Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T02:19:22.451Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Statistical analysis of dental variation in the Oligocene equid Miohippus (Mammalia, Perissodactyla) of Oregon

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  20 July 2017

Nicholas A. Famoso*
Affiliation:
Department of Earth Sciences, 1272 University of Oregon, Eugene, OR 97403, USA 〈nfamoso2@uoregon.edu〉University of Oregon Museum of Natural and Cultural History, 1680 E. 15th Ave., Eugene, OR 97403, USA 〈nfamoso2@uoregon.edu〉John Day Fossil Beds National Monument, National Park Service, 32651 Hwy 19, Kimberly, OR 97848, USA 〈nicholas_famoso@nps.gov〉

Abstract

As many as eight species of the “anchitherine” equid Miohippus have been identified from the John Day Formation of Oregon, but no statistical analysis of variation in these horses has yet been conducted to determine if that level of diversity is warranted. Variation of the anterior-posterior length and transverse width of upper and lower teeth of Turtle Cove Member Miohippus was compared to that of M. equinanus, Mesohippus bairdii, Equus quagga, and Tapirus terrestris using t tests of their coefficients of variation (V). None of the t tests are significant, indicating that the variation seen in Turtle Cove Miohippus is not significantly different from any of the populations of other perissodactyls examined in this study. Data also indicate that Mesohippus is present in the Turtle Cove Member. Additionally, hypostyle condition, used to diagnose all species of Miohippus, was found to be related to stage of wear using an ordered logistic regression. Only two species of equid, one Miohippus and one Mesohippus, in the Turtle Cove Member can be identified, therefore only Miohippus annectens, the genotype and first species described from the region, can be recognized as the sole Miohippus species known from the Turtle Cove assemblage. There are insufficient data to determine which species of Mesohippus is present. The dependence of hypostyle condition on crown height in Miohippus implies that wear stage must also be considered in investigations of dental morphology in the “Anchitheriinae.”

Information

Type
Articles
Copyright
Copyright © 2017, The Paleontological Society 
Figure 0

Figure 1Distribution of localities utilized in this study. Localities are color coded by member; localities with unknown stratigraphy are not mapped. The locations of Portland, Eugene, and John Day are marked. Oregon is highlighted in black on the map of the United States of America.

Figure 1

Figure 2Composite stratigraphic section of the John Day Formation used in this study. Specimens are from the upper portion of the Big Basin, Turtle Cove, Kimberly, and Haystack Valley members. Specifically, specimens were recovered from Turtle Cove units A, B, C, D, undifferentiated layers in E, F, H, J, and K2 and Kimberly unit M. Specimens without a specific unit assigned could be from any unit within the assigned member. Additionally, the units described here are not always laterally continuous through all exposures of the Turtle Cove and Kimberly members, and may be undifferentiated in various localities.

Figure 2

Figure 3Representative examples of hypostyle conditions in Oligocene horses of the Turtle Cove assemblage of Oregon. Hypostyle condition follows the terminology of Prothero and Shubin (1989). (1) Type 1 hypostyles (UOMNH F-58207) are thin ridges that have no cusps or spurs projecting anteriorly; (2) Type 2 hypostyles (JODA 1086) exhibit a small spur, which projects anteriorly from the hypostyle ridge; (3) Type 3 hypostyles (UCMP 75274) are characterized by a small distinct ovoid or triangular pocket between a posterior ridge and an anterior spur; I have added the additional condition, (4) none (UCMP 75279), which I define as the lack of hypostyle in heavily worn teeth. Note that there are multiple hypostyle conditions contained within an individual tooth row. Arrows point to exemplar hypostyles on each tooth row that exhibit the specific condition. Line drawings of exemplar teeth are to the right of the photographs with the hypostyle highlighted in blue. Scale bars=1 cm.

Figure 3

Table 1Sample size of equid teeth for each stratigraphic unit in this study.

Figure 4

Table 2Summary statistics for t test. V=Coefficient of Variation, V'=Coefficient of Variation (small sample size correction), n=sample size, SD=standard deviation, APL=anterior-posterior length, TW= transverse width, N/A=Not available. Mean values are in mm.

Figure 5

Table 3Summary statistics for ordered logistic regression. Wear=Wear stage as approximated by Hypsodonty Index and represents the overall relationship between wear stage and hypostyle condidtion, 1|2=ordered test of hypostyle condition 1 and 2, 2|3= ordered test of hypostyle condition 2 and 3, 3|none= ordered test of hypostyle condition 3 and none, *=dependent variable. Hypostyle condition and wear stage appear as independent variables because the logistic regression tests both for a relationship with wear stage and for differences among ordered pairs.