Vikki Bell's thoughtful consideration of art in post-dictatorship Argentina asks the reader to look with her at a series of artworks and spaces as a means to broach the question of how art stimulates our imagination and in so doing makes us participate in this world differently. Two central concepts thread through her book: the spectre and ethos. The first is that art allows for the past to take place in the present (or perhaps indeed the ghosts of the past demand that art makes them present) with the hoped-for end of a different future. As regards the second, Bell argues, borrowing from Foucault, that it is not the artworks in themselves that are important but their force as ‘aesthetics of existence’ in the temporal gap between the past and the future, in which we can critically attend to the power structures shaping our lives.
This book is seeped in theoretical debates on art's ability to relate traumatic pasts and its limits to do so and how art functions in its various forms whether paintings, sculptures, photographs as well in some specific sites, such as the already well-studied notorious Advanced Naval School of Mechanics (ESMA) and Parque de Memoria in Buenos Aires, and the lesser-known centre of detention and torture in Córdoba (D2). Though prior knowledge of the authors from which Bell draws and with whom she wishes to dialogue makes the reading all the more thought provoking, the artworks and spaces she caringly and richly describes and reflects upon alone make this book a meaningful read. By including some artists whose own careers span beyond the years of the dictatorship (1976–83), León Ferrari (chapter 2) and Diana Dowek (chapter 7), and into the Kirschner years with Lucila Quieto (chapter 7), the temporality of a ‘long present’ (and indeed a long past) and the still waited for future is reinforced.
A third theme throughout Bell's book is that of justice. The introductory chapter looks at the role of law and legal decisions – the vacillating closings and openings of accountability – since the return to democracy to the Kirchners’ governments. Bell argues that law is only part of how the ‘nomos is constituted’ and that art offers ‘alternative sites at which people consider their worlds against their yearnings and their hopes for the future’ (p. 6). Yet, how these two sites are intertwined remains largely implicit in Bell's analysis. At times art is seen as ‘jurisgenerative’ (p. 12) such as creative demonstrations in favour of accountability. Or vice-versa, quests for accountability may lead to art such as when a box of photographs appeared mysteriously on the doorstep of D2 shortly after a police raid, photos that then came to form part of the archive but also of a museological curation (chapter 6). However, for the most part in Bell's study artistic and legal practices run parallel to each other, suggesting a continued division between restorative justice (that art may provide) and retributive justice (that the courtroom may provide). For instance, in chapter 4 Bell brings the readers to the courtroom of the large trial against 18 Navy men (whose arguments and spatial arrangement remind readers of the lack of consensus over the past) and juxtaposes this trial against today's memorial ESMA; other than mentioning that some spaces in the ESMA were roped off from the public during the trials, little is made of the possibility of this space and the activities and engagements therein staged might have opened up or advanced the possibility of accountability. As Rebecca Atencio in Memory's Turns (2014) has argued, art and legal practices and pursuits may indeed influence each other and push each other to more fully attend to the past or at the very least they might be perceived as emerging simultaneously. A concluding chapter is needed, for in it Bell might have returned to these ‘distinct but related register[s]’ (p. 60), the interplay between culture and transitional justice mechanisms, to understand how new norms take root.
In addition to the introductory chapter, The Art of Post-Dictatorship has six chapters on artists, art practices and sites. Chapter 2 turns to Foucault's notion of biopolitics as a means to think through the call by some for the reappearance of the disappeared. Bell follows in particular the case of Fernando Brodsky who was to reappear in a photograph taken while in detention, a photo that was smuggled out, and later retrieved from the law courts archive after the transition to democracy by his brother Marcelo Brodsky, an artist who later incorporated this photograph in an exhibition. Chapter 3 further develops the idea that art may serve as a critique to power, as a ‘practice of freedom’, by focusing on the work of León Ferrari, ‘a life lived as a series of ethical endeavours’ (p. 37). This chapter ties directly to the theme of the ‘art of existence’ and the occupying of the temporal gap described in the introduction. Chapter 4 shifts from artistic works to spaces of memory production: the ESMA megatrial and conversion of the former centre of detention, torture and disappearance. Chapter 5 complements well the previous chapter by turning to the Parque de Memoria and the different ethical questions raised by turning this space into a site of remembrance and how art facilitates such labour. Chapter 6 looks as well at the transformation of the former detention site D2 to a memory museum, but Bell also uses this chapter, and the museum's strong presence of photographs to return to her earlier discussions of photographs as both absence and presence, and how they invite the viewer to see this past. The book ends with a final chapter on two artists Diana Dowek and Lucinda Quiero as a means to consider how they have ‘“answered” the events of their lives through the making of artworks’ (p. 119).
The book is filled with black-and-white images interspersed in the chapters as well as a sizeable mid-section of plates. Routledge should be commended for including them, especially the colour plates for the contrast of the sombre subject and at times the bright colours of the artwork (such as Ferrari's bright pink sculpture ‘Espectadora’) is important to Bell's argument. The last plate in Bell's book is from Quieto's series ‘Archaeology of absence.’ The image is of a young Argentine whose parents were disappeared by the state. Projected upon her naked back is a photograph of her parents holding her, their baby; now a young adult, she gently tilts her head to the photo on her back, expressing tender remembrance and an ongoing encounter. This artwork captures well Bell's central argument that art makes manifest the space in between this past and the future.
