These are two valuable books on the related topics of human rights and transitional justice, although they approach these topics in very different ways. Sonia Cardenas provides an encyclopedic analysis of the common themes that run through scores of national human rights institutions (NHRIs), which she correctly notes have been neglected in the scholarship on human rights. Kirsten Weld, on the other hand, focuses on the struggle to achieve justice in one of the countries reviewed by Cardenas that is marked by severe violations of human rights, Guatemala.
Where Cardenas is concerned with administrative institutions such as national human rights commissions and ombudsman offices, Weld’s point of entry into the dynamics of transitional justice is the less visible institution of the archive. Weld’s complicated story begins with the abandoned records of the Guatemalan City National Police and ends with their reorganization and deployment as an instrument for the vindication of human rights by political activists. Despite these obvious differences, there is an important lesson to be drawn by considering these two studies in tandem. Institutions such as the ones Cardenas and Weld study are battlegrounds on which political conflicts over what counts as a human right and what can legitimately be done to protect or promote such rights are played out during times of regime change and civil war. NHRIs and archives can be used to restrain states from abusing their power, but they can also be used by states to camouflage the violation of human rights. This ambiguity is reflected in the metaphors they use to introduce their argument.
Cardenas’s title—Chains of Justice—trades on a metaphor I was not familiar with, the seventeenth-century Indian image of a long golden chain that citizens unsatisfied with the administration of justice at lower levels can pull on in order to appeal directly to the emperor. Similarly, Cardenas argues, NHRIs provide an alternative means of appeal when the normal protections of human rights fail or when the state itself is culpable of violating these rights. She correctly reminds us that like the chain of justice, NHRIs can also function in an oppressive way, deflecting international criticism of a state’s human rights record and even serving as a “mouthpiece” for a state with a repressive record (p. 13).
Weld’s metaphor in Paper Cadavers, Ariadne’s thread, is also intentionally ambiguous, revealing the complex role that archives can play in the process of transitional justice (p. 253). Ariadne’s legendary ball of thread that she gave to Theseus so that he could find his way out of the Minotaur’s labyrinth represents, in Weld’s hands, two ways of “thinking archivally.” An archive is not simply a repository of historical knowledge that we enter in order to extract information; it is a way of creating and using knowledge to repress dissident minorities and it is a way of reorganizing knowledge in order to contest a repressive authority (p. 16). Weld takes us back into “the cave” to see how information was gathered by the Guatemalan City National Police to repress democratic activists, and then she follows the thread forward in time as activists (and some members of the police themselves) reorganize the original files in order to create a path leading to a more democratic future.
Cardenas’s reach is extraordinary. Temporally, she begins with the early precursors to NHRIs in the mid-twentieth century and charts their early formation and diffusion up to the present, using the United Nations “Paris Principles” of 1993 as a benchmark. Geographically, she covers this process in Africa, the Asia Pacific region (an artifact of United Nations bookkeeping), Europe, and the Americas. What has led to this diffusion of national institutions? According to Cardenas, when human rights violations are in question, one way that “self-regulating states” can reassert their authority is to create an NHRI. There are, according to the author, typically three occasions when this response is likely to occur. One such occasion she describes generally as a “regulatory moment,” modeled on Bruce Ackerman’s notion of a constitutional moment (1993) in We the People: Volume 1. Democratic regime changes, new constitutions, and peace agreements are examples of such regulatory moments when one would expect the establishment of an NHRI to resolve political norm ambiguity. (59) Besides these regulatory moments, external treaty obligations can create the incentive for states to introduce new, ostensibly self-regulating institutions, and at other times transnational or domestic pressure because of human rights violations can be the incentive. (Chains, p. 61).
Reviewing her case studies, Cardenas concludes that the “strongest incentive to create an NHRI nonetheless arose internally, among states experiencing a regulatory moment” (p. 65). It is significant, she adds, that the likelihood that a state will create an NHRI depends less on the extent of democracy than it does on whether the regime is undergoing a transition or not (p. 65). However, she is reluctant to draw very strong general conclusions. Instead, she urges the reader to take a look at regional patterns and individual cases.
One of many insights that Cardenas shares is the pattern of institutionalization in Anglophonic and Francophonic African countries in the 1990s. Among the first group, the Commonwealth States, she describes two processes of diffusion and strategic emulation. The states in the first group (Namibia, Ghana, South Africa, Malawi, and Uganda) were primarily responding to internal regulatory moments when they created NHRIs. For example, Namibia, the first to act, was impelled by national independence and a protracted, negotiated process of constitutional drafting. The second group (Nigeria, Ethiopia, Zambia, and Kenya) was motivated to act by external critics of ongoing abuse (p. 108). In these cases, the new NHRIs enjoyed only limited independence from the state (p. 113). The creation of NHRIs during this first decade in Francophonic states was more cosmetic (p. 121), and the diffusion of these institutions to other parts of the continent over the next decade had similar weaknesses. The main lesson that Cardenas draws from these cases is that while the most recent diffusion of NHRIs in Africa has been the result of international pressure from external multilateral institutions like the World Bank, African leaders have still been able to “deploy NHRIs strategically to resist incursions into their rule” (p. 152).
An interesting case that illustrates some of the limitations of NHRIs is Iran, a country that since 1995 has created a series of national institutions that in various ways have failed to meet the minimum requirements of the Paris Principles. Cardenas traces the complex pattern of institutional adaptation that has emerged as a result of external pressure on, and domestic political change within, Iran (p. 204). An example of a similar phenomenon is Guatemala, the subject of Weld’s in-depth study. Here is a country in which approximately 200,000 of its own citizens have been killed by the government over the past 30 years. There was certainly a need for an NHRI. As the first Latin American country to create an NHRI, Guatemala,’through its military dictatorship, introduced its particular hybrid version of a civil rights commission and ombudsman in 1985 as part of an effort to present itself as a constitutional order after decades of brutal military rule. In Cardenas’s terms, the incentives were to appease its critics and to retain power, leading her to conclude that even though in 1999 the Guatemalan NHRI had earned a “B-status rating and was soon fully accredited,” the overall result was still a nominal democracy and an NHRI that “has never managed to escape its origins as a halfhearted agency” (p. 97).
Having compiled this information on more than a hundred NHRIs, Cardenas turns to the crucial evaluative question of influence: How well have these institutions protected and promoted human rights? The record in countries such as Iran and Guatemala, not surprisingly, is discouraging. However, Cardenas does not reduce influence to enforcement or punishment. Instead, she asks how effective NHRIs have been in creating a “public, discursive, and normative space in which to confront and engage one another” (p. 311). Her emphasis on process rather than only outcome metrics leads her to formulate a set of “stages of accountability” that begin with the process of documentation and remediation, followed by what she calls “prevention.” To gauge the effectiveness during this final stage, she calls attention to the processes of socialization of authorities and the education of the public. Have public authorities truly adopted the language of human rights and have citizens become more aware of what constitutes their violation and nonfulfillment (pp. 319–20)? The records are mixed, and it bears repeating that in cases where human rights violations have occurred, they often occur at the hands of the state. Therefore, one should not expect that it will be easy for an NHRI to break this pattern and protect and promote the very rights that the state has been violating. The work is difficult and the risks of reprisals are high. What the NHRI can do in situations like this, however, is to make it clear that “the subject of human rights is no longer perceived as being ‘anti-national’” (p. 348).
Where Cardenas works in broad strokes on a global canvas, Weld is a pointillist, detailing the processes of repression and resistance in one locale. There is a conventional story, Weld reminds us, that consists of the U.S. overthrow of the democratically elected Arbenz government, subsequent Cold War support of the military dictatorship to quell an alleged communist insurgency, and the genocide of rural indigenous Mayan civilians. The full story, according to Weld, is much more complicated and does not underplay the role of Guatemalan political activists. But telling this side of the story requires more evidence, and until the National Police records were stumbled upon in 2005, that evidence was unavailable (Cadavers, p. 10).
With the accidental discovery of the Guatemalan National Police records—records whose existence had been flatly denied by the government—the history of the past decades of genocide and myriad human rights violations could now be written. As of 2013, 15 million of a total 75 million pages of records kept by the National Police had been “cleaned, reordered, and digitized” (p. 12). What emerged was a very different picture of the perpetrators of violence (the police, not just the military) and the resistance offered by its victims, both urban and rural.
These police archives that documented state terror then gradually became a site on which a new generation of politically active Guatemalans began to write the next chapter in their history: “Increasingly, human rights activists have come to phrase their demands upon the state in archival terms: to obtain documentary means to obtain truth, and to obtain truth means to obtain justice” (p. 14). This is what Weld means by “thinking archivally.” By reading Weld together with Cardenas, we are reminded that archives, just like human rights commissions, can serve as “public, discursive, normative spaces” in which the abuses of power can be more openly and democratically examined.
As an historian and participant-observer in the “Project for the Recovery of the National Police Historical Archives,” Weld brings us inside the archives. Her interviews with amateur archivists do not shy away from their personal connections to the deceased, but at the same time she stresses how important the work becomes for them politically (p. 154). Working side by side with police agents during the Project, some activists, though by no means all, came to see their relationship to the National Police in different terms: “They would give us water, which was scarce, and we would share space with them, and that was how things started to change for the first time, how the relationship advance. And that’s how you open up ideologically” (p. 176).
The Project has led to several indictments and convictions, and other criminal investigations by other domestic bodies have occurred, including the prosecution of “ex-dictator Efrain Rios Montt, the first-ever former head of state to be prosecuted for genocide in his home country’s domestic court system” (p. 242). However, the Right has pushed back. In 2011 one of Rios Montt’s political allies filed “a lawsuit against twenty-six ex-guerilla leaders, including Gustavo Meoño, director of the archival recovery project” (p. 244). Rios Montt’s conviction in 2013 for genocide against the Mayan people in 1982 and 1983 was overturned by the country’s highest court.
At a time when local police forces in the United States are under scrutiny because of the militarization of their tactics, not just their ordnance, together these two books serve as a cautionary tale. Despite the absence of a National Human Rights Institution in the United States, Cardenas reminds us that there are many state human rights institutions in addition to the U.S. Civil Rights Commission that address some of the same issues that NHRIs address in other countries (Chains, p. 23). Human rights violations can be committed by local police forces, not just the military, and state and local human rights institutions can be democratic discursive spaces or they can simply appease critics of human rights violations. Enlisted to fight an anticommunist counterinsurgency war, the Guatemalan City National Police committed crimes against humanity no different from the crimes committed by their counterparts in the Guatemalan military. Enlisted to fight a global war on drugs or terrorism, local police forces in the United States must be trained and mindful not to commit the same mistakes.
