No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 November 2004
Juan Cole's history of Shi

ism is the right book at the right time. It is essential reading for anyone—scholar, policy-maker, or concerned citizen—who hopes to follow the next few years of Middle East developments. Unfortunately, readers who have no background in Islamic and Middle Eastern matters are likely to find it hard going.
The history of English-language writing on Shi

ism makes the need for Cole's book evident. Dwight M. Donaldson published The Shi

ite Religion in 1933. Thirty years later, when I was starting graduate school, it remained the only book on Shi

ism available in English. Another thirty years passed. The United States led a coalition that forced Iraq out of Kuwait and then sat idly by while Saddam Hussein brutally crushed the Shi

i uprising, urged by American propaganda. By then, historical scholarship had improved somewhat. Interpretive works by Moojan Momen (An Introduction to Shi

ite Islam [New Haven, Conn: Yale University Press, 1987]), Abdulaziz Sachedina (Islamic Messianism: The Idea of Mahdi in Twelver Shi

ism [Albany: State University of New York Press, 1981]), and S. H. M. Jafri (Origins and Early Development of Shi

a Islam [London: Longman, 1979]), among others, had filled in some of the blank spots in the early history of Shi

ism. And good studies of contemporary Shi

ism in Iran and Lebanon had become available. But a broad perspective on modern Shi`ism still eluded most students of the Middle East.
The profound Sunni bias of Western scholarship on Islam is seldom remarked. A centuries-old illusion that Shi

ism is for all intents and purposes an exclusively Iranian matter effectively absolved Arabists of responsibility for learning anything about it. The fact that Shi

i constitute the majority populations in Iraq and Bahrain, and the largest confessional community in Lebanon, should have alerted students of contemporary Arab affairs to the need to inform themselves. The same can be said regarding the political potential of Shi

i minorities in Syria, Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Afghanistan, Pakistan, and India. But introductory works on Islam continue to this day to minimize discussion of Shi

ism.
The effectiveness of Western master narratives of modern Middle East history in confining discussion of Shi

ism to Iran resulted, after the Iranian Revolution of 1979, in a snap judgment in both popular and official thinking. Shi

ism was equated with suicidal fanaticism and Sunnism with moderate, sensible Islam—despite the fact that the attack on the grand mosque in Mecca in the same year was carried out by Sunnis led by Juhaiman ibn Muhammad ibn Saif al-Utaiba, a member of a highly regarded Wahhabi family, and despite the fact that the widely read writings of the Sunni thinker Sayyid Qutb advocated a revolutionary violence that went well beyond that of the Iranian revolutionary theorists.
Twenty-five years after the Iranian Revolution, American surprise at the power and organization of the Shi

i clergy in Iraq has at last made it clear that a crash course on contemporary Shi

ism in its full breadth is sorely needed. Cole's book largely fulfills that need.
Even though it is composed in part of previously published articles, the flow from chapter to chapter is almost seamless. Part 1—Chapters 2–6—deals with the history of Shi

ism in Iran and the Arab world in the early modern period. Chapter 4 on the Akhbari–Usuli struggle whose resolution led to the solid structure of religious authority in contemporary Usuli populations, including those in Iran, Iraq, and Lebanon, is of particular importance. The three chapters in Part 2 cover Shi

ism in India, the subject of Cole's innovative first book, Roots of North Indian Shi

ism in Iran and Iraq: Religion and State in Awadh, 1722–1859 (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1988). Part 3 takes up two key problems of 20th-century Shi

ism: the role of Shi

is as national minorities and the issue of theocracy.
Though the coverage of the book is impressive, and the weaving together of materials pertaining to the Shi

i communities of South Asia, Iran, and the Arab world is skillful, some important subjects fall outside its purview. The Alevi Shi

is of Turkey and the Hazaras of Afghanistan, for example, get little attention. However, compared with earlier works concentrating on single countries, Cole's breadth of vision is more than welcome. Departing from the exclusive concentration on doctrinal matters of scholars dealing with early Shi

i history, Cole grounds each chapter in a thorough discussion of the social context of the community he is discussing.
Unfortunately, this is where he is going to lose many non-specialist readers, including most beginning students of Middle Eastern history. Despite the deceptive brevity of the index, the text bristles with names, dates, and details. As a scholar, I would have it no other way. Cole's presentation of the contexts of modern Shi

i developments requires a full exposition, and much of the information he brings forward has never been integrated into a general historical view of the modern Middle East.
Yet one could still wish for some sort of executive summary. With the United States embarked on a campaign to transform, by one means or another, a good part of the Muslim world, and with knowledgeable scholars possessing expertise that might shape or curtail misguided aspects of that campaign, it is more than ever incumbent on the Middle East scholarly community to seek an idiom for addressing the ongoing public debate.
This is not a criticism of the book that Cole has presented us with. It is by far the best and most far-ranging account of Shi

ism in the early modern and contemporary periods. Rather, it is to urge him to write another book that will be more accessible to students and to educated lay readers, and to urge other writers bent on explicating the contemporary complications of Middle Eastern and Islamic affairs to read Cole well and use his work to counterbalance the Sunni bias that continues to distort our policy decisions in troubling times.