest chapter is again rather speculative. M. seeks to establish that Lucretius’ modes of argument are essentially Epicurean, and he analyses the different types of argument according to Cicero's categories in the Topica, which may be reasonable enough, but also argues that his use of analogy is influenced by Epicurus: ‘Lucretius’ poetics reflects Epicurus’ methodology: it offers explanations of what is invisible by presenting what is visible’ (85). This is more problematic. As David Sedley has said (ibid., 107): ‘[In On Nature] physical theses are defended by regular appeal to the usual Epicurean requirement that they be “consistent with” or “uncontested by” phenomena, but there is no sign of Epicurus focusing his audience's minds, as Lucretius would have done, on familiar examples of analogous phenomena.’ Lucretius’ use of analogy, then, is not ‘Epicurean’ in the sense that it follows Epicurus’ usage, but only in that it is a peculiarly apposite mode of argument for a system that insists on the truth of all sense perceptions while, paradoxically, basing the foundations of reality upon an invisible atomic world. It is, really, quite difficult to reconcile Lucretian practice with Epicurean theory. M.'s book has had the misfortune of appearing at about the same time as Myrto Garani's authoritative Empedocles Redivivus: Poetry and Analogy in Lucretius (2007). Garani studies Lucretius’ debt to Empedocles’ analogical methods of argument in great depth and detail, arguing persuasively that Empedocles is Lucretius’ main source for his use of simile, metaphor and personification.
This is not to say that M. is ‘wrong’ in any of his assertions or analyses, but such a radical reinterpretation of Lucretius’ influences would benefit from a much longer and more thorough treatment than the small scale of this present volume allows.
