In this book, published in Palgrave/Macmillan's Rethinking Peace and Conflict Series, Roland Bleiker proposes to break the mold of international relations scholarship by proposing an aesthetic approach to the study of international relations—an unlikely coupling of aesthetics and politics in a field dominated by hard-nosed, statistics-laden studies that typically focus on interstate relationships. Bleiker, understandably, takes great pain to defend this approach in the introduction and conclusion, and he observes that the coupling is not so far-fetched when we recall that the founders of international relations theory, such as Hans Morgenthau, E. H. Carr, and Herbert Butterfield, brought literary interests to their studies. Of course, their interest in the aesthetic hardly compares to what Bleiker and his iconoclastic colleagues-in-arms propose to bring to the field.
A preliminary question occurred to me while reading this book: Why focus on the connection between aesthetics and world politics? How does this coupling differ from, say, the connection between cultural studies and world politics? A famous example might help here. The political firestorm over the publication of Salman Rushdie's The Satanic Verses (1988) highlighted the explosive relationship between art and politics. But mainstream scholars in international relations took this as an occasion to write about the way in which cultural conflict was replacing (or redefining) the older geopolitical conflicts of the Cold War. Samuel Huntington's “clash of civilizations” approach—focusing on the allegedly conflicting ideologies of Islam and Christendom—typified this argument.
Curiously left out of this sweeping reduction of the aesthetic to the cultural was any appreciation of the uniquely aesthetic qualities of Rushdie's novel that made it a lightning rod for political reaction in the first place. Clearly, Ayatollah Khomeini's fatwa demanding Rushdie's assassination bore witness to the power of art in shaping international relations.
Bleiker's book seeks to do more than simply bear witness to this rather indisputable fact. As the title clearly states, it is not art as such that captures the author's fancy but a much more elusive category: aesthetics. Bleiker contests the idea that aesthetics is a philosophical field far removed from political realities. His claim is that our understanding of political reality is always filtered through the lens of taken-for-granted theoretical and cultural presuppositions. This in itself might not seem remarkable, but drawing from Hans-Georg Gadamer's phenomenology, Bleiker argues that it is language that predominantly shapes our experience of the world; language, far from being an innocent medium of representation and signification, constructs the world metaphorically. He illustrates the importance of this aesthetic dimension of everyday language in framing international relations during the Cold War in terms of a “balance of power.” This metaphor came to define reality for IR scholars to such an extent that they could not entertain—despite evidence to the contrary—that the USSR's highly-vaunted military and economic capability was largely a myth constructed by the metaphor.
In addition to encouraging IR scholars to take seriously the metaphorical dimension of their own categorical understanding of political realities, Bleiker believes that an aesthetic approach to politics can also help policymakers understand political reality according to different tropes, thereby imagining less conventional policies. Last but not least, the author thinks that IR scholars should focus some of their empirical energies on exploring the political role of art, while attending to the political dilemmas that accompany aesthetic interventions in political life (pp. 187–88).
Having begun by discussing the larger theoretical implications of Bleiker's book for expanding the disciplinary boundaries of IR, let me now turn to a brief summary of the chapters. After laying out the aforementioned themes in a way that is not only comprehensive but also quite generous in acknowledging other scholarly contributions, Bleiker focuses on one political event of global importance—9/11—that perfectly illustrates the intersection of world politics, art, and aesthetics. Much has been said about the political “spin” surrounding the revolutionary shift in our political consciousness that followed this event, but Bleiker shows that beyond the metaphors of apocalyptic cataclysm and Manichean struggle between good and evil that shaped our understanding of global political reality post-9/11, there were aesthetic issues raised by the public's response to its horrific depiction.
Drawing extensively from Immanuel Kant's and Edmund Burke's philosophical treatments of the “sublime,” Bleicher shows how the painful pleasure associated with depictions of awesome (and awful) power/destruction reflects a deeper cognitive dissonance undermining our presumed grasp of political reality. In a sense, the experience of the sublime is a radical reminder of the infinite gulf separating political reality from our finite, prosaic understanding of it. The incommensurability between our power to represent in words and images what is infinitely beyond all representation and expression highlights our uncertain grasp of things and forces us to temper our own epistemic confidence. The author's discussion of the debates surrounding the design for the Ground Zero memorial illustrates this aesthetic motif by affirming the impossibility of summarily capturing all the contradictory emotions and representations attached to mourning, resisting, and rethinking the political tropes (most of them manifestly “heroic” and “masculine”) dominating our initial reaction to 9/11.
When thinking of the intersection of aesthetics and politics, most people are immediately drawn to the power of visual art. Picasso's Guernica depicting the carnage of war or, to take a more sinister example, Leni Riefenstahl's propaganda film, Triumph of the Will (1934) documenting the monumental, neoclassical staging of the events surrounding the Nazis' celebration of their party congress in Nuremberg, provide obvious—if misleading—examples of this thesis. Indeed, they raise important questions about how close art can be to political reality before it loses its essentially aesthetic—namely, transcendent, imaginary, and oppositional—relationship to that reality. Critical theorists such as Georg Lukács, Bertolt Brecht, Theodor Adorno, and Walter Benjamin debated these issues at length. Bleiker appears to come down on the side of those who believe that art must retain some semblance of autonomy from the political reality it seeks to “represent,” even if it remains close to the vernacular of popular culture and common sense. His preference for poetry as an exemplary artistic medium to illustrate his ideas—which dominates the second half of his book—is therefore understandable, when we recall the centrality of language in shaping our experience of anything whatsoever, and when we understand the remarkable capacity of poetic language in particular to express irony, to deconstruct its own superficial meaning, and to articulate the sublime ambiguity, indeterminacy, and incommensurability of a reality divided against itself.
Adorno once famously said that “poetry after Auschwitz” is impossible. He later recanted that statement in light of a rereading of Paul Celan's poetry—the topic of Bleiker's initial foray into the poetic illumination of political life. Bleiker's analysis of “Deathfugue,” whose metaphors are readily accessible to laypersons, shows that complex and ambivalent allegories on sublimely polarizing events such as the Holocaust can alter political understanding. Less obviously so are Celan's later poems, such as “The Straightening,” whose level of abstraction is far more challenging. This theme is taken up in Chapter 7's treatment of Pablo Neruda's overtly political poems written in a vernacular style. If “the author must produce more than mirror images of reality [and] has to distort visions,” then, in Bleiker's evaluation of Neruda's blindness to gender stereotypes and Stalinism, Neruda's “play with mirrors and mirror images, was characterized by mixed success” (p. 139).
A very different kind of politically compromised poetry is reflected in the East German Prenzlauer Berg group of the 1980s. Writing under extreme censorship and with fear of expatriation and imprisonment, many of these poets managed to convey the disillusionment with communism through ambivalent depictions of nature and domestic life or through experimental styles that reflect fragmentation, escape, or confinement. Rainer Schedlinski's poem “Die unvordenkliche Lichtung der Worte” expresses all three in its unorthodox visual layout. But the fact that Schedlinski also worked as an informant for the Stasi—and later rationalized this collaboration with postmodern indifference to truth and rightness—also underscores the way in which nihilistic poetry can accommodate itself to the status quo. The remaining chapters on Russian poet Anna Akhmatova and South Korean poet Ko Un are less problematizing, but they succeed in underscoring the poetic value of language (especially poetry) as a source of countermemory and counteridentity formation.
Aesthetics and World Politics will not be to everyone's taste. However, if one sets aside disciplinary conventions, it is a beautifully written tome that writes intelligently and competently about its subject matter from a number of different disciplinary perspectives.
