A trading or market order is constituted by an indefinitely large number of exchanges between an indefinitely large number of natural and legal persons, each of whom may, in theory at least, trade an indefinite number of times with any other. Since a trading order is simply the set of exchanges between those who trade, it is essentially trans-jurisdictional; that is, it tends naturally to globalisation. But no trading order, whether considered nationally or transnationally, exists in a vacuum: trading orders exist as one order – along with, for example, linguistic orders and jural orders – within broader, all-encompassing social orders. Social orders exist in association with state and interstate organisation and thus are subject to various organisational influences. State intervention in the trading order is one such organisational influence and is ubiquitous; it includes fiat currency, control of the money supply, direct and indirect taxation, and multifarious forms of regulation of market activities and institutions.
The appropriate nature and extent of state interventionism in modern economies is something about which people disagree (just as they disagree about the range of services that should be provided by the state) and about which there is no dearth of scholarship. There is such a dearth, however, on the subject of state participation in the market. In order to fulfil their functions, governments not only collect and distribute revenue and other compulsory contributions, they also engage in trade by purchasing everything from paper clips to aerospace technology. In this book Christopher McCrudden observes that although this government activity is ‘long something of a Cinderella area of academic study’, governments ‘play an increasingly important role as an active participant in the market, purchasing public works, supplies, and services’ (p. 3).
Buying Social Justice is, in the first instance at least, a book about the law regulating government contracting or public procurement, but in addition to providing an analysis of this law in national and transnational context, it examines how governments use this activity to produce ‘social justice’ results. The author calls this use of procurement ‘linkage’, and this work focuses on linkages in which governments use their purchasing power to advance equality and non-discrimination goals. If the government is buying paper clips or aerospace technology or anything else, how may such purchasing be used to advance the goal of, for example, gender or racial equality? Can government procurement advance these goals? More fundamentally, should it be used to advance such goals? And what about instances – such as legislation enacted in Massachusetts in 1996 regarding Myanmar (formerly Burma) – when procurement linkages attempt to bring economic pressure to bear on foreign governments by penalising companies that are involved in these countries?
In the ‘Preface’ the author gives a personal account of how and why he became involved with the issue of government procurement, and he recounts his involvement in various United Kingdom (relating principally to Northern Ireland), European and international initiatives. He draws on both this experience and the theoretical literature in setting out the arguments for and against procurement linkages. Although the overall view is ‘a complex picture of apparently competing considerations that seem to be starkly at odds with each other’ (p. 128), McCrudden suggests that on balance a good positive theoretical case can be made for procurement linkages to advance social equality. Moreover, in practical terms, although many economists argue against the practice on grounds of inefficiency and many lawyers do so on grounds of international economic law, Buying Social Justice argues that it is an efficient and legal means of achieving status equality and social policy goals generally.
In the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, United States and European governments used public procurement in the domestic context not only to realise particular social policy goals but also to stimulate economic activity, to protect national industry against foreign competition, to improve the competitiveness of certain industrial sectors, and to remedy regional disparities. Buying Social Justice provides an historical overview of these uses of procurement, which included efforts to realise social goals like ensuring fair working conditions, such as minimum wage and maximum hours, and the increased utilisation of the disabled in employment. Modern procurement systems developed alongside the development of the welfare state and ‘it is hardly surprising that the former was used in part to underpin the latter's goals’ (p. 13).
There is also detailed discussion of historical and theoretical developments in equal status law and policy that have helped to stimulate the development of equality-based procurement linkages. While there are traditionally two main functional models to which antidiscrimination law conforms – an individual justice model (concentrating on securing fairness for the individual) and a group justice model (concerned with the relative position of groups or classes) – McCrudden also charts the attempts to secure the implementation of equality norms extra-territorially, and through the introduction of equality ‘mainstreaming’ processes. The limitations of traditional enforcement of individual justice approaches, for example, encouraged several jurisdictions to adopt procurement linkages as an additional enforcement mechanism, and linkages were central to the ‘MacBride principles’, the set of antidiscrimination principles that US investors in Northern Ireland were encouraged to adopt from 1984 onwards.
Increasingly, procurement choices at the national level are influenced by international decisions, and a central theme of this book is ‘the interplay of domestic and international influences on the trajectory of procurement policy’ (p. 16). Indeed, the bulk of the book considers the development and characteristics of domestic procurement linkages and the relationship between these and the development of transnational procurement regulation. Although numerous transnational legal instruments address procurement, the two approaches considered in depth in this book are those of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) and the World Trade Organization (WTO) on the one hand, and those of the European Community (EC) on the other hand. Although these two transnational approaches ‘developed in close relationship’ and ‘cross-fertilized’ each other (p. 16), there are nonetheless significant differences between them. The original GATT explicitly excluded government procurement from its non-discrimination provisions. However, during the 1960s, when the EC was beginning the process of limiting discrimination in government procurement by adopting two action plans to reduce restrictions on access to government contracts, a procurement dispute between Belgium and the United States, arising out of a change to the Buy American Act 1933, sparked negotiations at the Organization of Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) that resulted, in 1979, in an international agreement on rules to liberalise and improve the transparency of procurement. In 1994, many trading states entered into a broader and very significant Government Procurement Agreement (GPA).
The book emphasises the different experiences of a range of countries in the context, first, of the GPA and, second, of the EC. In the main, developing countries like Malaysia and South Africa – which represent prominent examples of the use of procurement linkages to achieve equal status goals – have not sought to join the GPA, although there may be some indirect influence of the GPA and the WTO in the case of non-members. For example, although Myanmar is not a member of the GPA and so could not invoke GPA disciplines against the United States with regard to the Massachusetts law of 1996 mentioned above, the disciplines were nonetheless relevant in the United States litigation that resulted in the law being held to be unconstitutional. The development and specific forms of procurement linkages in the United States and Canada, which are GPA members, are also set out in detail. These forms include, for example, linkages in the form of affirmative action ‘set-asides’, which link the award of government contracts to programmes that advantage particular status groups considered to be economically disadvantaged by giving preferences to businesses that are owned or controlled by such groups in the award of contracts.
In considering the development of procurement linkages in the EC context – in which one of the most developed of social policy approaches is that relating to status equality – McCrudden emphasizes that the debate in the EC about the appropriate relationship between public procurement and equality is a classic example of where the tension between the ‘economic’ and the ‘social’ is most in evidence:
‘From the point of view of (some) equal status advocates, the use of procurement for these purposes is a natural consequence of moves to “mainstream” equality throughout governmental decision-making. From the point of view of (some) European procurement practitioners, this use of procurement threatens to undermine the transparency and fairness of procurement systems, thus delaying the achievement of the single market in Europe.’ (p. 20)
McCrudden traces the scepticism and opposition of the Council of Ministers and the European Commission to the practice and how, despite these efforts to suppress the social use of procurement, by 2006 such linkages ‘were firmly on the agenda of several Member States to an extent that would have seemed unthinkable ten years earlier’ (p. 573). The introduction of equality mainstreaming was significant in this regard, as was the greater legal clarity provided by European Court of Justice decisions and the reformed procurement directives of 2003.
The relationship between the movements for status quality and public procurement aiming at achieving greater economic efficiency is complex and multifaceted, as is the debate about the pros and cons of procurement linkages more generally. Buying Social Justice, as noted above, argues in favour of these linkages; it also proposes that the European and international legal regulation of procurement can be interpreted as providing ‘sufficient legal space … to permit wide-ranging use of procurement linkages’ (p. 574) and thus as an important means of accentuating the positive in both the social and economic uses of procurement.
Buying Social Justice provides a thorough guide to the issues at stake in considering procurement linkages. Its rigour and originality were acknowledged in 2008 when the book was awarded the American Society of International Law's Certificate of Merit for a Preeminent Contribution to Creative Scholarship. The author raises questions that are both serious and difficult and he does so in a particularly exacting and scholarly way, but perhaps he attempts to address too many different types of questions in too many contexts. One wonders, indeed, if there might not properly be more than one book in the material between the covers of Buying Social Justice. In the ‘Preface’ McCrudden leaves it to the reader to decide if his personal involvement in various procurement initiatives has enabled him to capture fully the complexity of the issues, explaining the tensions generated in a way that makes them understandable and – as he argues – resolvable. It could be said that there is simply too much detailed information, too much theory and too much analysis in the book for the reader to answer an unequivocal ‘yes’ to his question.
Buying Social Justice is insufficiently clear regarding the nature of justice but, ironically perhaps (given the book's title), this is the one – indeed the only – piece of the jigsaw that the author leaves out deliberately. At the outset, McCrudden eschews any assumption that any particular technical meaning is being adopted when he refers to ‘social justice’: his concern ‘is to concentrate on a particular instance of what has been conceived as an example of a concern with social justice: the attempt to eradicate unjust discrimination and advance social equality’ (p. 3). The author is wise to frame his analysis in such loose terms vis-à-vis the idea of justice. The subject of his book relates to the question of imposing organisational conditions on the operation of the trading order with a view to bringing about changes in the social order. Justice within the trading order is reciprocal, and concerned only with the justice involved in the individual transactions that constitute the order (Barden and Murphy, Reference Barden and Murphy2010, chapter 5). It is not, and cannot be, concerned with the overall pattern or outcome at any given time of the assignment of participants' resources, whether resources are considered in material, status or any other terms. Certainly, state regulation or interventionism can influence the trading order, but it cannot – unless the ‘intervention’ successfully prohibits trade – guarantee any outcome. McCrudden cites Karen Yeung's view that the aim of any form of regulation ‘is to modify the behaviour of those subject to regulation in order to generate a desired outcome’ (Yeung, Reference Yeung and McCrudden1999, p. 37, quoted at p. 64), but this type of thinking is a classic instance of overestimating the power of organisational influences on pre-existing (and they are always pre-existing) orders.
McCrudden's wisdom in not dwelling on the subject of ‘social justice’ must therefore be qualified by the fact that this means that certain relevant theoretical questions are not addressed. It seems to the present reviewer that these questions would move more to the foreground of future debates if more attention were paid to the practical question of whether procurement linkages ‘work’, that is, whether they succeed in achieving their goals. As the author notes in concluding this work, empirical research testing the extent to which relevant theoretical arguments are accurate is in its infancy in many countries; none of the advantages or disadvantages of procurement linkages shown by various existing empirical studies is guaranteed or inevitable; and there is therefore ‘a clear need for further empirical research of the phenomenon’ (p. 616).
