Roxanne Varzi's Warring Souls is an examination of postrevolutionary Iran, secular urban youth, film, and social space. Although the “culture of martyrdom,” “war culture,” and “public Islamic culture” constitute the objects of her analysis, culture is not a concept upon which the author elaborates. By culture she seems to mean both ideology and habitus, the mystifying forces that attempt to convince people to do and believe in ways not of their making or not to their benefit. The term also stands in for the collage of discursive, material, and visual production that was such a mainstay of Khomeini's revolutionary Islamist project. Posters of the valorized martyred Basij, Shiءi religious themes, and dress codes are part of what this Islamic nation as “image machine” (p. 26) and “discursive construct” (p. 34) produced. As we learn from this book, however, they were not enough to fully embed ideology into the belief and “experience” of all Iranians.
The goals of this ambitious book are multiple: it is a journey “through different moments and themes in post revolution Islamic Iran to look at how the Islamic republic was constructed, sustained, consumed and transformed” (p. 5); a demonstration of “how a visual world was created, consumed, and dismantled”; and an exploration of how “images worked to create a state of martyrdom and ultimately a religious state” (p. 6). Using personal writings and long-term discussion groups with Iranian youth, Varzi aims to show “how the government attempted to use a strong Islamic public sphere to turn youthful subjects into Islamic objects” (p. 7), to show “how people occupy the same strict ideological space and yet live in completely different realities,” and to understand how secular youth in Tehran as “individuals experienced their realities” (p. 12).
The book begins with a discussion of how the image, especially that of Khomeini, was “an actual actor on the political stage” (p. 24). The rich descriptions in Warring Souls prompt questions about what kind of historical moments or political contexts are those in which images bear greater political weight. Do violent situations, or existentially crucial periods, tend to, or need to, rely more heavily on visual representations, explicitly politicized emotion, or reorganization of the visual status quo? The pictures of the dead framed as the missing after 9/11, the nonexistent images of coffins and bloody soldiers during the U.S. war on Iraq, graphic television news from Vietnam, the martyr posters in Lebanon and Palestine, massacre photos in Thailand, and war documentaries in Iran seem to suggest that it might be so. However, when one contends that “real change occurs” at the level of “inner identity” (p. 206), what exactly could it mean to say that “power is bound by its visibility” (p. 108)?
In Varzi's rendition of Iranian history, Khomeini was the mystical guide of the Iranian people, who, in the beginning chapters, are somewhat sidelined in favor of excursus on mysticism and early Persian writing. Khomeini was the romantic myth maker who lured the people after him “to the world of image and sign” (p. 37). Through the glorification of martyrdom came the “ultimate union of citizen and nation, lover and beloved, and servant of God and God” (p. 47). Chapter 2 renders the Basij through a fictionalized amalgamation of the ethnographer's imagination, observation, and historical fact. In her philosophical exploration of martyrdom, Varzi relies on Kojève's reading of Hegel. Without a discussion of the intentional politics and myriad contingencies that shaped the revolution and people's choices to be involved or flee, however, it is difficult to understand fully this widespread social dynamic.
This book is replete with alluring statements that leave the reader wishing for a more sustained exploration of the author's intriguing ideas. State cultural producers during the revolution, Varzi writes, for example, focused on self-annihilation and martyrdom as “a precursor to Islamic citizenship” (p. 6). This could have led to a discussion of the meaning of “citizenship,” a concept often assumed to be tied to conventional liberal democratic philosophies. It also could have inspired an examination of the practical possibilities of a policy that is dependent upon large-scale self-sacrifice, and what role it played in spreading the pervasive political apathy, cynicism, and desperation of today's Iranian youth.
Warring Souls also experiments with allegory and poetry. However, when Varzi asks, “How can anthropology be more exact than divination or anything but another kind of mourning?” (p. 2) one wonders if style might not be interfering with scholarship. Varzi, who incorporates fictional accounts into her experimental ethnography, argues that she does not want to make authoritative claims on reality (p. 16). Although it is important to recognize the power of academic knowledge production, and it is of course necessary to protect informants' identities, it is also dangerous to reduce anthropology to little more than magic and emotion. Relinquishing claims on the special kind of knowledge that anthropologists have access to by virtue of their methodologies and, yes, even their authority to write reliably about people, places, and the social systems in which they are organized, would seem to be, as many scholars after the “postmodern” turn have argued, the surest way of surrendering anthropology to political and pedagogical irrelevance, if not public and academic derision.
However, when the author settles in to describing the consternation and contradictions that trap the upper-middle-class youth who are her subjects, the reader can glean a great deal about the fault lines of the republic's power. After a lengthy discussion of an important documentary on the Iran–Iraq War, in which we are asked if war is not “the ultimate storyboard” (p. 92), Varzi turns to the experience of social Islamic space. Based on questionnaires, Varzi concludes that Tehran youth see themselves as “part of the objective space not as individuals but as fellow citizens” (p. 113).
However, social space saturated with state and Islamic meaning can also be rewritten. (It is unfortunate, by the way, that a more eagle-eyed proofreader did not rewrite parts of this text, especially the sometimes discombobulating footnotes, and remedy the spelling and editorial mistakes.) We see how state propaganda is ignored, strict rules of decorum are side stepped and ridiculed, ideology is eschewed, and fast cars are used to transgress. The identity crisis that youth experience is also part of the state's crisis of legitimacy. One might wonder whether these “weapons of the ‘weak”’ wielded by this privileged class could blossom into political energies beyond the calls for “freedom” and “referendum” that briefly echoed throughout the student protests in 2003, for example. What is the relationship between these advantaged youths' attitudes of disaffection, the 40 percent poverty rate, sharply declining voter turnout, and conservatives' victories over reformists? Although explicit political questions are not considered as much as some might like, in Varzi's explorations of how “youths have come to counter the state-produced ‘real’ by participating in a double existence,” there is a fascinating puzzle of the relationship between subjectivity, class, ideology, belief, and behavior (p. 142).
