Luis Martinez's timely book offers insight on the current political situation in Libya, namely, the regime's transition from a black sheep of the international community to an accepted actor on the diplomatic scene based on its commitment to the global “war on terror.” Although this has been achieved through the conscious and pragmatic efforts of President Muʿammar Gadhafi to reconstruct his image, Martinez argues that little has changed on the ground in the way of political liberalization. In addition, although oil incomes have bought prosperity for much of the Libyan population, making it one of the wealthiest countries on the African continent, Martinez demonstrates that these monies have also been channeled into the security apparatus, reflecting the common pattern of rentier states able to purchase political quiescence.
This concise study of contemporary politics and political ideology begins with a presentation of the political and economic impact of international sanctions from 1992 to 2003. Martinez focuses on what he hesitantly labels the “conversion” of the regime, particularly between 2001 and 2003, and how this results from the personal interests of Gadhafi; he concludes with an examination of whether political reform is possible.
The first section, covering the 1990s, illustrates the economic and medical costs of international sanctions imposed by the United Nations Security Council. Although the standard of living in Libya, literacy rates, and medical care had all improved dramatically since the end of colonial rule, and particularly since Gadhafi's rise to power, much of this success was the direct result of his redistribution of oil incomes, which stagnated under the sanctions. The contrast between expectations and reality, Martinez suggests, resulted in popular frustration, criticism of Gadhafi, and popular resentment toward African immigrants (the connection between African immigrants and popular racism appears more anecdotal than systematic, however). To illustrate this, Martinez considers how a sector of entrepreneurs, primarily businessmen involved in cross-border trade, were able to profit from these conditions. Entitled “The ‘young revolutionaries’ and the voyage to Malta: Rai music, sex, money and sport,” the section does not include an analysis of rai lyrics or how they represent the spirit of “young revolutionaries.” Without references from news media, television, popular jokes, or music, it is difficult to see the breadth of “the social transformations that took place during the sanctions” (p. 12) or even how prevalent criticism of the regime was.
In the second chapter, Martinez examines how Gadhafi's efforts to end economic and diplomatic sanctions were accelerated by 9/11, specifically through his commitment to “fighting terror” alongside the United States. Martinez pinpoints the role of fear and Gadhafi's concern that the U.S. invasion of Iraq in 2003 would be followed by similar military interventions into Libya, although the transition also appears to be a highly pragmatic strategy of a man who has been able to maintain authority for over three decades (through a combination of repression and what could be considered financially coercive methods). Gadhafi's own actions, such as his insistence that the Libyan Islamic Fighting Group be placed on the State Department list of terrorist organizations, are less a sign of fear and more another sad example of an authoritarian regime using the label of terrorism and Islamic fundamentalism as a way to earn international support and arms supplies to stifle domestic opposition (as has skillfully been demonstrated by Tunisia's ben ʿAli and Algeria's Boutefliqa). One could also argue for a considerable amount of continuity in Gadhafi's political positions. Whereas in the earlier phase of his regime political opponents (including those Martinez terms “Islamists”) were labeled imperialist tools, in the current climate Gadhafi has wisely chosen to consider them terrorists (throughout relying on arbitrary arrests and possible use of torture to obtain information).
Although Martinez is correctly skeptical about the sincerity of Gadhafi's “conversion,” his assessment of Libya as a “terrorist” state would have benefitted from a clear definition of the term. At times it appears to be a reflection of U.S. State Department lists, at others an assessment of Gadhafi's Anti-Imperialism Center and support for revolutionary regimes in Africa and Latin America struggling against imperialism, which Martinez refers to as “the Libyan regime's ambitious terrorist policy” (p. 54). For instance, Martinez notes that the number of terrorist acts that the Gadhafi regime has been linked to declined in the 1990s; yet without explicitly stating what constitutes an “act of terrorism” or how Gadhafi has “supported or sponsored” them, the value of these calculations is diminished (p. 53). Such statements would have been better supported in a discussion of specific examples of the regime's activities and detailed explanations of why these are terrorist rather than anti-imperial policies. This lack of theoretical clarity similarly pervades his later discussion of “Islamists” and their “jihad.”
The third chapter focusing on Gadhafi is by far the strongest because it offers a clear picture of the organizational structure of the Libyan state under Gadhafi. This appears crucial in understanding the political, economic, and social change because Gadhafi plays a central role in the decision-making process. This chapter provides a useful introduction to readers less familiar with contemporary Libya. It covers the influence of Nasser and pan-Arabism on Gadhafi's revolution as well as his efforts toward African unity, his socialist rhetoric, the democratic structures in place since 1969, and the redistributions of oil incomes to improve the national standard of living. Although Martinez offers insight on various personalities in the government, Gadhafi's own family plays the most visible and continuous role in politics.
Finally, Martinez regrets that Libya's impressive figures regarding industrial development, expanded health care and literacy, national production, and standards of living have all been achieved by centralization and state sponsorship. This follows a model of political power not conducive to democratization. Thus, despite efforts toward partnerships with Europe and the United States, Martinez sees little opportunity for economic success to lead to political change.
Although Martinez's book offers prescient insight on Gadhafi's efforts to reintegrate into the international scene as an accepted partner in diplomatic and economic relations, it contains less depth on how other political figures within the government have responded to this ideological transition and how much support Gadhafi (or his son and probable successor Sayf al-Islam) have within the government. In part, this may be a result of sources; the footnotes do not mention government documents or official memos, Arabic-language newspapers, or other primary sources such as blogs or popular music. There is no bibliography.
Although the text includes passages from personal interviews, Martinez dismisses the possibility of further examining how Libyans have responded to Gadhafi's about-face, claiming that “Libyan public opinion is impossible to fathom” (p. 105). Although his focus is decidedly on Gadhafi's position in international circles, further examination of how these policies and rhetoric are viewed and experienced in Libya would have been a worthwhile addition, particularly considering the scarcity of English language research on contemporary Libya. Yet, despite obscuring the importance of culture in understanding political history, Martinez provides a welcome and useful overview of political trends in Libya over the past three decades.
