Lise Storm's Party Politics and the Prospects for Democracy in North Africa is an informative book about North Africa's political parties. Comparing Morocco, Algeria, and Tunisia, Storm argues that political parties in these countries have become vehicles of personalism, clientelism, and co-optation rather than spearheads of democratization. The parties, she emphasizes, have sought to realize the interests of their leaders rather than the preferences of their voters.
To build her argument, Storm draws on Steven Wolinetz's classification of political parties into three types: policy seeking, vote seeking, and office seeking. Whereas policy-seeking parties appear mostly in developed industrialized democracies such as the United States and France, the latter two types proliferate in the political systems of developing countries. Although Wolinetz's typology was conceived for Western political parties, Storm deftly applies it to the North African context, finding that nearly all of the parties fall within the vote-seeking or office-seeking classification and none of them meet the policy-seeking criteria. Storm's explication of the Western political party literature and evaluation of its applicability (and nonapplicability) to North African politics is perhaps the most incisive portion of the book. Students and scholars of Arab politics could benefit from her insightful analysis.
Having laid out the frame of her study, Storm's next step is to outline how party elites and candidates benefit from these systems of clientelism and personalism. In other words, what “goodies” come from participation in parties, and who gets what, when, and why? For the case of Morocco, Storm's main country of expertise, answering these questions would require a deeper investigation of the services that party elites provide to their supporters, such as the acquisition of public licenses and government jobs. It would also require an analysis of politics outside of the legislature since many clientelist transactions take place in the municipalities (known as communes), though this is beyond the scope of Storm's book (a study of legislative politics). Ultimately, Storm introduces but does not complete this topic, marking it as fruitful terrain for future researchers interested in North African political parties.
The book could have better defined and specified the concept of co-optation—what Storm describes as the makhzen-ization of parties (p. 54). Although emphasized throughout the text (e.g., pp. 4, 6, 13, 49, 50, 51, and 181), it is never fully explained. At a certain point, the book seems to conflate political participation with co-optation: any participation in the elections system, whether by a party or a politician, is taken as evidence of co-optation. The situation is clearly more complicated than this, as not everyone is equally co-opted or “co-optable.” How can Morocco's Islamist party be a co-opted organization when it was nearly banned by the Ministry of the Interior after the Casablanca bombings of 2003? How can the decision of Morocco's socialists to participate in formal politics in 1975 be understood as co-optation when they suffered arrests following the urban riots of the 1980s? Moreover, significant variation exists in the “co-optability” of politicians. Compare, for example, the Islamist Mustafa Ramid, the socialist Fathallah Oualalou, the palace-insider Fuʾad ʿAli al-Himma, and rural tribal notables. Variation in the co-optability of Moroccan politicians is also apparent within the parties themselves. Take the leadership of Morocco's socialists: individuals deemed close to the monarchy's inner circle, such as Driss Lachgar, sit beside those considered outside its realm of control, such as the recently passed eminent sociologist, Mohamed Guessous. Eva Wegner and Michael Willis have more cogently explained this delicate dance of Moroccan politics in which politicians and political parties push for democratizing change while recognizing the regime-imposed glass ceiling on reform. In other words, politicians and political parties pursue their interests, both economic and electoral, while realizing that the regime has its own immobile interests, both economic and electoral. Storm's book begins—though does not complete—the task of untangling these issues.
The reason for this may be that unlike Storm's excellent earlier work, Democratization in Morocco (New York: Routledge, 2007), a hallmark example of embedded fieldwork featuring interviews with party luminaries such as Ahmad Osman, Muhammad al-Yazghi, and ʿAli Belhaj, this new book utilizes neither field interviews nor Arabic sources. This reader remains unconvinced when the author asserts that Morocco's Islamists have been “completely makhzenized” (p. 181), without presenting interviews from their leaders or articles from their party newspaper. The inclusion of Islamist voices detailing why they entered the political system and how they benefited from this choice would have enhanced the argument.
In general, scholars of North African politics could use local Arabic materials more thoroughly, following in the footsteps of their colleagues working on Egypt and Jordan, who have been drawing on such materials for years. Given the fact that Morocco's second largest Arabic newspaper, as-Sabah, has an excellent online archive, and that the Islamist newspaper, at-Tajdid, has a well-organized physical archive in Rabat, with newspapers dating from the 1970s to the present, limited accessibility is no longer an excuse for not examining these primary sources. It is important to note that Arabic newspapers like as-Sabah and al-Massae have a larger national readership than French-language newspapers like L’économiste and the weekly magazine Tel-Quel, which service Casablanca's business community. The latter two newspapers may present a narrower perspective on events than the former two.
On the whole, Storm has made an important contribution to research on North Africa's political party scene, for which there is a dearth of recent empirical information. Rather than overwhelm the reader with obscure details, she conveys the core information on these countries. Engaging fruitfully with the available literature on North Africa in English and French, her book is a welcome contribution and will benefit scholars and students alike.
