Matteo Valleriani's detailed study explores Galileo's work as a practising artist-engineer, from his earliest days at Pisa to his house arrest outside Florence following his condemnation in 1633. Valleriani argues first that Galileo's contributions to science grew out of his training and practice as an artist-engineer; his subsequent claim is that these practical pursuits were directed by theoretical concerns and problems derived from Aristotelian natural philosophy. As such, Galileo, according to Valleriani, was not merely an ‘artist-engineer’ but an ‘Aristotelian engineer’ or ‘engineer-scientist’, an individual who combined the training and know-how of an artist-engineer with a high level of education. This volume is the second of four projected volumes in the series The Historical Epistemology of Mechanics, which is based on a research projected centred at the Max Planck Institue for the History of Science in Berlin and intended ‘to explain the development and diffusion of mechanical knowledge in terms of historical-epistemological concepts’ (p. xi).
In identifying Galileo as an ‘Aristotelian engineer’, Valleriani draws on a long tradition of distinguished scholarship. Multiple scholars, including Leonardo Olschki, Jürgen Renn and Peter Damerow, have explored Galileo's work as a practising engineer. Vallieriani's specific thesis – that Galileo combined practical engineering experience with theoretical concerns derived from Aristotelian natural philosophy – has been articulated by, for example, Michael Mahoney (‘The mathematical realm of nature’, in D. Garber et al., The Cambridge History of Seventeenth-Century Philosophy, 1998). Valleriani also builds on recent interest in the practice of artisans and engineers exemplified in such works as Pamela Smith's The Body of the Artisan (2004). Valleriani's account, however, far surpasses these treatments in the level of detail and attention he pays to the specifics of Galileo's work in the practical realm. Part 1 is especially rich in this regard. Here Valleriani relies on material from Galileo's correspondence to recover his knowledge, training and activities. The reader learns, for example, details about Galileo's work as a lens- and instrument-maker, including his interactions with merchants and hired craftsmen and the difficulties he faced obtaining quality optical glass; from the records of a shopping list Galileo took to Venice in 1609, Valleriani reconstructs the process by which Galileo made his telescopic lenses. Valleriani's commitment to detailed, informative scholarship continues as he analyses the contents of Galileo's private instruction on fortifications, a set of courses which addressed practical arithmetic and geometry, military architecture, and the science of machines. Valleriani does an admirable job of comparing (when possible) Galileo's own contributions and approaches with those of his contemporaries. Galileo's letters take centre stage in Valleriani's analysis, and he includes an appendix of English translations of the majority of letters in Antonio Favaro's Edizione Nazionale of Galileo's Opere which are related to Galileo's engineering practice.
In the two case studies that comprise Part 2, Valleriani carefully traces the connections between Galileo's familiarity with natural philosophy and his work in the practical realm. He demonstrates how two specific sections of Galileo's theoretical writings on matter – namely parts of Day 2 of the 1638 Discorsi and the doctrine of heat presented in his 1623 Saggiatore – developed as a result of consultations with practitioners and a theoretical framework shaped by the pseudo-Aristotelian Mechanical Questions and Aristotle's Meteorology and Physics. Valleriani shows how Galileo's practical experience with shipbuilders and with the thermoscope forced him to confront difficulties with Aristotelian theory and develop alternative models for explaining, on the one hand, the resistance to breakage of ships' oars and, on the other, Aristotle's explanations of heat, rarefaction and condensation.
The one hesitation in my recommendation concerns the absence of an explicit discussion of methodologies and terms. In the introduction, Valleriani promises, as a first step, to ‘show how Galileo followed the typical educational path of the artist-engineer’ and ‘how he consequently began his career and retained the profile of a military engineer’ (p. xvii). The implication here is that Valleriani will discuss what this generic ‘path’ and ‘career’ resembled in the period and then demonstrate how Galileo conformed to it. Instead, Valleriani implicitly appears to reverse this approach by using Galileo's own career as a window into the world of the Renaissance artist-engineer. While this second approach is valid, it introduces a question (which Valleriani does not address) of the representativeness of Galileo compared to other artist-engineers and engineer-scientists in the period. I also have a small quibble with Valleriani's decision to rely on the terms ‘artist-engineer’ and ‘engineer-scientist’, both of which he defines in reference to the descriptions of previous historians (that of Edgar Zilsel (1891–1944) for the former, and E.J. Dijksterhuis (1892–1965) for the latter). Valleriani does acknowledge the difficulties with terminology – for example, he explicitly eschews the term ‘practitioner’, arguing that in recent scholarship the word is used in a vague way to refer to a spectrum of individuals, from ‘the illiterate young assistant of a machine maker to the highly educated military engineer at a sixteenth-century court’ (p. xx) – but, in general, he does not display the same sensitivity with his borrowed analytical categories as he does when navigating the primary sources. An alternative approach would have been to begin with Galileo and develop and define terms as they applied specifically to his life and work.
These criticisms aside, Valleriani's Galileo Engineer is a valuable contribution to historians of Galileo and of early modern mechanics, as well as to scholars interested in recovering the practices of early modern artisans and engineers. Valleriani's rich exposition and translated letters provide information not only about technical matters related to Galileo's instruments and investigations but also about his interactions with craftsmen and merchants. The detailed analyses of Galileo's working methods, reconstructed not only from Galileo's letters but also from manuscript and printed texts of contemporaries and predecessors, will provide rich fodder for those interested in understanding the practices of early modern artisan-engineers.
