How should observers explain the surprising tenacity of China's one-party political system? Recent studies have generated a range of new concepts, all centered around the idea that successful authoritarian states, of which China is one, have become “smart,” “adaptive,” and “resilient,” meaning that effective institutional and political reforms have taken place even in the absence of substantive democracy. This book focuses on state-media-society relations as a window onto what author Daniela Stockmann terms China's “responsive authoritarianism” (p. 5). Its overarching argument is that media commercialization has not posed a serious threat to one-party authoritarian rule—a surprising conclusion given that market liberalization of the media in authoritarian countries was once seen as leading to political liberalization and democratization. This argument is supported by impressive fieldwork, survey data, and multi-method interdisciplinary analysis drawing from political science, communications, and social psychology, and for these reasons alone Media Commercialization and Authoritarian Rule in China will be required reading for any researcher seeking to understand political communication in China today. In addition, the book's rich conceptual vocabulary, attention to micro-processes, and comparative agenda make it valuable to those working on issues of cultural change and political communication in virtually any context. As a result, its intellectual impact should be felt across a range of areas and disciplines.
As observed in the book's introduction, China is only one of several authoritarian countries whose media have become more market-oriented in recent years. However, as China has not subsequently experienced democratization or pronounced political instability as a result of marketization, the question is: why not? By focusing on “the circumstances under which marketization of media benefits authoritarian rule and the mechanisms that tie state, media, and audiences together” (p. 4, emphasis in original), Stockmann provides a compelling explanation by demonstrating how marketization and accompanying new forms of media control have helped China's government to solve its “dictator's dilemma.” Simply put, the state must know what people are thinking in order to fine-tune its governance, but at the same time must control what people think in order to ensure the one-party system's legitimacy and survival—how to balance these two contradictory needs represents the “dilemma.” It is unavoidable because management of public opinion appears to significantly reduce the costs of governance. Media marketization (deregulation, privatization, and commercialization) is desirable because market signals in response to news stories are seen as reasonable proxies for what the public really believes, not because the government actually seeks to promote a free press. Marketization also lowers the operational costs of media production and management, as social complexity drives people to seek out media in the marketplace as a diversion and source of information. In other words, people will pay for propaganda even when they know it is propaganda. What matters, as it turns out, is whether the propaganda is useful, whether the newspaper seems trustworthy, and how the propaganda is framed.
These conclusions may also seem somewhat counterintuitive, but are backed up by painstaking research. Stockmann is part of a new wave of social scientists who believe that public opinion matters to authoritarian politics. Chapter 2, “Instruments of Regime Stability and Change,” shows that China's leaders, starting with Mao Zedong, have made propaganda a critical element of the Communist Party's approach to authoritarian rule. In more recent decades, China's newspaper industry has been reformed—that is to say, marketized—in ways that have allowed for the survival of official newspapers and the emergence of nonofficial newspapers. However, the industry as a whole remains state-controlled.
Chapter 3, “Types of Newspapers in China,” details the numerous infrastructures that boost state capacity even in this increasingly competitive media sphere: control over industry, control over editorial appointments, control over journalists (including punitive actions leading to self-censorship), and the absence of laws protecting free speech. Interviews with propaganda personnel, editors, and journalists in Beijing and Chongqing support the argument that competition and journalistic professionalization has led to a wider range of news outlets and story formats without seriously challenging these infrastructures; moreover, “closed” topics (i.e., topics of great political sensitivity) are restricted to coverage by official newspapers, whose editorial lines are in turn shaped directly by party institutions.
Two dense and analytically satisfying empirical sections (part 1, “The Production of News,” and part 2, “Media Credibility and Its Consequences”) provide thorough evidence for Stockmann's claims that marketization has not eliminated propaganda from the marketplace but, to the contrary, strengthened its grasp on institutions and readers' attention. Those interested in the methodological foundations of the study will find additional rich material in the book's five appendices. Stockmann spreads her final conclusions across an additional two comparative chapters that suggest that media marketization and media credibility may be the key ingredients in the relative durability of one-party rule, in contrast with other authoritarian state forms. Some readers may argue that it is still too soon to tell, while others may find that the book, like other recent studies of China's party-controlled media system, gives too much credit to just one element of the Communist Party's governing strategy in explaining why no successful challenges to one-party rule have yet arisen. Certainly, however, Media Commercialization and Authoritarian Rule in China will stimulate further discussion of these issues, and has in the meantime significantly raised the empirical bar for interpretations of how governments, newspapers, and audiences interact under conditions of political media management.
