It is always a pleasure to welcome a new book by one of our most prolific and distinguished historians of science. Here we find David Knight tackling the history of science in the long nineteenth century, over two decades since he published The Age of Science (1986). The reader will not be disappointed. This is a longer, fuller and more comprehensive study.
Knight opens by asking how science became a practical, intellectual and social activity. He provides a masterly introduction to the way history has been written, professing himself ‘an opportunist’ (p. 10) who picks from different historiographic traditions in order to suit his subject matter and context. This allows him to arrange his material thematically, in broad chronological order but ranging widely in time, place and coverage. He does not recount the development of each of the sciences separately, but draws on different fields and disciplines which best illustrate his themes. Chemistry features prominently, but both the physical sciences and natural history are treated at length. Knight starts with science in and after 1789, describing advances in the sciences which generated both poetic enchantment and a sense of unease. This is followed by a discussion of the languages of science, and the ways in which we are taught to speak scientifically, aiming for objectivity while confronting the fact of the instability of nature and the limitations of knowledge. Science applied to practical problems soon showed its power to transform the world through technology and encouraged the development of educational systems to provide the necessary trained engineers and technical specialists.
Chapters follow on intellectual excitement, created above all by the two great syntheses of conservation of energy and evolution; on the development of public health and medical education; on where and how science was done (the growth of laboratories); and on the fringe sciences of phrenology and psychical research. Knight pauses in the 1850s and 1860s – the ‘Time of Triumph’ – noting the growth of ‘honest doubt’ along with the Church Scientific, before examining the role of science in nation-building and competitiveness. He then examines method and heresy, how different methods of doing science were adopted, the role of science in culture, and its rise to a leading position, ending with a chapter on science at the opening of the twentieth century. A timeline follows which should stimulate the most sluggish mind (shaking palsy, famine in Ireland, mammoths in Siberia, diffraction gratings, radioactivity, Rutherford's new alchemy), followed by extensive notes and references. The latter fill a fifth of the book and provide a superb introduction to the key literature on the subject, original texts and broader reading. For example, Nicholas Rodger's Command of the Ocean: A Naval History of Britain 1669–1815 (2004) stands as a reference for the ‘world wars’ of the eighteenth century.
Knight is a realist in the philosophical sense, but provides a sensitive account of why people feared a materialistic science which denied the existence of the soul or a transcendental life. He writes with great empathy about how science was and is done, stressing the importance of little things – such as the development of rubber tubing for laboratory work – as well as the data-trimming methods which can blur into cooking the results and, at the extreme, the outright forging and hoaxing which can so damagingly erode trust. Each chapter is helpfully divided into sections, with catchy headings which capture the essence of his themes – ‘Disenchantment?’, ‘Feeding the world’, ‘Sterile and tidy?’, ‘Learning from experience’ and so on. He skilfully describes key theoretical concepts while ensuring that the story is grounded in people and places. He has an enviable ability to conjure up a person or situation with a few well-chosen words, to select a fresh and illuminating anecdote, or to convey the colour of debates about different approaches and the ‘right’ method for doing science, be it ‘vaulting deductive’ or ‘plodding inductive’. The story may be a little Anglocentric, but there are enough references to provide a sense of international developments and contexts.
The book is peppered with the reflections of a historian who has read widely and deeply in his subject. He remains an optimist in the face of much disillusion about the effects of twentieth-century science. He loves science and he loves history. This work is a splendid example of how to communicate that enthusiasm and should be on reading lists for both science and history students.
