In this excellent exposé of the history of slavery from its legal abolition to contemporary manifestations, Professor Joel Quirk fills a serious gap in the study of this issue and lucidly addresses the inevitable trait-d'union existing between past and present in slavery studies. Unfortunately, as correctly pointed out by Quirk, scholars focusing on the history of slavery and those studying contemporary practices tend to work in parallel without extended links and co-operation; the hope is that this book will encourage them to walk more on a common path.
The book is coherently organized and it is subdivided in three parts. The first one discusses in three chapters how the legal abolition of slavery in the British Empire was based on a ‘moral redemption’ ideal and not on a complete ‘rejection of the prevailing social order’ (p. 53). The second one is subdivided in two chapters that are dedicated to building a bridge between the history of the abolition of slavery and more contemporary practices: Quirk's lucid conclusion is that the former constituted only a necessary – but imperfect – first step, which should have been followed by others, and not the endpoint in this field (p. 137). Finally, the third part examines contemporary exploitative practices and focuses, in particular, on three of them: the one with more ancient roots, namely chattel or classical slavery; debt bondage, which is considered to be the most widespread in the world; and the most debated one in recent times, trafficking in persons. Quirk makes reference to the situation in Mauritania, Niger, and Sudan for the purpose of discussing the issue of chattel slavery; turns to India, Pakistan, and Nepal when analysing debt bondage; and generally focuses on transnational migration to examine human trafficking.
The author definitely convinces the reader that ‘a necessary corrective to a widespread tendency to assume that the problem of slavery came to an end at some indeterminate point in the past’ is needed (p. 6). While, however, he rightly claims that the anti-slavery movement has been constantly in a flux in the last two and a half centuries, his use of the term project, aimed at identifying the anti-slavery movement and its achievements and failures, is less convincing. Quirk defines the term project as referring to a ‘complex task, or undertaking, which usually involves a number of different phases’ (p. 6) and as being opposed to ‘a finished result’ (p. 173). However, the term gives the impression that, since the beginning of the anti-slavery movement, there has been a pre-established plan run or co-ordinated by one or more entities for the purpose of reaching the global abolition of slavery worldwide.Footnote 1 Instead, the reality is more complex than this, and Quirk in this case rightly emphasizes the different actors involved in the anti-slavery movement, the advancements and drawbacks, and the multiple variations of the history of abolition in different parts of the world.
The book lucidly describes the move from the definition of slavery included in the Slavery Convention of 1926 to the Supplementary Convention on the Abolition of Slavery, the Slave Trade and Institutions and Practices Similar to Slavery of 1956 as passing from ‘strict equivalence’ to ‘sufficient similarity’, and it also correctly criticizes the abolition of slavery in as much as it was disconnected from effective emancipation: the image provided by Quirk's reference to a ‘sink or swim approach’ is simple and extremely effective in clarifying the concept (p. 207).
An interesting critique contained in the book is the one related to the use of the term ‘new’ as associated with slavery and ‘modern problems’ (p. 194). Quirk claims that many such contemporary practices have ancient roots and are very much related to the way in which the abolition of slavery was conducted: in other words, the façade of buildings was often renovated but internal structural problems persisted worldwide. While agreeing with Quirk that, in some cases, underlying causes might be shared by past and contemporary exploitative practices, so that we should learn from history and avoid making the same mistakes again, the use of that term by some experts of ‘contemporary slavery’ can also be interpreted as a way to focus more on new characteristics, discontinuity, and difference, as opposed to old patterns, continuity, and similarity. Moreover, some scholars – including myself – mainly used it in relation to trafficking in persons, which is new at least from a definitional point of view, as far as the 2000 Protocol aimed at Preventing and Suppressing Trafficking in Persons, in Particular Women and Children (hereinafter the Trafficking Protocol) is the first international treaty to contain its definition. Finally, it is interesting to emphasize that the UN Working Group of Experts on Slavery,Footnote 2 in its first Report adopted in 1975, emphasized that since the elaboration by the Special Rapporteur on Slavery, Dr Mohamed Awad, of the 1966 Report on Slavery:
it was generally recognized that . . . there had been no substantial changes in the situation of slavery and slave trade in all their practices and manifestations which continued to exist in many parts of the world. On the contrary, the new and subtle forms of slavery which had appeared had even aggravated the position.Footnote 3
The Working Group includes among these new practices the rising of bonded labour in rural societies, and the ‘illicit traffic in persons and especially in women’ from poorer countries to industrialized ones for the purpose of the exploitation of the prostitution of others. It seems, therefore, that, first of all, this connotation was not introduced by some contemporary scholars, and, second, it was implemented by the Working Group as a way to distinguish between traditional slavery and other slavery-like practices. It is also very interesting to emphasize that it was exactly on the basis of this difference that, in 1987, the body justified the proposal to rename itself the Working Group on Contemporary Forms of Slavery.Footnote 4
Quirk also correctly acknowledges the definitional problems related to the boundaries of the concept of slavery as he clarifies that:
In this evolving political environment, the number of practices and institutions that have been formally equated with slavery has steadily increased, making it difficult to identify a coherent rationale linking them together. Is slavery now an analytical category, or an evocative concept? Is slavery now being invoked literally, rhetorically or some indefinite combination of the two? Once slavery is held to come in many number of forms, it is not always easy to determine a point at which slavery begins and ends. (p. 249)
While agreeing with Quirk on this point, it is questionable that ‘[t]his is particularly an issue when it comes to the range of issues that have recently been associated with slavery by the United Nations, such as genital mutilation, incest, honor killings, and the sale of organs’ (p. 249). While it is true that in the past the main UN body dealing with this issue, namely the Working Group on (Contemporary Forms of) Slavery, discussed under the rubric of slavery-like practices certain phenomena that were sometimes lacking a close link to slavery,Footnote 5 a different path is evident since the adoption of the Report prepared by David Weissbrodt and Anti-Slavery International, submitted to the Working Group in 2002. The Report recognizes how:
A number of . . . issues have been considered by the Working Group on Contemporary Forms of Slavery, including apartheid, colonialism, trafficking in human organs and incest. Although these practices generally constitute serious violations, some, including apartheid and colonialism, may not fall within the ambit of the international conventions abolishing slavery.Footnote 6
The same conclusion was reached by the Report in the case of incest, while honour killings and genital mutilations were not taken into consideration and reference to trafficking in human organs – and not to the sale of organs – was made in relation to the adoption of the Trafficking Protocol.Footnote 7
Probably, the definitional problems identified by Quirk in relation to the term slavery led him to resort to the use of a different terminology, introducing human bondage instead (see, inter alia, pp. 4 and 138), for the purpose of referring to both past and present exploitative situations. However, the term is not clearly defined by Quirk and it is up to the reader to understand its extension and limits.
Finally, the book introduces the issue of trafficking in persons: Quirk unfortunately frames the discussion only in terms of transnational migration (p. 217) and he states that ‘if both traffickers and trafficked operate within the boundaries of a single state, they are not formally covered by the [Trafficking] Protocol’ (p. 227). In this way he ignores the internal dimension of the phenomenon: according to the UNODC Legislative Guide on the Implementation of the Trafficking Protocol, ‘transnationality is not required as an element of domestic offences’.Footnote 8 Moreover, Quirk makes reference to the definition of trafficking in adults as included in Article 3(a) of the Trafficking Protocol (p. 226), but he ignores the one related to children included in paragraph (c) of the same provision. A final remark has to do with the title of Chapter 8, ‘Trafficked into Slavery’: the international definition of human trafficking included in the Trafficking Protocol contains a non-exhaustive list of various forms of exploitation, which might constitute the purpose/outcome of a trafficking process. That list includes, but is not limited to, slavery.Footnote 9
Notwithstanding this, Quirk does outstanding work diligently introducing a historical perspective into a debate very much framed in legal and sociological terms. The study of contemporary slavery currently stands at a crossroads between various disciplines, thus making it difficult to adopt a multidisciplinary approach to analyse the various issues at stake. Contributions from various experts and interdisciplinary debates are fundamental for the purpose of completing the puzzle of the knowledge necessary for adopting and implementing the best policies aimed at eradicating serious exploitative practices still existing worldwide. In this framework, among historical accounts of past and contemporary slavery, Quirk's The Anti-Slavery Project – together with Suzanne Miers's Slavery in the Twentieth Century (Altamira Press, 2003) – stands as an important piece of the puzzle.
