Institutional violence in South Africa prior to 1994
Violence in South Africa manifests in different ways. For the purposes of this section, the focus will be placed on political violence as a form of collective violence. The term ‘collective violence’ has been defined by the World Health Organization (WHO) as
the instrumental use of violence by people who identify themselves as members of a group – whether this group is transitory or has a more permanent identity – against another group or set of individuals, in order to achieve political, economic or social objectives.Footnote 1
This definition, according to Duncan, may include physical force or power that may be threatened or actual, and that is exercised with the objective of privileging an in-group at the expense of an out-group.Footnote 2 It is in this context that political violence in South Africa is discussed below. In 1990, at the opening of the South African Parliament, the erstwhile President F. W. de Klerk made a startling announcement that the African National Congress and other liberation movements were to cease to be banned.Footnote 3 The release of arguably one of the world's most celebrated political prisoners, Mr Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela, was imminent. This radical step by the National Party government meant that South Africa was moving in a direction fundamentally different from its apartheidFootnote 4 laws that it had followed for over seventy years.Footnote 5
The policy of apartheid had vested power and privilege in the white minority for decades. This in turn embodied one of the most damaging contemporary systems of political violence. Racial classification, as formalized by apartheid, split the South African population into four major groups: white, coloured, Indian, and African.Footnote 6 Furthermore, the National Party government, under its policy of separate development, created tribal homelands for each African group, which became the lex domicilii for each one.Footnote 7
Jenkins describes apartheid as a system comprising two ideological themes of white supremacy that attempted to guarantee racial peace and maintain a pure white race.Footnote 8 The first theme was segregation as a means of domination.Footnote 9 The second was segregation as trusteeship, which allowed Africans to express themselves completely within their own communities.Footnote 10 Apartheid may thus be seen as a system of institutionalized violence, in that its success could only be achieved by repressive means of law enforcement.Footnote 11 Generally speaking, institutional violence stems from the establishment of explicit rules within a particular society where such rules may inculcate a culture of racism and separatism, as was the case in South Africa. During the wrath of apartheid, the distinction between political and criminal conduct was often blurred. ‘Freedom fighters’ justified their conduct as a legitimate weapon against a racist regime. Various laws enacted by the state entrenched political violence across racial barriers.Footnote 12
Early forms of violence prior to 1948 appeared at the mines in Johannesburg during the 1920s.Footnote 13 As a result of the continued influx of African migrant labourers, violence in that region escalated to an unprecedented intensity. The harsh discriminatory laws created by the apartheid government merely intensified and perpetuated the violence. However, the Soweto uprising in 1976 marked an incipient change in the perception by both Africans and whites that Africans were powerless.Footnote 14 The year 1983 saw the inception of the tri-cameral parliamentary system.Footnote 15 The fact that Africans were excluded from representation in this system spawned further violence, commonly referred to as the ‘African revolt of 1984’. This revolt did not lead to an overthrow of the National Party government, but by the late 1980s many had been persuaded that African power had to be taken seriously and needed to be accommodated.
Duncan states that in 1983 an estimated 3.5 million people had been affected because of forced removals.Footnote 16 Many Africans were subjected to widespread malnutrition, poor health and education systems, overcrowded schools, poor social security, and high levels of unemployment. It is therefore not surprising that apartheid is regarded as the largest contributing factor to the political violence that prevailed in South Africa for decades. The political agenda of the National Party government, as well as the actions of the South African security forces, is often seen as having fostered the creation of an environment conducive to gang activity.
The Truth and Reconciliation Commission as a response to institutional violence
Immediately after the 1994 national elections, the post-apartheid Government of National Unity proposed that a mechanism be put in place to address the political violence that had haunted South Africa for so many years, namely a Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC)Footnote 17 chaired by Archbishop Desmond Tutu. As a form of transitional justice, the TRC was tasked with providing a full picture of the nature, causes, and extent of gross human rights violations committed during apartheid. Between 1960 and 1994, 2,500 people had been hanged for political crimes, while about 80,000 people had been detained without trial.Footnote 18 The TRC's mandate was limited to atrocities committed during that period. In this regard, Duncan comments that:
[First,] some of the worst acts of political violence committed by the apartheid state effectively fell beyond the scrutiny of this institution. In the process, therefore, a sufficiently comprehensive examination and analysis of the extent and impact of the various forms of political violence engendered by apartheid, for all intents and purposes, were precluded. … Secondly … the narrow definition of gross human rights violations as ‘the killing, abduction, torture or severe ill-treatment of any person or any attempt, conspiracy, incitement, instigation, command or procurement to commit an act of killing, abduction, torture or severe ill-treatment’, precluded not only the examination of all the variants of political violence spawned by apartheid, but also of the system of apartheid itself as a crime against humanity.Footnote 19
Amnesty provisions in terms of transitional justice
It is submitted that true reconciliation was never achieved by the Truth and Reconciliation Commission; rather than being unveiled, the past was buried deeper. The question of criminal accountability was, however, raised during the negotiation process and, while a general amnesty was found to be counter-productive, a concession was made and the final chapter of the Interim Constitution included the following text:
In order to advance such reconciliation and reconstruction, amnesty shall be granted in respect of acts, omissions and offences associated with political objectives and committed in the course of the conflicts of the past. To this end, Parliament under this Constitution shall adopt a law determining a firm cut-off date, which shall be a date after 8 October 1990 and before 6 December 1993, and providing for the mechanisms, criteria and procedures, including tribunals, if any, through which such amnesty shall be dealt with at any time after the law has been passed.Footnote 20
Despite these amnesty provisions, which may conflict with international law, the TRC was not in a position to address the post-1994 political violence; this criticism was echoed around the world. True conciliation can only be achieved by a genuine willingness of South Africans to acknowledge and deal with one of the most violent periods of the country's history.Footnote 21 While in essence the TRC was intended as a vehicle for many South Africans to unravel the past, in reality it fostered an ever-growing amnesia developed by South Africans in order to forget that violent past.
It is submitted that South Africa has a legal obligation, in terms of both national and international law, to continue to prosecute persons who have committed politically motivated gross human rights violations. Bubenzer draws attention to the legal framework for establishing criminal accountability.Footnote 22 The constitutional law obligations include the obligation of the state to respect, promote, and fulfil the Bill of Rights.Footnote 23 Bubenzer affirms that the prosecution authorities' obligations apply to violations of rights that occurred after the Constitution came into force, as well as offences committed beforehand.Footnote 24 Stating that the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) had presented only a few cases before the courts between 2003 and 2008, he therefore contends that:
The NPA is, to a certain degree, simply refraining from investigating and prosecuting cases, thereby, to a certain extent, creating a state of de facto indemnity. The government contributes significantly to this state of impunity by not giving the NPA the support it would need to go further. Instead, it has … attempted to restrict prosecutions from progressing further.Footnote 25
As a result of the small in number of prosecutions by the National Prosecuting Authority, gangs have continued to thrive, in the hope that they would benefit from the amnesty provisions, and consequently the violence has continued in all its bloody horror.
Gang violence as a form of urban violence
Historically, South Africa's segregation laws have been instrumental in creating a platform for some of the most violent crimes related to urban gangsterism. Cities such as Johannesburg and Cape Town, in particular, have experienced unprecedented levels of gang-based violence.
Gang violence in Johannesburg and surrounding areas
In Johannesburg and its surrounding areasFootnote 26 the mining industry required a largely African male labour force. The resulting influx of Africans of various origins led to different ethnic groups being housed together in same-sex barracks on the mine property. Fights between the different ethnic groups became an everyday occurrence. The white authorities at the mines did not intervene, but rather tended to take deaths resulting from the faction fights for granted, as synonymous with the deaths from rock falls underground.Footnote 27 The mine managers were thus absolved of any responsibility, and it was not considered that supervisory abuse or housing and job allocation policies that encouraged ethnic chauvinism could lead to violence.Footnote 28
The Ninevites gang
The end of the nineteenth century marked the emergence of probably one of the most notorious gangs in South Africa: the Ninevites, led by Nongozola.Footnote 29 In her review of van Onselen's book,Footnote 30 Lucille Davie repeats that Nongozola decided on the name Ninevites because ‘I read in the Bible about the great state Nineveh which rebelled against the Lord and I selected that name for my gang as rebels against the government's laws’.Footnote 31
The Zulu-based Ninevites operated in the Witwatersrand and, according to van Onselen, frightened the inhabitants of the urban African locations; yet they were also known for administering justice to white employers who had mistreated African workers.Footnote 32 They were an African criminal organization that operated in prisons and in the community. With the advent of strict British administrative control at the start of the Anglo-Boer War, they sought refuge in mines and prison compounds.Footnote 33
At the turn of the twentieth century, South African prisons had a regular influx of predominantly African males, mainly owing to the pass laws enacted by parliament at that time. The criminal justice system, a reflection of racist policies, did very little to separate effectively the tough and often dangerous criminals from first offenders. These factors largely contributed to the successful predominance of the Ninevites' criminal activities in prisons. Kynoch states that the moment the Ninevites targeted white agents of the state, the government attempted to systematically wipe out the gang.Footnote 34 This marked the end of the Ninevites' gang activity outside prisons.
Gang activity at the mines continued with the presence of another gang, formed as a defence against the existing Ninevites. It was called the Isitshozi, and was initially established to protect the Mpondo mine workers.Footnote 35 The intensity of the violence at the mines later led to the imprisonment of a large number of Isitshozi members. Instead of being jailed, other Isitshozi members were sent to Pondoland, thus resulting in the infiltration of gangs into urban areas.Footnote 36
In the 1950s, a gang known as the Tsotsi was formed. They regarded the migrant workers as ‘unschooled in the ways of the city’ and friction between those workers and the Tsotsi often ensued. The migrant workers would retaliate with indiscriminate attacks on the city youth.Footnote 37 An array of gangs flourished during this period, whose members mostly had little or no educational background.Footnote 38 While many of their activities were defensive in nature, the consolidation of some gangs meant that their power increased and they consequently adopted a more aggressive approach. The most common form of violent activity for the Tsotsi was gang warfare, and bigger gangs were often tasked with carrying out ritual violence.Footnote 39
As violence spread through the townships, the police authorities were slow to respond, and residents in many neighbourhoods therefore grouped together in street patrols and other neighbourhood watch systems. The government's lack of institutional response was tantamount to a carte blanche for gangs to pursue their criminal activity. The state actively supported many of these gangs and thus indirectly encouraged urban violence, so civic organizations were ineffective in their ‘war against gangsterism’. The cities of Cape Town and Durban did not escape the wrath of the various gangs, as shown below.
Gang violence in Durban and Cape Town
Durban and Cape Town lacked the dominance of the mining industry prevalent in the Witwatersrand region, and more particularly Johannesburg, at the turn of the twentieth century. Cape Town, for example, had a large coloured population and this naturally impacted on the dynamics of urban violence in the city.Footnote 40 It is still a city of contrasts and visible social fragmentation built on policies of apartheid. The segregation laws of the 1950s created a largely polarized population, resulting in whites living in the affluent cosmopolitan area at the base of Table Mountain and along the coast, while the non-white population settled in suburban areas, such as District Six, mainly on the back of the Group Areas Act of 1950.
As a result of urban migration and unemployed youth during the 1940s, the notorious suburb of District SixFootnote 41 became the birthplace of street gangs.Footnote 42 Its inhabitants responded fiercely with vigilante tactics; the ‘mafias’, as they became known, were in fact family-based groups who fought for the protection of their close friends and family against the ever-growing threat of gangsterism. The gangs' infiltration of the Cape FlatsFootnote 43 suburb was mainly due to the segregation laws and resettlement schemes of the 1960s. It is interesting to note that not all the Cape Flats inhabitants were in favour of state intervention against gangs in the area. Indeed, the Mail & Guardian reported in 1999 that the former Hard Livings gang boss, Rashied Staggie, was seen by many as a hero.Footnote 44
The Hard Livings gang
In 1993 the Hard Livings gang were preparing to become junior partners of organized crime. As Kinnes explains, in that same year South Africa was on the eve of political transition to democracy.Footnote 45 At the same time, the government and the opposition forces were negotiating amnesty and indemnity from prosecution. The political atmosphere was extremely fragile and killings and upheavals were rife, yet gangs in a rather opportunistic fashion manipulated and interpreted the socio-political uncertainty as an occasion for committing crime in the name of freedom.Footnote 46
Kinnes opines that gang members consciously did not draw a distinction between crimes committed by them and crimes committed by the liberation movements. As a result, the Hard Livings gang demanded that they be included in the amnesty provisions, as well as indemnity from prosecution, because they were supposedly victims of apartheid.Footnote 47 In part, the Hard Livings gang gave strong support to the African National Congress, while at the same time a rival gang operating in the same area, the ‘Americans’,Footnote 48 supported the ruling National Party. Cape Town, and especially the Cape Flats, were the scene of the most violent gang-related crimes during the run-up to South Africa's first democratic elections.
Between 1990 and 1994, South Africa had experienced quite a lot of low-intensity conflict in African residential areas.Footnote 49 There were numerous media reports on assassinations of influential political figures, bomb blasts, and ruinous battles in the various townships. Political analysts regarded the violence as being ‘black on black’, and Knox in particular states:
Between February 1990 and April 1994 South Africa roller-coastered between the highs of political agreements to the lows of countless massacres and levels of violence unprecedented in a land already scorched by bloodshed. … ‘the nature of political violence was transformed from a primarily overt conflict between the regime and the forces of liberation, to a more entangled fight among a wide variety of players with disparate motives, tactics and objectives’.Footnote 50
This type of violence thus had hybrid characteristics. On the one hand, it was seen as classic gang violence and, on the other hand, as political violence. Retracing its development, Kynoch writes that:
The urban-led protests of the mid-1980s, combined with the rise of state-sponsored vigilantism and the fighting between ANC and IFP [Inkatha Freedom Party] backed forces, turned many townships into virtual war zones. All the warring parties recruited criminal gangs to some extent, and not surprisingly were unable to exercise full control over the elements that fought in their name.Footnote 51
Whatever the form of violence in the period between 1980 and 1994, its victims always included displaced children and political detainees held without trial, and it always involved deaths and injuries. The wrath of this violence was particularly evident in the province of KwaZulu-Natal.
Violence in KwaZulu-Natal
The suburb that experienced the most political violence during the two decades prior to the 1994 democratic elections was Mpumalanga Township in KwaZulu-Natal, which has always been the province hosting an Inkatha Freedom Party stronghold.Footnote 52 There have been numerous clashes between the followers of the Inkatha Freedom Party, the United Democratic Front, and the African National Congress.Footnote 53 In 1987 the tensions in Mpumalanga Township intensified, resulting in the creation of ‘closed’ zones for territorial and political supremacy in the region. Regarding the violence in the region, Mosoeta remarks:
The violence was often labelled as ‘black-on-black’ violence with the regime at that time posing as a neutral actor, genuinely concerned about resolving the war. Yet there is well-documented evidence of direct involvement by the South African Police in support of the Inkatha Freedom Party and against those supporting the African National Congress and its allies. At a more passive level, the police did not take up crimes committed against and reported by the United Democratic Front members.Footnote 54
The state's response to gang violence
Black-on-black violence was largely ignored by the South African police before 1994, mainly because they were concentrating on enforcing pass laws and other repressive legislation enacted by the apartheid government. The lack of police responses to urban violence during this period meant that gangsterism, rape, and murder flourished in the townships. Kynoch states that ‘When protest against the apartheid regime gathered momentum in the 1970s and 1980s, police efforts were concentrated on crushing political dissent rather than addressing violence within black communities’.Footnote 55
Many areas in South Africa became ungovernable, owing to lack of effort by the police. It can be argued that the police were not effective enough to combat gangsterism and prevent crime because they were more reactive than proactive. The transition to democracy in 1994 meant that police services necessarily had to change from a repressive policing style to a more community-based service. In order to achieve this, a Commission of Inquiry under the leadership of Judge Goldstone was established.Footnote 56 The objectives of the Commission were to:
—inquire into the phenomenon of public violence and intimidation in the Republic, the nature and causes thereof, and what persons were involved therein;
—inquire into any steps that should be taken in order to prevent public violence and intimidation; and
—make recommendations to the State President in respect of public violence and intimidation.Footnote 57
The Goldstone Commission made quite a number of recommendations to the State President on steps to prevent violence and intimidation. These included:
—deploying an effective police presence in local communities;
—utilizing the new division of Internal Security to counter violence;
—taking urgent steps to prohibit the carrying of weapons in public; and
—improving the relationship between the police and local communities.Footnote 58
The Commission also drew up a number of significant reports, including those on the violence affecting CrossroadsFootnote 59 and Nyanga,Footnote 60 and the report on the storming of the Kepton Park World Trade Centre in June 1993.Footnote 61
Durington argues that, as a result of the faith lost in the South African police services, private security companies may become the next investment strategy, because it is perceived that the private security companies might perform better than the police currently are.Footnote 62 A short reflection on crime statistics before and after 1994 follows.
Crime statistics before 1994
Statistics on crime in South Africa during the apartheid years may not be either conclusive or accurate. This may be attributed to the fact that crime figures during this period did not include crimes committed and reported in the Bantustans (homelands).Footnote 63 Louw and Schönteich state that from 1973 to 1993 recorded crime, measured on a per capita basis, increased by about 35%.Footnote 64 During the mid-1980s violent crimes were often justified by the wrongdoers as a legitimate means of defence against political opponents and enemies. This resulted in an exponential increase in violence during that period.
Crime statistics after 1994
In the first three years after becoming a constitutional democracy, South Africa saw its crime levels stabilize, despite being fairly high.Footnote 65 Statistics obtained from the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime reveal that the overall crime rate during the 1994/1995 twelve-month period was 5,224 reported incidents per 100,000 of the population.Footnote 66 This figure increased slightly to 5,571 per 100,000 during the 2001/2002 period.Footnote 67
A steady decrease in certain crimes occurred between April 2003 and March 2009. For example, common assault offences declined from 280,942 reported incidents in the April 2003/March 2004 period to 192,838 in the twelve months ending March 2009. Yet over that same time span public violence escalated from 979 reported incidents to 1,500 in March 2009.Footnote 68 An increase in drug-related crime was also recorded.Footnote 69 These statistics show that, despite South Africa's transition into a constitutional state, the rights, freedoms, and privileges of many South African nationals and foreigners on South African territory are constantly under threat.
Vigilantism as a means of curbing gang-related crime
Vigilante action has proliferated as a result of the government's inability to combat drugs and crime. It became evident in the late 1990s, with the emergence of the People against Gangsterism and Drugs group in 1996. At the time the police welcomed the group, seeing it as a virtual substitute performing their functions, especially since they themselves may have feared for their lives in combating gangsterism. The state was quick to curb the group's actions after it had been linked to a number of terrorist-related activities, including drive-by shootings and petrol bomb and hand-grenade attacks against alleged drug dealers and gangsters, as well as against police stations.Footnote 70 There is little doubt that crime in South Africa is a force to be reckoned with, exacerbated by the fact that the perpetrators of the most violent crimes know no bounds. Law enforcement is thus increasingly strained.
‘Shoot-to-kill’ policy
In 2008 the Deputy Minister of Security shocked many human rights activists when she stated publicly in response to the high crime statistics that:
You must kill the bastards if they threaten you or the community. You must not worry about the regulations – that is my responsibility. Your responsibility is to serve and protect. I want no warning shots. You have one shot and it must be a kill shot. Criminals are hell-bent on undermining the law and they must now be dealt with. End of story. There are to be no negotiations with criminals.Footnote 71
South Africa's National Police Commissioner Bheki Cele reiterated that police officers should use deadly force when faced with armed criminals. The statements made by these high-profile leaders are irresponsible and in violation of international and national laws. According to the United Nations Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials, intentional lethal use of firearms may only be made when it is strictly unavoidable in order to protect life.Footnote 72 These principles are guidelines that states need to follow in order to ensure that their police officials perform their duties in accordance with internationally recognized standards, and with due regard to basic human rights. The principles thus clearly guard against arbitrary killing of criminal suspects. The South African ‘shoot-to-kill’ policy has therefore come under the spotlight and will be briefly discussed here.
Section 49 of the 1977 Criminal Procedure ActFootnote 73 has been the centre of attention for a number of years. The section originally applied to situations in which it was deemed justifiable for the police or any arresting authority to use lethal force. This section was amended in 1998, primarily to conform to the Constitution. The amendment only came into effect in 2003, one year after the Constitutional Court ruled that section 49, prior to the amendment, was unconstitutional.Footnote 74 The 2003 amendment has not yet been challenged, although it arguably allows for lethal force only when the arrester's own life or the lives of others are in danger.
It is submitted in hindsight that the criteria set in the Walters case should apply, and not the 2003 amendment, as those criteria provide better legal certainty.Footnote 75 It thus becomes clear that the South African ‘shoot-to-kill’ policy is not in accordance with international and national law. Since April 2010, a new Bill has been tabled before parliament, and it is hoped that the proposed Bill, when enacted into law, will provide legal certainty in line with the Walters decision.Footnote 76
‘Taxi wars’ as a form of urban violence in South Africa
In order to understand the manifestation of taxi violence in South Africa, it is necessary to consider the history of the taxi industry dating back to 1977. Before 1977, the Motor Carrier Transportation Act of 1930 prohibited the transportation of goods or passengers by road for profit without permission from the South African Local Road Transportation Board. In essence, the transport industry was monopolized by the South African Transport Service. Thus any taxi owner who conducted business outside the jurisdiction of the Local Transport Board was doing so illegally. African transport owners found it near impossible to meet all the requirements of the regulations laid down by the Motor Carrier Transportation Act.Footnote 77 Taxi operators who were operating illegally formed various informal associations, and these associations regulated loading practices and prices.
The legislation permitted those Africans who qualified for a taxi permit to use small vehicles able to transport only four passengers at a time. Buses and trains in the 1970s were inadequate and expensive, and the demand for taxis therefore grew rapidly. The National Party government realized in the late 1970s that participation in the transport industry was becoming less viable and highly politicized. In 1977 the Van Breda Commission of Inquiry was established and recommended deregulation of the taxi industry in terms of legislation.Footnote 78 A myriad of taxi associations emerged in the wake of an absence of official control, resulting in large-scale corruption and consequential violence among the competing associations.Footnote 79 Sekhonyane and Dugard comment that:
contrary to many expectations, the cycles of taxi violence fomented during the late apartheid period did not end with the demise of apartheid. Indeed, unlike other forms of political violence that diminished and disappeared after 1994, taxi violence actually escalated in the immediate post-1994 period.Footnote 80
The state's response to the taxi violence
From the above it is clear that taxi violence became increasingly widespread and less manageable by the authorities. Attempts to restructure the taxi industry were slow. In 1995 the government established the National Taxi Task Team to inquire into the causes of, and possible solutions to, the prevailing violence.Footnote 81 The National Taxi Task Team presented its findings and recommendations to the Minister of Transport the following year. The most significant recommendation was that the taxi industry be deregulated.Footnote 82 Strong opposition came from a number of taxi associations and resulted in an upsurge of taxi violence between 1998 and 1999.Footnote 83 The National Land Transport Act of 2000Footnote 84 was the government's attempt to help formalize and re-regulate the taxi industry. Part of the process of re-regulation included a four-year recapitalization scheme.Footnote 85 Delays in this process arose from the taxi industry's inability to form a cohesive association representing all the taxi owners, as well as disagreement between taxi owners as to the nature of the proposed recapitalization scheme.Footnote 86 The recapitalization programme has had a number of shortcomings, including the lack of financial assistance from banks, which have led to its fairly slow implementation.
In 2007 the Department of Public Transport announced that a fast, comfortable, and low-cost urban transport system called the Bus Rapid Transit System (BRTS) was being planned for the host cities of the 2010 FIFA World Cup.Footnote 87 It is envisaged that the BRTS will play a leading role in the transformation of public transport within cities. However, taxi associations remain resistant to government interference in the taxi industry, since the BRTS is seen as a threat to the livelihood of many taxi operators. Evidence of this resistance surfaced in May 2010: there were two shooting incidents in Soweto, one resulting in the death of a commuter on the Rea Vaya Bus Rapid Transit route from Soweto to Central Johannesburg.Footnote 88
The BRTS should not be viewed as the final solution to public transport in South Africa, but as the government's attempt to minimize conflict in the taxi industry, provided that existing taxi operators ‘buy into the system’.Footnote 89 It remains to be seen whether this will ultimately be achieved.
Xenophobic violence as a form of urban violence in South Africa
The Compact Oxford English Dictionary defines xenophobia as ‘intense or irrational dislike or fear of people from other countries’.Footnote 90 Xenophobia can thus be seen as unreasonable distrust, fear, or hatred of strangers or foreigners, or anything foreign or different. Brutal assaults, police victimization, and ethnic cleansing and mass expulsion are some of the forms that xenophobia may take in any particular country.
South Africa experienced a series of xenophobic attacks in May 2008, directed primarily at foreigners in poor settlements. Those attacked included foreigners who had acquired citizenship because of their specialized skills,Footnote 91 as well as persons with legal work and study permits.Footnote 92 An outline of xenophobic violence in South Africa is given below, followed by a discussion of the May 2008 and subsequent attacks.
Legal framework of laws relating to the protection of migrants
There are several international human rights instruments to promote the human rights of all migrants. It is a principle of international law that governments have wide sovereign discretion to determine nationality. However, when a foreign national is found on its territory, the government has to ensure that the foreign national's human rights are respected. The rights contained in those international legal instruments are thus guaranteed to all persons present in a particular state, including nationals and non-nationals irrespective of their legal status, their gender, or their age.
Various human rights treaties specifically highlight the prohibition against discrimination. These treaties include the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR),Footnote 93 the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR),Footnote 94 and the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (ICERD).Footnote 95 Refugee protection laws include the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of RefugeesFootnote 96 and the 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees.Footnote 97
South Africa acceded to the 1951 Refugee Convention and the 1967 Protocol on 12 January 1996. In order to give effect to its international obligations, principles, and standards relating to refugees in terms of these two international instruments, South Africa promulgated the South African Refugees Act 130 of 1998.Footnote 98 The Act provides for the reception into South Africa of asylum seekers and regulates applications for and recognition of refugee status. In addition it provides for the rights and obligations flowing from such status, and other related matters. South Africa further sought to control illegal immigration by promulgating the Immigration Act 13 of 2002.Footnote 99 Although the country was thus bound by instruments of national and international law, since its first manifestation xenophobic violence has become a ‘household brand’.
History of xenophobic violence in South Africa since 1995
May 2008 was not the first time South Africa experienced xenophobic violence. Indeed, looking no further back than 1995, there are numerous shocking accounts of such attacks.Footnote 100 According to a Human Rights Watch report, immigrants from Malawi, Mozambique, and Zimbabwe living in Alexandra Township were physically assaulted in 1995.Footnote 101 The report states that armed gangs identified suspected undocumented migrants and marched them to the police station in an attempt to ‘clean’ the township of the foreigners.Footnote 102 The campaign accused the foreign nationals of being responsible for the high crime and unemployment rates, as well as the increase in sexual violence, particularly against women. Nahla Valji writes that:
In September 1998 two Senegalese and a Mozambican were thrown from a train by a group of individuals returning from a rally organised by a group blaming foreigners for the levels of unemployment, crime, and even the spread of AIDS.Footnote 103
Very often the victims of these attacks are foreign hawkers seeking refuge in South Africa. Some South Africans argue that, by taking up employment in South Africa, foreigners are largely responsible for depriving South African nationals of job opportunities. Poverty and poor service delivery are two further causal factors for xenophobic attacks.Footnote 104 In South Africa the gap between rich and poor is wide and deep, and various forms of violence, including xenophobic violence, have consequently become prevalent.
In September 2000, seven foreigners were killed in the Cape Flats district.Footnote 105 These xenophobic murders, as described by the police, were allegedly motivated by fear that foreigners would claim the property belonging to South African nationals.Footnote 106 In October 2001, residents of the Zandspruit informal settlement targeted Zimbabweans, believing that they were responsible for the local inhabitants being without jobs. The Independent Online Newspaper reported that:
The violence in Zandspruit squatter settlement outside Honeydew, west of Johannesburg, erupted when the Zimbabweans failed to leave the area after being given a 10-day ultimatum … to leave the area or face the wrath of the locals. The ultimatum was allegedly brokered in a meeting held at the local police station.Footnote 107
In 2006 Somali refugees sought intervention from the South African Human Rights Commission with regard to a number of attacks on Somali traders.Footnote 108 The media reported that about twenty-six Somali traders had been killed in 2006.Footnote 109 The South African police were quick to dismiss the reasons for the deaths as being linked to xenophobic attacks. This recurring ‘blind-eye’ attitude of the police service seemed to reflect a more general attitude of the state towards foreign nationals.Footnote 110
Several attacks on Somalis, Pakistanis, and Zimbabweans occurred in various townships during 2007 and 2008, where some of the shops and shacksFootnote 111 were set alight.Footnote 112 Despite major public outcries from large sectors of the South African population and international human rights organizations, foreign nationals continued to be targeted and, in May 2008, South Africa and the world witnessed yet another series of xenophobic attacks.
On 11 May 2008 Alexandra, a township north of Johannesburg, was flooded with police after the township's local residents violently attacked foreign nationals, killing and injuring migrants from Mozambique, Zimbabwe, and Malawi.Footnote 113 Shortly after these attacks, violence spread to other settlements in the Gauteng Province, as well as the coastal cities of Durban and Cape Town. In 2009, 3,000 foreigners in the De Dooms Township in Cape Town, including refugees and asylum seekers from Zimbabwe, were driven from their shacks.Footnote 114 The UN High Commissioner for Refugees welcomed the rapid response of the local authorities in Cape Town and of the South African Red Cross Society in providing communal tents, water, public toilets, and mobile medical facilities.Footnote 115 These attacks, as well as those prior to 2008, stemmed from the increasingly xenophobic climate that has been spreading throughout South Africa for a number of years.
The paradoxical reality is that many of the victims were immigrants from neighbouring countries who had initially integrated quite easily with the local African population during the apartheid era, with little or no violent xenophobic disruption. To unravel this paradox, some understanding is required of why these attacks occurred in the first place.
Factors that may have triggered the xenophobic attacks in May 2008
The existence of various factors conducive to xenophobic violence was mentioned above. They include poverty informed by a disparity in income between rich and poor, poor service delivery, overcrowding in squatter camps, lack of housing, and widespread unemployment. Arguably, some South Africans also exude a feeling of superiority towards other Africans.Footnote 116 South African youth has been on the receiving end because of the socio-political defects embedded in daily South African life. Many African young people have, for various reasons, dropped out of school and subsequently been unable to find employment.Footnote 117 This has resulted in youth being drawn into various forms of crime and violent behaviour,Footnote 118 and thus to an ever greater extent into sub-cultures involving gangs and drugs. Zondi states that:
Low educational qualification, high unemployment and the weakening of social organizations, especially at the family and community level, seem to have combined to breed a significant sense of alienation, marginalization and neglect. This expresses itself in anger against the establishment and violence against various targets from time to time. This then also manifests in the spate of violent crime, disorderly protests and senseless attacks on ‘others’.Footnote 119
It is thus clear that poverty and unemployment are key factors to consider when addressing xenophobic violence in contemporary South Africa. This begs the question whether South Africa is effectively responding to the security risks of structural xenophobia.
The state's response to the xenophobic violence
In a public statement issued by the South African Human Rights Commission, various stakeholders emphatically called for an end to the violence that has erupted throughout South Africa.Footnote 120 The Commission very strongly urged the South African government to impose a moratorium on the arrest and deportation, despite their legal status, of victims of violence. It also called upon the Department of Justice and Constitutional Development to ensure that special and extraordinary courts be set up in order to ensure that those arrested might be brought to trial expediently,Footnote 121 and urged civil society organizations to act with compassion in rendering humanitarian aid to the victims. Replying to criticism that the Commission had been slow to respond to the xenophobic attacks, its Chairperson, Lawrence Mushwana, pointed out that the Human Rights Act of 1994 does not have any prescribed methods for dealing with a complex disaster such as the xenophobic attacks that occurred on 11 May 2008.
Shortly after the attacks, state and civil society organizations established temporary camps, including police stations and community halls, for the victims of the attacks. The South African government at first thought that the refugees held there should be reintegrated into the communities from which they had originally fled. This view was rapidly dispelled as more draconian recommendations on migrants were developed by the South African Human Sciences Research Council and seemingly entertained by the government.Footnote 122 Some of the recommendations in the Council's report are proposals that the government should legalize immigrants and refugees already in South Africa, after which the South African borders should be closed and patrolled by the South African National Defence Force.
This measure was intended to ensure that additional foreigners were not allowed to ‘come and go as they please’.Footnote 123 The Council further recommended that foreigners be barred from certain types of employment and that a new system of minimum wages be developed in certain sectors so as to prevent immigrants from working for lower wages.Footnote 124 Sharp, in a response to South African migration policies, says:
How is it that they, like many other South Africans, have forgotten so quickly that a great deal of the country's present wealth and development was built, over the entire course of the twentieth century, on the backs of foreign African migrant workers?Footnote 125
The South African immigration policy was initially designed to deter illegal migration into South Africa by encouraging foreign nationals to apply for different permits to legalize their stay in the country. It further aimed to attract scarce skills required by the economy, in accordance with the government's Vision 2014 strategy.Footnote 126 The policy also states that a human-rights-based culture of enforcement should be encouraged. Despite this, there has been a slow and inadequate response from the South African government, which has been severely criticized. Monson and Misago argue that the state's reluctance to protect and assist foreigners perpetuates violence, social instability, and injustice for nationals and non-nationals alike.Footnote 127 They put forward the following five reasons why the state failed to address the attacks effectively.
Failure to prevent violence and protect victims
On the point that South Africa failed to prevent violence and protect the victims of the attacks, Monson and Misago comment:
That many attacks recurred in places that had experienced similar breakdowns in order in the recent past is strongly suggestive of a failure to manage risk in these areas. This prompts the question, if citizens had been the victims of the attacks, would risk management have been equally poor?Footnote 128
In a research interview between Monson and a senior police official in Alexandra, where the attacks occurred, the police official indicated that, before some of the attacks, meetings were held by communities to discuss vigilante action. According to Monson, the police were aware of this but took no responsive action.Footnote 129
Deportation of victims to their countries of origin
In its early responses to the xenophobic attacks, the South African Department of Home Affairs authorized immigration officers to arrest victims who did not have any documents. These persons were destined for deportation to their countries of origin. Yet later reports indicated that the Minister of Home Affairs had subsequently made an announcement that no victim of the xenophobic attacks was to be deported.Footnote 130 As a result of this incoherent governmental reaction, the state, according to Monson and Misago, ‘supported the intention of the perpetrators to remove foreigners from communities, contributed to stalling judicial measures against perpetrators of violence, and, where deportation was involuntary, criminalized undocumented victims rather than their assailants’.Footnote 131
Failure to prioritize prosecutions
Monson and Misago suggest that the state failed to prioritize prosecution of the perpetrators. It is argued that, when the state had the opportunity in 1994 and from then on to prosecute perpetrators, it had not done so, and this reluctance may have increased the risk of future violence. Often non-nationals are treated as outsiders, mainly because of their non-citizenship status, and therefore do not benefit from the protection of government agencies, except in limited circumstances under the authority of the Department of Home Affairs.Footnote 132
The Consortium for Refugees and Migrants in South AfricaFootnote 133 reported in its newsletter in March 2009 that the office of the National Prosecuting Authority of South Africa had revealed statistics on the number of persons prosecuted since the attacks in May 2008.Footnote 134 The Consortium had asked the National Prosecuting Authority for statistics on the subject and subsequently reported that:
The NPA has responded and clarified that 1,627 people were originally arrested in connection with the violence. 105 cases out of a total of 469 have now been finalized with 70 returning a guilty vote. 208 cases have been withdrawn so far with reasons including the complainant no longer being interested in the case, the complainant not being traced, remand being refused by the magistrate and the inability to locate an interpreter. Three special courts were set up in the Western Cape and prosecutors in the other provinces were instructed to prioritize xenophobia-related cases.Footnote 135
Some of the reasons for the withdrawal of the 208 cases are without justification. It can be inferred from this that the state is unwilling to prioritize matters relating to foreign nationals, primarily because these foreign nationals are non-citizens.
While criminal prosecutions slowly proceeded, Lawyers for Human Rights in South Africa successfully challenged the legality and conditions of the Soutpansberg Military Grounds detention centre before the North Gauteng High Court.Footnote 136 They argued that the conditions at the centre were in violation of the Constitution, the Immigration Act, and international law,Footnote 137 and that the persons detained at the centre had never been charged with or convicted of a criminal offence. The detention of children at the centre was also severely criticized. The court ruled that the centre had not been set up in accordance with the Immigration Act, and that the conditions of detention at the centre were unlawful and unconstitutional.Footnote 138
Reluctance to render humanitarian assistance
The South African ConstitutionFootnote 139 specifically prohibits forms of prejudice such as racism and sexism.Footnote 140 Equality, in the form of non-discrimination, and human dignity are the cornerstone of a constitutional and democratic state such as South Africa. Many state organs looked to the Department of Home Affairs to render humanitarian aid within the framework of its immigration management functions.Footnote 141 Local municipalities ‘passed the buck’ to provincial municipalities and, in the absence of aid from the provincial municipalities, the local municipalities were reluctant to respond.Footnote 142
No commitment to the reintegration process
Reintegration has been defined as the return of a person to a community and their acceptance by it as a participant member; the definition therefore includes the re-entry of formally displaced people into the social, economic, cultural, and political fabric of their original community.Footnote 143 Monson and Misago crucially distinguish the term ‘reintegration’ from ‘return’ and ‘resettlement’ and correctly submit that:
According to the UNHCR, reintegration, as it refers to returning refugees, requires access to reasonable resources, opportunities and basic services to establish a self-sustained livelihood in conditions of equal rights with other residents and citizens. Reintegration should therefore be distinguished from return (the process of going back to one's place of original residence) or resettlement, which refers to the process of starting a new life in another part of the country.Footnote 144
It is clear from the above that, as a result of poor disaster management programmes in place, many local and provincial state departments were quick to adopt a policy of returning foreign nationals to their places of origin rather than reintegrating them. The lack of effective reintegration policies is not a justification for state departments to engage in a mass exodus of foreign nationals, and it is submitted that this practice is at variance with international laws relating to migrants.
The five reasons put forward by Monson and Misago and cited above are a clear indication that South Africa rapidly needs to engage in revising its existing policies on migration in order to prevent xenophobic attacks in the future. It is highly undesirable for any state to develop migration policies that are in stark contrast to its international obligations vis-à-vis migrants, and in this regard South Africa has ‘failed the test’.
Conclusion
South Africa has a long and gruesome history of violence in all its different forms. The international community placed overwhelming expectations on the country in 1994 when it became a constitutional democracy. Change was inevitable. The only lingering question was whether the new South Africa could meet the challenges it had inherited from its oppressive predecessors. One of these challenges relates to violence. This article has considered the various forms, ranging from political to xenophobic violence, that have manifested in South Africa. The work of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission raised the hopes of many, but it failed to effectively address violence in South Africa after 1994, during a period when it reached an unprecedented peak. The taxi industry in South Africa cannot be ended overnight; continued meaningful dialogue between all stakeholders is required. Government may have to provide adequate investment in its recapitalization programme, which may lead to a reduction in the taxi violence.
A review of gang and xenophobic violence in various cities and townships in South Africa has been undertaken. South Africa's townships were the battlefields of apartheid in the 1980s and the 1990s, and gangsterism thrived during that period. It is clear that South Africa's law enforcement bodies seriously need to reform their attitude towards law enforcement in a manner which may restore dignity and, in a sense, humanity to all people living within its territorial borders. The brutal xenophobic attacks on foreign nationals in the recent past are indicative of flawed government responses, as well as poor leadership at all levels of government.
South Africa is a signatory to most international human rights instruments and consequently has an obligation to ensure that justice there must not simply be done, but must also be seen to be done. The country has a vibrant civil society, a fairly advanced infrastructure, and a free press, and enjoys global support. Although these attributes imply that South Africa should be able to take its place in the international community with pride, the high rate of ongoing violence means that this goal may not be readily attained. As Desmond Tutu has so wisely said, ‘Stability and peace in our land will not come from the barrel of a gun, because peace without justice is an impossibility’.Footnote 145
