The broad scope of this book honoring the historian Maurice Meisner reflects the intellectual diversity of his students, with chapters ranging from early-twentieth-century radicalism to environmental history. Nonetheless, the book coheres around several themes that engage with Meisner's pioneering scholarship on the Chinese revolution and socialism. Many of the authors build on his insights that China's backwardness prior to the 1949 revolution influenced the voluntarism and utopian thought of China's Marxist revolutionaries, most notably Mao Zedong. In keeping with Meisner's focus on ideology, the authors’ study of Chinese radicalism is premised on the importance of ideas and how men and women acted on those ideas. In contrast to much recent scholarship, which has rejected the once dominant revolutionary paradigm for a modernization paradigm in which China's revolutionary socialist experience is treated as an aberration, the authors argue for the revolution's centrality and potential to provide a critical resource for a more democratic and just future.
Sooyoung Kim's study of Chen Duxiu's pre-Marxist thought emphasizes how his conception of individualism and nationalism were mutually supportive as he grappled with new values to address China's crisis. Chen's linkage between individual moral values and the nation-building project would be highly influential among Chinese revolutionaries, an issue that merits further exploration. In a stimulating comparative analysis of Mao Zedong and Liang Shuming, Catherine Lynch underscores the two men's belief in the means used to achieve utopia, whereby utopia could be found in a future good time, “euchronia.” Lynch departs from the standard interpretation of Liang as a conservative, “last Confucian” to highlight how he shared Mao's populist, utopian streak and belief in the ability of human consciousness to create a new society. Lynch thus rejects the view that Mao was singular in his utopian propensity or that its form in “late Maoism” only defined that utopianism. Tina Mai Chen also builds on Meisner's insight that revolutionary transformation for Mao depended on a transformation of the subjective world, while applying a feminist reading of Maoist texts from the 1920s and 1950s. Chen reveals how Mao's advocacy of collectivization during the mid-1950s used the trope of feudal women as “untimely specters” to remind his contemporaries that the revolutionary potential of women and peasants had to be “imagined, created, and brought into being” (p. 72).
Seconding the scholarship of Melvyn Goldstein, Lee Feigon shows that mutual respect and moderation characterized the relationship between the Fourteenth Dalai Lama and Mao up through 1957. Feigon suggests that, despite his condemnation of Han chauvinism and willingness to delay reforms in Central Tibet, Mao could do little to restrain overzealous Han Chinese cadres, prevent internal rifts among the Tibetan leadership, or mitigate geopolitical forces, such as CIA involvement, that bolstered Chinese hard liners’ repressive approach to Tibet. Less well explained, however, is why Mao pursued radical reforms in Kham and Amdo, which ultimately triggered the uprising of 1959.
Building on many of the themes heralded in Meisner's The Deng Xiaoping Era: An Inquiry into the Fate of Chinese Socialism, 1878–1944 (New York: Hill and Wang, 1996), Thomas Lutze provides a useful overview of how the emergence of a capitalist rural economy has spurred thousands of farmer protests. Lutze highlights the privatization of land use, the growth of a rural bourgeoisie, the privatization of rural enterprises that have discarded the collective ethos, and the exploitation of wage labor. Paul G. Pickowicz's vivid account of three contemporary underground films, These Dogs Belong to All of Us (dir. Zhang Zhanqing, 2003), Better to Live Than to Die (dir. Chen Weijun, 2003), and Red Snow (dir. Peng Tao, 2006), complements Lutze's chapter by showing the seamy underside and gritty reality of rural life, the dog-eat-dog mentality fostered by unbridled capitalism and callous disregard for human life by party cadres. Although Robert Marks acknowledges how rapid industrialization under the ideological guidance of Maoist voluntarism contributed to China's deforestation after 1949, he argues that commercial interests unleashed during the reform era have quickened the pace of environmental degradation. Marks cautions that China's biodiversity has suffered from recent afforestation projects, however well intentioned, that substitute large numbers of seedlings for healthy forests and mature trees. In keeping with these critical assessments of the reform era, Bruce Cumings demonstrates how pundits’ and experts’ fixation with the “rise of China” metaphor coincides with their denial of U.S. military dominance in the Pacific and its economic power, which has only expanded since 9/11. Cumings faults much of the literature for ignoring historical links between the Maoist and reform eras and for accepting at face value China's aspirations to restore its traditional global centrality.
For a conference-based volume convened on the twentieth anniversary of June 4, 1989, it is surprising that the book overlooks the role of social movements and the question of Communist Party relations with social forces during the revolution. Moreover, since the book purports to show the relevance of the revolution to contemporary life, discussion would be warranted of how China's “New Left” grapples with its socialist legacy. Nevertheless, the authors should be commended for raising questions about social justice and demonstrating the centrality of the Chinese revolution, thus honoring Maurice Meisner's scholarly legacy.
