This work is inspiring: it is the first in-depth study of one of the most theatrically dynamic, aesthetically meaningful and ideologically provocative trends in Indian theatre, known as ‘theatre of roots’. The project is ambitious, presenting theoretical debates, case studies, play analysis, production reviews and official records documenting the history, theory and practice of this vibrant theatre movement in post-independence India. Mee shows invaluable awareness of the incorrect homogenization of Indian theatre history, seeking to illuminate ‘the ways in which the theatre of the roots makes itself modern on its own terms, within the specificities of its own culture’ (p. 19). She furthermore counters the critical denial of the aesthetic validity of the practice according to which ‘the theatre of the roots does not or cannot deal with the complex issues and problems of the modern world’ (p. 27), an argument which relies on a conceptual opposition of ‘tradition’ against the ‘modern’. Mee, on the contrary, clarifies that traditional performances ‘do not belong to the past: they are constantly reinventing themselves, responding to contemporary political events and social changes, adapting to changing performance circumstances, and playing to new audiences’ (p. 27). She presents an articulated argument that outlines the roots movement as a theatrical alternative redefining ‘theatre’ and ‘modernity’ in and for the Indian context.
Mee starts from a discussion of the emergence of colonial theatre spaces in Bombay (1800) and Calcutta (1795), thus mapping the history of the arrival of a literary theatrical culture in India and giving attention to early nineteenth- and twentieth-century Indian theatre history: the emergence of naturalism in the Marathi stage, the revival of ‘folk’ theatre traditions, the formation of Indian People's Theatre Association (IPTA) and the Dramatic Performance Act (1876), which become the basis of several key arguments throughout the book. Three case studies (Shanta Gandhi, Utpal Dutt and Habib Tanvir) show how the members of IPTA, after the association was dissolved, revitalized the urban stage and developed into the theatre of the roots.
Mee demonstrates in the following chapters that the playwrights and directors of the ‘theatre of the roots’ replaced the text-based theatre, returning to ‘indigenous’ performance-driven theatre. Panikkar, for instance, uses dramaturgical structures of Kudiyattam, the actor-training methods of Kathakali, bodily training from Kalarippayattu and aesthetic theories of Natyasastra, to redefine modern theatre practice in India. The section is highly illuminative, though Mee does not seem to be aware that Panikkar is part of a larger literary and intellectual movement in 1960s Kerala that set the background of the roots theatre movement in the region. In Chapter 3, Mee then explores the aesthetic formations of ‘the complex subjectivities of post-Independence India’ as presented in Karnad's 1971 play Hayavadana. She shows how the playwright integrated the ‘folk’ theatre tradition to create an intentional hybridity in post-independence Indian theatre. Later, she analyses the works of Ratan Thiyam, one of India's leading theatre directors of Manipur, whose physical work is heavily influenced by Manipuri martial arts. His theatre language is complex and visually spectacular. The discussion is focused largely on Thiyam's productions in India and abroad, while Mee is less successful in showing how Thiyam has developed a training method and a stage language appropriate to the roots theatre movement.
Earlier, Chapter 4 inserted some highly useful documents showing how official schemes supported, formalized and institutionalized the roots movement, which originated from the impulses and experiments of individual theatre artists. In the final chapter, Mee raises important questions concerning the relevance and prominence of roots theatre in post-independence India. Playwrights like Mahesh Dattani and Manjula Padmanabhan, and directors like Mangai, Usha Ganguli, Tripurari Sharma, Maya Rao, and Arjun Raina, are briefly discussed. The book includes appendices offering details of the seminars and theatre festivals conducted by the Sangeet Natak Academi (SNA) since 1956. The extensive notes are worth mentioning as they offer valuable information about the cultural, theatrical and political history of India from the nineteenth century up to the present. Mee's essential work is well infused with vivid descriptions and a mixture of perspectives and arguments on some of the most important cultural and aesthetic issues such as tradition and modernity, national identity and intercultural interactions which are persistently mounting concerns in contemporary Indian theatre.
