Protest is sweeping the United States: the presidential election protests, #BlackLivesMatter demonstrations, and numerous other social change movements. As Americans stand up to authority, many academics and activists are discussing approaches that effectively harness the power of protest to make potent messages that will lead to change. Faculty members who want to educate students in the theory and practice of “serious play,” an ethnographic term referring to the use of ritual and spontaneous action for conflict resolution, should consider including Tactical Performance by L. M. Bogad in syllabi. Bogad reimagines “serious play” to fit the activist setting by “referring to ludic or playful actions that agitate in support of a social movement” (5). Tactical Performance does it all: juxtaposes the theory of performance to protest actions, jumpstarts creative messaging, and models the thinking and practice of the protestor.
Bogad positions the dissenter as a tricky player who subverts and intentionally misinterprets the rules set forth by those in power, thereby hoping to reveal the emperor's nudity. Bogad asserts that by engaging in a type of tactical carnival, it is possible to create a “joyous, participatory, and semi-anonymous, relatively safe place for power inversions/subversions” (100). By creating performative protest maneuvers and direct actions, the opposition can then find itself in a “‘demonstration dilemma,’” a position that eliminates the possibility of a good move for the hegemonic power (17). Bogad urges activists to initiate joy. Throughout Tactical Performance, terms such as “Clownfrontation and clowndestine maneuvers” (112), “artivists” (217), and “tricknology” (211) are used to underscore the importance of playfulness and invention. Bogad believes “ludic protest encourages people to enjoy, and to imagine other possible worlds” (96). Tactical Performance reminds readers that a spectator entertained might become an active supporter—or, at the very least, an onlooker seduced to watch just a little longer.
Tactical Performance claims to set down, in writing, the evolving best practices of creative protest for social change—something that has yet to be done. Bogad stresses that the historical memory of corporations, governments, and organizations is very, very long and that such institutions are likely to have the resources to make future protests and direct actions impossible to duplicate. Social change agents, opines Bogad, tend to be focused on reacting to the next moment rather than recording the tactics, processes, and results of the present protest. The smart “artivist”—the nom de guerre Bogad uses for the activist engaged in tactical performance—pays attention to political rhetoric and identifies the gap between politicians’ words and people's reality because this provides “a special opportunity to perform that gap—to embody and enact that vast discrepancy and hypocrisy” (215; emphasis in original). The book's descriptions of tactical performances devised in the gap are the activist's serious play through which processes and analyses can be learned. Bogad emphasizes that Tactical Performance is intended to fill in the institutional memory of some of America's most surprising (and sometimes silly) activist performances.
The memories of Bogad's processes, protests, and perturbations are humorous and revelatory. It is impossible not to laugh, and even admire, the creative Billionaire for Bush names like “Ollie Gark” (195) or the CIRCA leader's moniker “Colonel Oftruth” (112). Bogad's careful descriptions of the on-the-spot performance direction (and sharing of direction) used by CIRCA/NYC's clowns at the 2004 Republican National Convention clearly reveal how “the pirate model of democracy” allows power to be shared and transferred between clowns (191). Actual strategic conversations that took place between activists are recalled throughout the book to model the thinking that leads to a tactical performance. Bogad presents a real problem a group confronted, shares the ideas they invented, and identifies how they developed a solution. What is so unique about this approach is that Bogad often asks the reader, “What would you have done?” (30). Readers are encouraged to devise tactics they might use in the same circumstances. While Bogad's anecdotes make for amusing reading, the reader cannot help but wonder what other artivists create. The autoethnographic methodology Bogad uses limits the scope of knowledge of tactical performances around the world and throughout history.
Tactical Performance is a unique hybrid between a theoretical exploration of performative processes and an introductory textbook for the blossoming artivist. The complexity of Bogad's explanations of theory vary throughout the text. For example, the general ideas of Aristotle, Brecht, and Boal are simplified, whereas the reasoning from Barthes, de Certeau, and Bakhtin is quite sophisticated. The advanced reader will enjoy thinking about social movement activism critically, but the beginning reader may need additional assistance to understand Bogad's arguments in their entirety. Tactical Performance offers vital information to educate artivists while also encouraging researchers to theorize about “serious play.” Ironically, Bogad cautions artivists that one group cannot address all issues; yet Tactical Performance certainly tries to fill all the gaps in the research of social movement activism.
