Ahmad Riza Khan Barelwi (1856–1921) was a reformist Indian Muslim scholar, prominent among the leaders of Islamic renewal in British India. He played a key role in debates about the spiritual life of the Muslim community and the true path for the Muslims to follow to preserve their faith and moral integrity under British rule in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. He is remembered with great reverence by members of the movement of Ahl-i Sunna wa Jamaעa, which he founded to support the close adherence of Indian Muslims to the Prophet's practice. The movement is better known in popular terminology among outsiders as Barelwi after the founder and his hometown of Bareilly.
In this short biography Usha Sanyal offers an engaging portrait of one of the most influential South Asian Muslims of modern times. In so doing, she makes accessible to a wider readership, and in an updated form, the benefits of her previous valuable research presented in Devotional Islam and Politics in British India: Ahmad Riza Khan Barelwi and His Movement, 1870–1920 (1996).
Sanyal observes that, while other reformers of the period also stressed the importance of the Prophet's Sunna, they commonly rejected Sufism in whole or in part, especially its focus on saintly intercession and miracles. Barelwi, by contrast, gave his support to the mystical, ritualistic approach to the faith represented in the Sufi shrine-based practice of South Asia. However, contrary to widespread supposition, Sanyal argues that Barelwi and his followers were not to be identified with support for certain features of the unreformed practices widely accepted among the rural population, such as large gatherings for qawwali singing. Instead, Barelwi advocated recital of the Qurءan and of poetry honoring the Prophet. He wanted his movement to be one of reformed traditionalists, keeping strictly within the bounds of the shariעa, emulating and venerating the Prophet with care. Sanyal contends that Barelwi's followers were actually an elitist minority of some thousands, or possibly tens of thousands, in the late 19th century, who may have had a significant influence in the countryside. However, it is not possible to determine with any accuracy the extent of this influence.
In chapter 1 Sanyal offers the reader a concise, clear account of Indian history in the 18th and 19th centuries. This is especially useful for her insights into contesting British visions for the moral and intellectual development of Indians and British views on the role of law and education for achieving their goals for the Muslim population. Chapter 2 then provides an overview of the Muslim leaders of reform and their movements in British India. This is a well-presented synthesis of current scholarship, which is helpful in establishing the spiritual, intellectual, and social environment within which Barelwi operated. Although this background is beneficial in enabling the reader to gain an understanding of the broader framework of Islamic reform in South Asia at this time, it does leave only approximately sixty pages for the core topic of the book, the life and work of Ahmad Riza Khan Barelwi. This is, nevertheless, a very readable short account, based largely on Barelwi's own writings and those of his followers. Sanyal presents a sensitive and perceptive discussion of a Muslim leader devoted to building a purified and faithful community, able to survive the difficulties of occupation by the British. There is a short discussion of the Ahl-i Sunna movement in Barelwi's lifetime and a brief note of his legacy, observing the presence of Barelwis among South Asian Muslims in the diaspora, particularly in Britain in the early 1990s. Given the importance of the movement among British Muslims, it would have been useful to have had fuller coverage here. Overall, the book offers a valuable introduction for students to one of the major Muslim reformers of British India.
