In the months following the election of Donald Trump there was a global surge in the sale of dystopian political fiction. In his recent title How Will Capitalism End? Wolfgang Streeck warns us that such existential angst is not necessarily misplaced. He argues that the increase in global chaos in the wake of the financial market crash of 2008 is symptomatic of a capitalist world order that is collapsing from under the weight of its own success.
Streeck begins from the perspective that capitalism today is not merely suffering from an economic malaise but also a weakening of the social and political glue that have provided the system with legitimacy. Streeck argues that the system's survival has relied on a series of stabilizing forces that have offset its various contradictions. In recent years, however, several of these counterforces designed to stabilize capitalism have begun to crumble all at once, with few obvious solutions in sight.
As the social and economic edifice of capitalism collapses with no opposing order to replace it, Streeck warns that the system will enter a period of immense political chaos, uncertainty, violence and misery, as the old system sheds its skin and gives way to a new order. He calls this period an interregnum phase in which capitalism will be left to hang “in limbo, dead or about to die from an overdose of itself, but still around as no one will have the capacity to move its decaying body out of the way” (36). The abolition of countervailing forces to capital accumulation will serve to weaken solidarity during the interregnum, as individuals retreat into even deeper into the cult of the self as a means of survival.
Although Streeck acknowledges that capitalism's obituary has been penned many times throughout its history, he suggests that there are a number of reasons to think that this time capitalism's contradictions may be too severe to be overcome. At the core of Streeck's argument is the long downturn of postwar capitalism, which was dealt with first through the inflation of public debt and then later with private debt once the state adjusted to a policy of fiscal consolidation. Deepening inequality brought about by low-growth capitalism has placed additional pressure on the state to hold together the social order while at the same time meeting the demands of a transnational financial sector that seeks to undermine national sovereignty to ensure the confidence of the markets. Stuck between an increasingly restless public and a global corporate oligarchy that controls the money supply, states have sought to undermine democratic institutions to ensure the ability to implement policies that contradict the interests of the many. Additionally, Streeck observes that governments today are largely unable to stop the naked commodification of labour, natural resources and money through the financial system as global competition continues to encourage increasingly exploitative practices.
These contradictions are hastened by the sweeping away of collective institutions that once provided a counterforce on the hegemony of capitalism. The decline of what Streeck calls “system integration,” the unifying social, political and economic balance that allowed the system to function, are in peril in large part because capitalism has been so successful it has all but eliminated any opposition to it (14). In this way, it has overplayed its hand, becoming too capitalist for its own good. A revealing clue that the problem is different this time, Streeck observes, is that after the crisis of 2008 the technocratic experts who largely control the system seem to have few solutions save for a doubling down on the very behaviours that have led to the crisis in the first instance.
In writing How Will Capitalism End? Wolfgang Streeck has provided us with an original and stimulating theoretical account for these uncertain times. Although he readily admits that many have predicted the premature death of capitalism during periods of crisis only to see it resuscitate itself, he makes a convincing case that the mounting problems the system faces today may make this time different. As Streeck suggests, just because all of the others were wrong before, does not mean that no one will ever be right. Indeed, as Hegel reminds us, “the owl of Minerva begins its flight only with the onset of dusk” (The Elements of the Philosophy of Right, 1991, 23). It may well be that only with the narrowing of light are we able to truly see the passing of an era.
