Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T04:45:50.304Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Direct numerical and large-eddy simulation of trefoil knotted vortices

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  15 January 2021

Xinran Zhao
Affiliation:
School of Mechanical Engineering, Purdue University, IN 47907, USA
Zongxin Yu
Affiliation:
School of Mechanical Engineering, Purdue University, IN 47907, USA
Jean-Baptiste Chapelier
Affiliation:
School of Mechanical Engineering, Purdue University, IN 47907, USA
Carlo Scalo*
Affiliation:
School of Mechanical Engineering, Purdue University, IN 47907, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: scalo@purdue.edu

Abstract

This paper investigates pre- and post-reconnection dynamics of an unperturbed trefoil knotted vortex for circulation-based Reynolds numbers $Re_\varGamma = 2\times 10^3$ and $6\times 10^3$ by means of direct numerical simulations based on an adaptive mesh refinement framework. Companion coherent-vorticity preserving large-eddy simulations are also carried out on a uniform Cartesian grid. The complete vortex structure and flow evolution are simulated, including reconnection and subsequent separation into a smaller and a larger vortex ring, and the resulting helicity dynamics. The self-advection velocity before reconnection is found to scale with inviscid parameters. The reconnection process, however, occurs earlier (and more rapidly) in the higher Reynolds number case due to higher induced velocities associated with a thinner vortex core. The vortex propagation velocities after reconnection and separation are also affected by viscous effects, more prominently for the smaller vortex ring; the larger one is shown to carry the bulk of the helicity and enstrophy after reconnection. The domain integrated, or total helicity, $H(t)$, does not significantly change up until reconnection, at which point it varies abruptly due to the rapid dissipation of helicity caused by super-helicity hotspots localized at the reconnection sites. The total helicity dissipation rate predicted by the large-eddy simulation agrees reasonably well with the direct numerical simulation results, with a significant contribution from the modelled subgrid-scale stresses. On the other hand, variations in the vortex centreline helicity, $H_C(t)$, and the vortex-tube-integrated helicity $H_V(t)$ are less sensitive to the reconnection process. Periodic vortex bursting events are also observed and are shown to be due to converging axial flow velocities in the detached vortex rings at later stages of evolution.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Initial vortex shape defined via the parametric equation (2.1), where $r_e$ is the initial effective vortex-core radius; $R_{min}$ and $R_{max}$ the minimum and maximum knot radius. The knot half-thickness (in the $z$ direction) is taken as equal to $R_{min}$. The trefoil vortex propagates in the $+z$ direction due to the self-induced velocity field.

Figure 1

Table 1.Geometrical parameters defining the knotted vortex filament and initial effective viscous core radius, $r_e$.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Grid following the vortex transport in the DNS simulation with AMR. The upper row and lower row show different views of the simulation results for $Re_\varGamma =6000$.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Grid convergence analysis for AMR simulations: $Re_{\varGamma }=2000$ (green), $Re_{\varGamma }=6000$ (blue), showing the evolution of the resolved volume-integrated enstrophy $\varXi$ (or, equivalently, normalized total viscous dissipation, $\epsilon$). The results in the plot include the six AMR simulations at $Re_{\varGamma }=6000$ and the three AMR simulations for $Re_{\varGamma }=2000$ (see table 2) with increasing levels of grid refinement as shown by the arrow.

Figure 4

Table 2.Summary of flow and grid parameters for the (single-mesh-level, i.e. $d=1$) Cartesian CvP-LES and the AMR runs, executed on $d=8$ and $d=9$ mesh levels. Here $N^3$ indicates the total number of points per AMR block, or in the whole computational domain for the Cartesian LES, $2r_e/\varDelta$ is an estimate of the number of grid points per initial effective vortex diameter, and $N_{{tot}}$ is the total degrees of freedom for each simulation in the unit of millions. For AMR simulations, $N_{{tot}}$ is taken at $t^*=3.0$ right after the reconnection.

Figure 5

Figure 4.Grid sensitivity analysis for LES: $Re_{\varGamma }=2000$ (green), $Re_{\varGamma }=6000$ (blue) showing the evolution of the resolved volume-integrated enstrophy, $\varXi$ (a), normalized total dissipation, $\epsilon _{total}$ (b), and SGS to total dissipation ratio (c). Grid resolutions considered are the finest three datasets from each simulation: coarse $( \cdots )$; intermediate $(\textrm {- - -})$; fine $(\textrm {------})$ (see data in table 2). Reference data shown in circles ($\circ$) are taken from the finest DNS data.

Figure 6

Figure 5.Grid sensitivity analysis for Cartesian CvP-LES (black) and AMR (green/blue) simulations: $Re_{\varGamma }=2000$ (a), $Re_{\varGamma }=6000$ (b) showing the one-dimensional energy spectra in the $z$ direction at the time of first reconnection ($t_1$) defined as the time when the maximum dissipation is achieved (see figure 2). Grid resolutions considered are the finest three datasets from each simulation: coarse $( \cdots )$; intermediate $(\textrm {- - -})$; fine $(\textrm {------})$ (see data in table 2). Red dotted line shows a reference $-$5/3 slope. Here $L_z$ is the domain size in $z$ direction.

Figure 7

Figure 6.Visualizations of $Q$-isosurfaces with $Q\bar {R}^4/\varGamma ^2=97$ extracted from $Re_\varGamma =6000$ simulation. Here $v_a^*$ denotes the dimensionless propagation velocity of the knot before reconnection ($t^*<2.5$); $v_{b1}^*$ and $v_{b2}^*$ denote the small and large rings velocity, respectively, after reconnection.

Figure 8

Figure 7.Plane-averaged vorticity as a function of $z$ (vortex propagation direction) and $t$. The velocities $v_a, v_{b1}$ and $v_{b2}$ (see figure 6) are calculated via a linear fit of the local maxima of vorticity in the $z$–$t$ plane. The dashed lines show the results from DNS, and dots are from LES.

Figure 9

Table 3.Non-dimensional propagation velocity (4.2c) of the vortex structures before and after reconnection from the AMR/DNS and Cartesian LES data.

Figure 10

Figure 8.(a) Evolution of effective core radius $r_e$ and (b) instantaneous vortex length $\ell (t)$ normalized by the initial vortex length $\ell _0$ for ${Re}_{\varGamma }=2000$ (green) and ${Re}_{\varGamma }=6000$ (blue). Regions shaded via vertical bars represent the time intervals when reconnection is happening, which are partly overlapping for the two different Reynolds numbers. Solid lines are used before reconnection; $\square$, large ring after reconnection; $\triangle$, small ring after reconnection; $(\circ )$, sum of small and large ring vortex length after reconnection. (c) Overlapping of $Q$-isosurfaces $Q\bar {R}^4/\varGamma ^2=323$ from ${Re}_{\varGamma }=2000$ and ${Re}_{\varGamma }=6000$ at four different non-dimensional times: $t^*=0.53$ and $t^*=1.58$ are two instances before reconnection; $t^*=2.95$ and $t^*=2.53$ are the reconnection times for ${Re}_{\varGamma }=2000$ and ${Re}_{\varGamma }=6000$ cases, respectively.

Figure 11

Figure 9.(a,c,d) Reconstructed vortex centreline upon reconnection for $Re_{\varGamma }=2000$ (green) and $Re_{\varGamma }=6000$ (blue). The radii of curvature are marked with black arrows, with the local normal vectors as their directions. Red arrows represent the direction of vectors tangential to the vortex lines. The angle between the normal vectors and the line connecting the two tipping points is marked as $\theta$. Panels (c,d) are for $Re_{\varGamma }=2000$ at $t\varGamma /\bar {R}^2=2.528$ and $Re_{\varGamma }=6000$ at $t\varGamma /\bar {R}^2=2.370$, respectively. (b) Change in radius of curvature at the tipping points before reconnection.

Figure 12

Table 4.Curvatures and tipping point angles right before reconnection (see figure 9) at two different Reynolds numbers.

Figure 13

Figure 10.(a) Local coordinate system at the reconnection location. Panels (b–e) show the different times during reconnection for $Re_{\varGamma } = 6000$. Panel (b) shows the onset position and (c,d,e) show the vortex structure evolution as reconnection progresses. Isosurfaces are extracted with a vorticity magnitude of $\omega = 0.5\varGamma /{\rm \pi} r_{e,0}^2$ coloured by normalized helicity density.

Figure 14

Figure 11.Finest DNS/AMR (a,c,e,g) and LES (b,d,f,h) at $Re_{\varGamma }=6000$ showing $Q$-isosurfaces at $Q\bar {R}^4/\varGamma ^2=323$ for $\langle I \rangle ,\langle II \rangle ,\langle III \rangle$ and 96 for $\langle IV \rangle$, coloured by helicity density; $\langle I \rangle$: a pair of anti-parallel vortex lines undergoing viscous cancellation; $\langle II \rangle$: hairpin vortices are generated along non-reconnected parts of threads and forming bridges; $\langle III \rangle$: newly formed threads; $\langle IV \rangle$: helical structures are generated.

Figure 15

Figure 12.Sensor function $f(\sigma )$ used in the CvP-LES closure in (2.16) at two different time instances from a LES at $Re_{\varGamma } = 6000$.

Figure 16

Figure 13.Visualization of the generation of hairpin vortices from $Q$-isosurfaces at $Q\bar {R}^4/\varGamma ^2=96$ for ${Re}_{\varGamma }=2000$ and ${Re}_{\varGamma }=6000$ from DNS/AMR data, coloured by normalized helicity density; threads created during the bridging process, intermediate hairpin vortex structure the final dominant hairpin structure are illustrated.

Figure 17

Figure 14.Isosurfaces of vorticity magnitude at various times during reconnection: $\omega = 0.3\varGamma /{\rm \pi} r_{e,0}^2$ coloured in transparent grey and $\omega = 1.0\varGamma /{\rm \pi} r_{e,0}^2$ coloured by red at $Re_{\varGamma } = 2000$.

Figure 18

Figure 15.Isosurfaces of vorticity magnitude at specific time steps during reconnection: $\omega = 0.5\varGamma /{\rm \pi} r_{e,0}^2$ coloured in transparent grey and $\omega = 3.0\varGamma /{\rm \pi} r_{e,0}^2$ coloured by red at $Re_{\varGamma } = 6000$.

Figure 19

Figure 16.Visualization of the threads (marked by dashed rectangles) evolution using $Q$-isosurfaces with $Q\bar {R}^4/\varGamma ^2=323$ for ${Re}_{\varGamma }=6000$ DNS coloured by normalized pressure fluctuations (structure $\langle III \rangle$) in figure 11.

Figure 20

Figure 17.$Q$-isosurfaces with $Q\bar {R}^4/\varGamma ^2=323$ from DNS results at $Re_\varGamma =6000$. Panels (a,b) show the axial flow direction before reconnection; (c,d,b) depicts the Kelvin-wave packet generated and colliding on the leading small ring, and (f–i) show the Kelvin-wave packets travelling and colliding on the large vortex ring after reconnection; (h) shows when the Kelvin-wave packets collide on the large vortex ring, an annular structure is formed; (j) shows the centreline axial flow energy spectrum before, during and after the Kelvin-wave collision event happened on the large vortex ring as shown in (g–i), respectively.

Figure 21

Figure 18.Direct numerical simulation and companion LES data for the evolution of volume-integrated, or total, helicity for $Re_\varGamma =2000$ (green) and $Re_\varGamma =6000$ (blue) for the vortex knot configuration considered in the present study. Direct numerical simulation results are shown by solid lines and the finest LES by circles ($\circ$).

Figure 22

Figure 19.Global helicity budget at different Reynolds numbers from the DNS and finest LES available: (a) $Re_{\varGamma }=2000$ DNS, in green; (b) $Re_{\varGamma }=6000$ DNS, in blue; (c) $Re_{\varGamma }=2000$ LES, in green; (d) $Re_{\varGamma }=6000$ LES, in blue. The symbols correspond to: $(\circ )$ resolved helicity production term (first term on the right-hand side of (6.4) and (6.5)); $(\triangle )$ SGS helicity production term (second term in (6.5)); $(\textrm {------})$ time derivative of resolved global helicity $H(t)$ (left-hand side of (6.4) or (6.5)) obtained by differentiating the time series of $H(t)$ collected at every Navier–Stokes time step.

Figure 23

Figure 20.Plane-averaged helicity as a function of $z$ (vortex propagation direction) and $t$. The white dashed lines show the positions of vortex rings estimated by the planed-averaged vorticity magnitude, with velocities $v_a, v_{b1}$ and $v_{b2}$ defined in figure 6 and calculated the same way as in figure 7. The DNS and LES results are compared for each Reynolds number.

Figure 24

Figure 21.Plane-averaged helicity production $\textrm {d} h^*/\textrm {d} t^*$ as a function of $z$ (vortex propagation direction) and $t$ from the DNS results. The white dashed lines show the positions of vortex rings estimated by the planed-averaged vorticity magnitude, with velocities $v_a, v_{b1}$ and $v_{b2}$ defined in figure 6 and calculated the same way as in figure 7.

Figure 25

Figure 22.Evolution of centreline helicity, tube-integrated helicity and circulation, for the entire vortex structure (black), and small leading ring (yellow) and large trailing ring (red) after reconnection. (a,c) Time series of vortex-tube-integrated helicity density $H_V(t)$$(\square )$, and centreline helicity $H_C(t)$$(\textrm {------})$ normalized by initial circulation from DNS results at $Re_{\varGamma }=2000$ and $Re_{\varGamma }=6000$, respectively. Green and blue triangles $(\triangleleft )$ show the normalized total helicity $H(t)$ for $Re_{\varGamma }=2000$ and $Re_{\varGamma }=6000$, respectively. (b,d) Evolution of instantaneous circulation $\varGamma _n(t)$ (see (6.8)) from DNS results at $Re_{\varGamma }=2000$ and $Re_{\varGamma }=6000$, respectively, shown by circles $(\circ )$. The grey box is masking the reconnection time when the vortex centreline is not clearly defined.

Figure 26

Figure 23.Axial flow distribution ($\hat {w}$) on three different cut planes on the large vortex ring after reconnection, based on the $Q$-isosurface of $Q\bar {R}^4/\varGamma ^2=323$ at $t^*=3.97$ and $Re_\varGamma =6000$ from DNS results.

Figure 27

Table 5.Grid sizes and marker legend for the box size sensitivity study; the reference length is taken as $L_0=10R_{min}$.

Figure 28

Figure 24.Comparison of evolution of energy and enstrophy among different box sizes. Refer to table 5 for markers used.

Figure 29

Figure 25.Two-point velocity correlation along different lines: (a–c) the $z$ location follows the knotted vortex; $z(t)-z_0$ is equal among box sizes at the same time step; (d–f) the $z$ plane is located at the initial position, cutting through the centre of the knotted vortex at $t^*=0$. Blue: $y=y_0-L_0/3$, black: $y=y_0$, red: $y=y_0+L_0/3$. Refer to table 5 for a description of the box sizes.