Ian Clark's International Legitimacy and World Society is a continuation of a number of questions he raised in his earlier work on Legitimacy and International Society (2005). Whereas the previous book dealt with questions of how international society is influenced by legitimacy, the current work takes up questions of how world society influences international legitimacy, which in turn impacts on international society. The book focuses on the puzzle of why international society embraces certain world societal norms even if there are no obvious benefits for its traditional interstate agenda. Clark aims to answer two types of questions: “First, with regard to international legitimacy, what part has world society played in its prescription and evolution? Secondly, with regard to world society, to what extent can an investigation into its engagement with international society shed light upon its nature?” (3).
Clark's important and interesting study of historical cases adds to a long-standing debate within English School scholarship about the nature and role of world society and its relationship to international society. He brings together constructivism and the English School as two theories of International Relations that deal with norms and how they develop in the context of international society. The focus is on examining the sources of norms and how international society came to subscribe to some in preference of others. By not only looking at the state system, Clark widens his enquiry to include a wide range of social actors that play a part in normative developments.
The book starts with outlining the theoretical foundations for the subsequent case studies and the central concepts of international legitimacy and world society. Clark argues that the practice of international legitimacy should be added to Hedley Bull's traditional five institutions of international society. Legitimacy is seen as a social concept that only makes sense within a social context; at the same time, society needs shared principles of legitimacy—”legitimacy constitutes society” (18). World society, on the other hand, does not possess its own political system in which legitimacy principles operate. Clark claims that the concept of world society has broadened the normative agenda to include issues such as human rights while greatly expanding the scope of social constituency in which legitimacy is sought. World society is, therefore, a source and a target of legitimacy claims, and even though international and world societies are seen as distinct concepts, they also overlap and merge to some degree.
The subsequent seven chapters of the book analyze different case studies of historical episodes that are mostly related to peacemaking or human rights issues. The cases examine how different normative claims that might be thought to have greater resonance from world society became prominent in international society. These normative claims are not part of the traditional agenda of an international society of states, which makes understanding why states would adopt them that much more puzzling. Clark sees these historical occasions (such as aftermaths of wars) as focal points for new norms that therefore provide opportunities to study the interaction between international and world society. Clark's central question is why and how international society became interested in these norms and what the lasting results on the evolution of international legitimacy are. The case studies examine how international society was influenced by world society and what the implications are for the development of the concept of international legitimacy.
The first case study examines the abolition of the slave trade in 1815, which is seen as the first case of political organization for a humanitarian cause. International and world society interacted through transnational actors shaping the policy of international society. The second case deals with the two Hague peace conferences of 1899 and 1907 and their impact on public conscience. The two conferences are important in this context as they promoted humanitarian notions that international society had a responsibility for humankind and that those values stretched beyond the traditional state system. Chapters 4 and 5 deal with Versailles 1919 and how different issues were dealt with by international society. First, Clark examines the issue of racial equality that was not adopted as a new norm of international society. This case shows an interesting point of contrast: the norm of racial equality was considered as a world society norm, but eventually rejected because of fears its adoption would provoke an unfavorable reaction in world society because international and world society lacked consensus on the issue. The second issue coming out of Versailles was that of social justice that was adopted by international society. By basing the peace treaty on a notion of social justice, international society committed itself to a general norm of social justice (peace founded on social justice). The setting-up of the ILO as an innovative meeting place of representatives of international society and representatives of employers and laborers set a precedent for other institutions that were established after World War II.
The subsequent case study of San Francisco and human rights in 1945 explores the notion of the relatively sudden elevation of human rights into the UN Charter. Clark argues that human rights are inherently contentious for the state system and that NGOs were instrumental in their adoption. He believes that the deal that was eventually reached in 1945 constituted a compromise between international and world society: international society recognized its responsibility for the protection of human beings who in turn shape principles of international order through world society. The final case study looks at the Charter of Paris for a New Europe of 1990 that aimed to strengthen democracy as the only form of government. Clark argues that this is a very puzzling activity in a pluralist international society: “[W]hile the declaration was palpably about the constitutional order to prevail within states, it was so momentous because it took the form of a statement agreed among states” (153). Domestic political arrangements were now linked to international legitimacy. The norm became possible because of the constellation of international society at the time but also due to the fact that it was grounded in a sense of legitimacy shared across a broad spectrum of world society.
The final chapter relates the findings of the historical studies back to theoretical issues by linking considerations about the nature of world society to issues of international legitimacy. Clark argues that the case studies showed that the normative claims made in these cases were normative beliefs rather than dominant practice. This is important, he maintains, because international legitimacy constitutes the dominant practice in international society, which raises questions of the origins of norms (rather than their impact and how they disseminate) and how world society impacts on the nature of international legitimacy. Clark concludes that “the key argument of this book is that a critical identity shift takes place at the interface of international and world society, and is reflected in the changing identity of international society” (209).
This book makes an important contribution to the literature that examines international and world society and their relationship to each other. Clark uses the historical case studies skillfully to illustrate the concepts and to reveal their significance in normative developments in history.
