iMuslims represents Gary Bunt's third attempt to explain the content of cyber Islamic environments (CIEs) and their implication for the practice and meaning of Islam. His book Virtually Islamic: Computer Mediated Communication and Cyber Islamic Environments (Cardiff: University of Wales Press, 2002) provided a first glimpse at what happens when Islam meets the Internet, with a specific focus on how the Internet shapes what Muslims recognize as Islam and its authority. Bunt's second book on CIEs, Islam in the Digital Jihad, Online Fatwas, and Cyber Islamic Environments (London: Pluto Press, 2003), focuses on CIEs, Islamist activism, and authority in cyberspace. Readers wanting a schematic mapping of what exactly Bunt means by “CIEs” will be grateful for an illustration in his third book, iMuslims (pp. 46–47). In all three texts, Bunt defines CIEs as “the different zones of cyberspace that represent varied Muslim worldviews within the House of Islam, all of which present a reference point of identity with a conceptualization of Islam” (p. 1). In his third book, iMuslims, Bunt explores the ways in which “specific forms of online or digital Islam, distinct from offline or analogue Islam have developed.” He justifies this choice to limit a study of Islam to what happens in CIEs by observing that “a place of religious instruction may only exist in a virtual context. A network or community may only gather online” (p. 1). In essence, the subject of Bunt's investigation is a “Wiki-oriented” form of Islam (p. 2). Through six chapters and a conclusion, Bunt argues that CIEs have had “an overarching transformational effect on how Muslims practice Islam” in addition to “how forms of Islam are represented” (p. 3). In a nutshell, Bunt's argument is that profound changes occur when “Islam and the Internet combine” (p. 275).
Chapter 1, “Locating Islam in Cyberspace,” traces the development of “the global Islamic knowledge economy,” or in other words, “the flow of data about Islam that is circulating via the Internet” (p. 12). One methodological challenge involved with studying CIEs and discussed in this chapter is that “substantial material online is lost to study, as it is not formally archived or preserved” (p. 20). Bunt struggles against the potential ephemeral nature of Islam online by maintaining his own archive of Islamic cyber environments. His efforts are displayed on his Virtually Islamic blog: http://virtuallyislamic.blogspot.com.
A second methodological challenge discussed in this chapter, and which recurs throughout the text, is ascertaining the impact of CIEs. Bunt wants to argue that CIEs are “rewiring the house of Islam” (p. 7), but he acknowledges that “given the fluid and random nature that surfing the Internet can take, measuring the impact of any one site raises a number of issues” (p. 39). Most of his statements about the impact of CIEs are thus contingent. The main purpose of the book is instead to explore Islamic online environments and to explain how the addition of digital forms of Islamic awareness and practice could transform Islam, both in its online and offline forms.
In Chapter 2, “Accessing Cyber-Islamic Environments,” Bunt takes a step away from his focus on CIEs in order to consider the question of access—who participates in CIEs, and how do they access the Internet? Bunt's main focus here is to explain that “Muslim networks may connect online, but this connection is not a universal one” (p. 55). This is because not all Muslims have access to the Internet. Chapter 2 is Bunt's attempt to map which Muslims have access to the Internet. Throughout the chapter he illustrates that the “digital divide” has “a clear impact in Muslim contexts and for Muslim networks” (p. 55). Bunt argues that as access to the Internet increases “through cheaper hardware and open-source applications,” this “will have a profound effect on how Islam is articulated and Muslim networks are shaped in the twenty-first century” (p. 75).
Chapter 3, “Decoding the Sacred: Islamic Source Code,” looks at “the digitization of many long-standing essential concepts and practices associated with Islam, including ideas of the sacred, within Muslim frameworks” (p. 77). Through this analysis, Bunt provides a “digital glimpse into the shared religious experiences of Muslims” (p. 78). From online Qurʾans, to processes of witnessing, discussions of Zakat, the Hajj, holidays, online fatwas, dating, financial transactions, and death, Bunt explores in this chapter how “from cradle to grave, the elements of (Muslim) human life are located online” (p. 102). In the conclusion to this chapter, Bunt again articulates a methodological challenge of his research when he observes that “we may never know the impact of online fatwas in terms of individuals or the number of people who follow them, but they can form an influential source of searchable materials for surfers seeking discrete answers to difficult questions” (p. 129).
In Chapters 4 to 6, Bunt organizes elements of CIEs thematically into three different realms of digital Muslim experience, each with an activist motivation. Chapter 4 examines the Islamic blogosphere to illustrate that “Blogs have become critical adjuncts to the Islamic knowledge economy,” which support “a dynamic space for iMuslims to participate in online collaboration and forms of information gathering and exchange” (p. 131). In Chapter 5, Bunt examines “militaristic Jihad in Cyberspace,” especially focusing “on al-Qaeda as a conceptual entity.” The Internet in this case “has become a crucial adjunct for individual and group self-knowledge and reinforcement, especially within microjihadi networks.” Through these networks, iMuslims can engage in e-jihad and “articulate solutions to popular causes in a radical way” (p. 186). Chapter 6 provides a more focused view of how e-jihad “relates to specific regional contexts of Iraq and Palestine” (p. 186). In all three cases of cyber activism, Bunt skillfully illustrates how “at a relatively low cost, in terms of media, the status of certain parties and players has radically increased through the Net” (p. 262). Bunt is careful to contextualize jihadi discourse and activism online when he observes that attention to e-jihad should not eclipse “an understanding of the relatively quieter forms of traditional and contemporary Islamic understanding” that predominate in CIEs (p. 282).
In the conclusion, Bunt summarizes the main message of his text, which is to trace the emergence of iMuslims and to illustrate the ways in which Islamic “traditional practices may not have been replaced, but alternative options for their enactment have been provided online” (pp. 279–80). Bunt states that at the end of this journey to explore CIEs in depth, he can offer thirteen illustrations of what it means to be an iMuslim. In addition to being well connected to the Internet, an iMuslim may, for example, “search the Internet for information relating to an issue of religious interpretation” or “use the Internet as a propagation tool to convert others to Islam or to an Islamic worldview” (p. 280). While the list goes on to reflect the nuances of Bunt's rich textual exploration of Muslim cyberspace, the main message is the same. When the Internet meets Islam, interesting new relationships, both real and virtual, emerge.
This text is suitable for both the undergraduate and graduate classroom. It is written in accessible language and will appeal to the specialist and nonspecialist alike. Bunt's work fills a niche market that has received less academic attention than it deserves. Only in the area of jihadi online activism does Bunt have any real competition. One hope in regard to future texts that Bunt may craft is that he finds a way to respond to some of the methodological tensions inherent in his approach. For example, his argument would be even more satisfying had he included voices of Muslims on the parts of CIEs that they find most useful and meaningful in their everyday lives. This could be accomplished by survey research as well as through software designed to trace how bits and bytes flow in Muslim cyberspace. A second, but related, concern is that while Bunt is interested in the relationship between online and offline religious expression, activism, and community, his focus on CIEs does not allow us to see or understand the linkages. Again, surveys of Muslim Internet users could provide the missing link. These requests for more analysis and an expanded look at what it means to be Muslim in the 21st century in no way detract from the value and skill with which Bunt guides us through a seemingly boundless and potentially contradictory cyberspace.
