I came to read this book as part of my research on the spatialisation project of the European Union, a key aspect of which is the extent to which territory and space have made an incursion into constitutional law-making, and the possible practical effect of this in terms of the legal construction of an idea of a single European territory. Whilst providing lots of stimulating material for this project, the geographical scope and intellectual breadth of Spatializing Law caused me to think more critically about my project, in particular how it represents a binary (law and geography) approach which has hitherto glossed over the complexities and pluralistic nature of law from a spatial perspective. I am very pleased to have read the book for this alone. But additionally, the book took me straight back to the roots of my interest in ‘law and geography’ scholarship and made me assess the development and limitations of this ‘movement’ anew, especially the added value of an anthropological perspective.
Spatializing Law is a critical and welcome response to the ‘traditional’ (if it is old enough to be seen as traditional) ‘law and geography’ approach to thinking about space and place in law, which has made strides in the identification and use of spatial metaphors ‘to characterise social spaces in order to delineate the places where law is being made and put into practice’ (p. 2). The contribution made by this book is to offer a series of interwoven interdisciplinary connections – a type of 3D intellectual screen – between law, geography and anthropology. The ‘extra dimension’ of anthropology is vitally important to the subject matter of the book. Whereas, the editors say, ‘most work in the geography of law and in legal studies has mainly focused on law and space in the context of state law in industrialized states in Europe and America, with an urban bias’ (p. 4) – a fair enough critique:
‘most people live under plural legal constellations…they negotiate one set of rules relating to personal law, such as customary law, with another such as religious or international human rights law (reflecting a more transnational dimension) along with state law that also reflects a degree of heterogeneity.’ (p. 4)
For this reason, the editors argue, ‘legal pluralism deserves a central position in the analysis of law in space’ (p. 4), particularly because under such conditions of legal pluralism, we see a complex overlap of different spaces, ‘imbued with different political and economic, moral or religious meaning’ (p. 7) and carrying with them ‘diverging claims to legitimacy, political and economic authority’ (p. 7). In practice, such divergent claims can lead to serious conflict, especially in the case of colonial and post-colonial political organisation (p. 7).
As a consequence, the chapters in the book are wonderfully diverse (in terms of space and time), covering peasant communities and land reform in Peru, refugees and citizenship in Bhutan, fisheries and natural resource management in Canada, land claims in Indonesia, the working of the international criminal court in Sierra Leone, the spatial design of courts for children in Scotland, and the regulation of commodity exchange in ancient Southern Africa. The chapters are bound together by a perceptive and interesting ‘way in’ to the subject by the editors and a concluding inquiry into mapping law.
With so much ground to be covered, the editors pick out carefully the themes of the book, starting with the use of space as a form of governance, particularly as a means of controlling people and resources. Such control is exercised not just by the state, but also through the formation of communities premised on various forms of exclusion and the construction of otherness (p. 9), often at odds with a more individualised and modern grid of legal understanding about space (‘abstract space’; p. 10). The strength of the book in this context is the anthropological insights into the complexities of such arrangements, in which ethnicity, culture and histories of communities, tribes and peoples are held up alongside social and economic factors in the organisation and control of land. Exactly how the ‘lived space’ as experienced by people in their daily lives comes into contact with the ‘abstract space’ created and imposed by the state is first seen in this book in the context of Peruvian peasant communities and the process of land distribution under the hacienda system, which relies upon the taking of land into private ownership and, consequently, the labour of subsistence farmers. Here, Monique Nuitjen and David Lorenzo Rodriquez remark upon the complexities of overlapping claims and the divisions and conflicts which arose as a result in the communities, with a focus upon territoriality as a controlling mechanism, including by the creation of land scarcity (p. 34), and the resultant struggle for territorial autonomy. They take in particular the story of the Usibamba community, several members of which broke the mechanisms of domination through asserting their legal rights of property ownership, only to then take control of the local community. This common state of affairs was finally dismantled in Usibamba, with its conversion – or ‘complete restructuring’ into a ‘model community’ (p. 43), but not without severe internal conflict in the area. In their clear presentation and precise analysis of the Usibamba, Nuitjen and Rodriguez provide a model for the use of the case-study.
Also working within the broad theme of control through space, Richard Whitecross writes on the promotion of Bhutanese citizenship through law, and presents as problematic the combining of political will to construct a particular vision of the nation with the creation of spaces which allow some to gain recognition as citizens but not others, all against a background of porous physical borders and fear of encroachment by more powerful neighbours. Importantly, ‘citizenship laws have been used in a variety of ways to create a range of frameworks for the exercise of power and control’ (p. 58), and are related to rights of access to land and other resources. Such laws have impacted heavily upon the Lhotshampa, or ‘people of the southern border’ (p. 57), due to a perception of their associations with ‘anti-nationals’. In this setting, citizenship laws have created an uneasy, and arguably discriminatory, ‘disjunction between physical presence (residence) and legal authorization (citizenship)’ (p. 71).
Melanie Wiber’s chapter on natural resource management in the Canadian Bay of Funday examines how international and state law work to exclude local rights of access to fish stocks. A main consequence of this is constraints on the creation and maintenance of local knowledge in favour of that from epistemic communities made up of federal bureaucrats and university researchers (p. 75). Different perceptions of scale, supported and constructed by law, are used to determine knowledge about stocks with serious implications for the fisher communities working and living on a more local scale and according to a set of values presented by the media as parochial and unsophisticated. In this account the place-based values of local fisher communities are overwhelmed by a more generalised (global scale) and expert-led agenda of rationalising and controlling access to fish stocks.
The second key theme is the nature of political authority and associated ‘property spaces’. Along these lines, Laurens Bakker witnesses the reclaiming of land by sultanates (armed with an ancient map) in Pasir, East Kalimantan, in Indonesia. This set in train a popular resistance and competing categorisation of space by the sultanates, other claimants and the local populations. Differing versions of local law (Parasese customary law) as well as state law are set against each other ‘on the basis of claims to validity that derive from the specific spatial setting in which they are applied’ (p. 13). Staying within Indonesia, the von Benda-Beckmanns draw out this theme from a close analysis of the competing legal orders in two regions (West Sumatra and the island of Ambon) incorporated into the Dutch colonial empire at different times. As a result they show the prevalence of older legal categories of space and property rights, emphasising the differential impact of colonialisation on traditional authority and its localisation in the village. Transformations of space in plural legal orders are shown not always to flow from top-down colonial rule, but to be strategically manipulated by local actors as well. Such contradictions also obtain between different versions of customary law, which actors mobilise against each other in their claims to land and trees. In sum, transformed versions of ethnic law do not necessarily supersede the earlier forms but may coexist with them (p. 131). This study of contested spaces of authority pays close attention to the grounding of social spaces, social relations and institutions, offering accounts of village life, personal relations and lineage.
The third theme is ‘scales of legal validity’, as exemplified in Gerhard Anders’s chapter on the Special Court for Sierra Leone, an ad hoc international war crimes tribunal, located outside or rather above the national justice system and which constitutes the legal dimension of the international response to the atrocities committed during the civil war between 1991 and 2001. Using ethnographic evidence, Anders shows up the disjuncture of scale inherent in the court as a symbol of global justice (or neocolonial military–humanitarian justice) and reveals how this adversely affects its work. His conclusion is that ‘place matters in international criminal justice. In spite of its appearance as universal and trans-local it is made and instantiated at particular places’ (p. 154). Such places are shaped by history and embedded in power relations.
Keeping with courts, Anne Griffiths and Randy Kandel explore the legal space (‘a micro context’) for children’s hearings (dealing with those children in need of compulsory measures of supervision) in Glasgow. In the course of the chapter we ‘meet’ several young people and find out about their hearings from transcripts, including their response to the physical space in which the hearing takes place. This leads the authors to discuss how concepts of risk, danger and safety are attached to spaces with regard to children, whether explicitly legal or not (such as home, street or school).
Engaging social geography, Edwin Wilmsen maps the processes by which law may have been fashioned to organise space in interior Southern Africa during the eighth to the fifteenth centuries and thereby reconstruct patterns of law and power. Unusually, he does this by taking account of the meanings attached to archaeological finds, and in so doing makes the claim that ‘material artifacts have the same ontological status as words … they have communicative as well as utilitarian functions’ (p. 178). Via Marxist and sociological theory, we arrive at ‘Things’ (beads, pottery, horn, skins, gold, tortoiseshell, shells, metals) and their significance for mapping not just trade but also the regulation of ownership and inheritance (p. 187ff.).
The final task of the book is to engage in the debate about the possibility and utility of ‘mapping law’, a process begun and advanced by de Sousa Santos (1987), but here identified by Maarten Bavinck and Gordon Woodman as a question about the relationship between law as mapped and social reality in conditions of legal pluralism, in other words, the case against maps of law. This leads the editors to make general points relating to the use of maps by legal anthropologists, previewing their use to show contested spaces in plural legal constellations, where different rights, of different actors, based in different legal systems, are projected on the same territory.
In summary, Spatializing Law makes a profound contribution to the empirical and intellectual richness of this area of scholarship. It is solidly grounded (literally so, with many of the chapters taken up with the connections between people, territory and land), well crafted (the consistency and clarity of the contributions suggesting a strong editorial hand!) and clearly signposted for the reader, to the extent that I would feel comfortable recommending it to postgraduate students working on a range of issues relating to property, commons and environment. It is a thoroughly stimulating read, along ‘keeping one reading through the night’ lines. Coming from law, I welcomed the editors’ explanation of the contribution of anthropology as a discipline, compared to the relative contributions of law (justice, order, control, governance, regulation) and geography (scale, space, place).
The editors enlarge on this contribution in their opening chapter, in which they summarise the way in which overlapping legal orders create hierarchies of locations within local communities, demonstrating that this differential grounding of rights and physical space produces social stratification and power relations. Exactly how a population is ‘localised’ (or globalised) is seen to have clear consequences for the ways in which economic and political rights can be negotiated (p. 14). They then emphasise how crucial it is to look at rights and other social relationships as located in space. In relation to the research conducted in Indonesia, the editors provide a clear rationale for engaging anthropology in the job of analysing the spatialisation of law:
‘The spatial localization of political and economic rights is a valuable factor that helps to explain key differences within the same social field of the “village” and its internal relationships. This is not self-evident and cannot be based on general, normative claims about law, but requires investigation into the kinds of social processes that are at work with their ensuing consequences. Thus it is necessary to pay close attention to the legal construction of spaces in the physical environment and to the spatial-temporal permanence of political and legal places, however fluid and temporal their boundaries may be.’ (p. 14)
So, they argue, taking this appeal into account, paying close attention to the social processes at work and their consequences over time and space – taking an anthropological perspective – offers up the chance to differentiate between ‘lived spaces’ and ‘abstract spaces’, and it is the ability to make such a differentiation which contrasts with much of the existing literature in the law/geography field. But is this entirely the case? I can recall plenty of research conducted under the law/geography banner which is taken up with the nature of social processes as well as the consequential differentiation and negotiations of rights and power – Blomley’s (1994) and Delaney’s (2003) work comes to mind – to the extent that I wonder whether such writers have directed an anthropological gaze upon ‘social processes’ (although not precisely ethnically informed), without avowedly doing so. In other words, these and others working within the law/geography ‘tradition’ have gone beyond using spatial metaphors to characterise social spaces in order to delineate the places where law is being made and put into practice, and have additionally looked to the lived nature of spaces, with their complex and messy patterns of social, cultural and legal rights and power relations. That said, the geographical shift in this book is noticeable, with a marked and general, though not wholesale, re-orientation of subject matter away from North America and Canada.
What exactly arises from this combination of disciplines cannot therefore be reduced to a particular theory or theme. Rather, it points to an approach, a view, and the depth and intensity of that gaze, as well as a receptiveness to recognising legal pluralism and the fascinating complexity that arises from this. Looking generally at the nature of the law/geography/anthropology combination of disciplinary frames, the idea of ‘place’ (‘any locality that has significance for a person or group of persons’; p. 75) and, more precisely, the intersections and transformation of ‘space’ into ‘place’ or a multitude of ‘places’, keeps occurring to such an extent that this might act as a key to many of the aims and ideas in the book.
Returning to my EU project on spatial planning, the themes of this book bring into sharper focus the deliberate and political processes engaged in flattening out the complexity and infinite variety of space, landscape and ‘place’ by law via the (now) constitutional concepts of territorial cohesion and solidarity, wrapped up in the rhetoric of diversity. Following the themes of this book, there is clearly more work to be done on the ‘lived’ experience and social and ecological processes arising from this, even from a predominantly legal perspective. In this EU context, the concern is not so much with differential claims of rights and power exercised through the ability of law to localise space (the nub of Spatialization of Law) but rather the centralising tendency of law and the consequential installation of general frameworks for dealing with and protecting land, within an overall developmental project which seeks actively to make competitive and accessible areas of land which might better be understood as ‘places’ rather than ‘spaces’.
