Yemen rarely makes the international headlines, and when it does, it is usually depicted as a “problem” or “threat.” Among the countries of the Middle East, it is one of the least covered and understood. And yet, with its peculiar history, Yemeni society is fascinating and often fosters thought-provoking analysis that can shed new light on social, political, and historical processes elsewhere. The rarity of new academic publications on Yemen is such that each release is an event for “Yemenologists.” Noel Brehony's Yemen Divided: The Story of a Failed State in South Arabia is no exception: the author's experience, knowledge, and connections to local actors as well as to the issues he tackles allow him to produce a fascinating and highly commendable account of the story of South Yemen as an independent state.
The volume builds on interviews, archives, and numerous documents in Arabic and English as well as on the most relevant secondary sources. It is interesting that, similar to the two other seminal studies on South Yemen written in English over the last three decades by Helen Lackner and Fred Halliday, Yemen Divided is released at a time when Yemen is undergoing profound change: since late January 2011, a revolutionary uprising has created a new set of challenges, formally putting an end to ʿAli ʿAbd Allah Salih's thirty-three-year-old regime and reshuffling the cards among the various opposition movements, including those that are originally from the once independent South Yemen and are now advocating secession. The timing of the book's publication is reminiscent of Helen Lackner's PDR Yemen: Outpost of Socialist Development in Arabia (London: Ithaca Press, 1985), which came out just weeks before the South Yemeni capital, Aden, experienced a brief but brutal episode of violence in January 1986 that transformed imbalance between local elites while impinging on the research project Lackner had been working on for years. Likewise, Fred Halliday's Revolution and Foreign Policy: The Case of South Yemen (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990) was released in 1990, the year that North and South Yemen's unification would transform many of the international relations dynamics that Halliday had analyzed so brilliantly. These three coincidences do not, however, put into question the relevance of these volumes. Much to the contrary, they render them handy tools or textbooks for anyone seeking to understand the roots of the complex political crises that were unfolding.
Despite its lack of theoretical ambition or a comparative scope, particularly in regard to other similar historical trajectories (Germany, Korea, or Vietnam), Yemen Divided delivers a truly vivid and nuanced account of the internal tensions and institutional shortcomings of the socialist experience, explaining its formal collapse through unification with the North in 1990 and near disappearance in 1994 after the aborted secession attempt of the South. The book adopts a straightforward chronological structure and focuses mainly on institutions and the political leadership, briefly addressing in the conclusion the issue of unrest around the Southern Movement (al-Hirak al-Janubi) that has developed since 2007. Chapters and sections follow closely the changes in South Yemeni leadership and institutions, each coinciding with significant shifts in practices and objectives of the state. Among the topics covered are the confrontation between the radical National Liberation Front and the pragmatic Front for the Liberation of Occupied South Yemen in the late 1960s (Chapter 3) and the rivalries between Salim Rubayʿ ʿAli, ʿAbd al-Fatah Ismaʿil, and ʿAli Nasir Muhammad, which continued through most of the People's Democratic Republic of Yemen's (PDRY) history (Chapters 6, 8, and 10).
The book's main value rests in the author's ability to combine firsthand experience (from his posting in South Yemen as a British diplomat and numerous subsequent fieldwork visits) with accounts from a wide range of sources. As a result, the complexity of state and party structures between 1967 and 1994 as well as their incapacity to overcome many regional, political, and personal power struggles are analyzed with great meticulousness. Brehony presents in equal detail the scale of Northern domination after unification in 1990 (Chapter 12). Such precision, illustrated by numerous anecdotes along with interesting maps and appendices, is likely to turn this volume into a classic. The book is informative in regard to the sensitive issue of contemporary southern secessionist movements. It helps historians—as well as social scientists, journalists, and diplomats—to navigate the complex genealogies, organizations, regional kinships, and hundreds of individuals that have played, and continue to play, an active role in southern Yemen. It also elucidates the continuities between the guerillas of the 1960s who fought for independence and the figures who claim leadership (some with more success than others) of the current Southern Movement. Figures such as ʿAbd Allah al-Asnaj and ʿAli Nasir Muhammad have been prominent politicians for fifty years, managing to adapt to evolving circumstances and remaining interlocutors for journalists, experts, and foreign diplomats despite their weakening capacity to actually represent contemporary southern interest groups.
Noel Brehony's volume constitutes a timely contribution to today's urgent debates and raises a number of relevant questions: What can Southerners currently advocating for independence, as well as diplomats and analysts, learn from past experiences and mistakes? To what extent will such a legacy, culminating in the failure of the People's Democratic Republic of Yemen, hamper any future attempt to recreate an independent South? Overall, the author manages to develop a balanced argument. He develops a stance that is less biased toward the Marxist-leaning elites and movements he studies than was that of earlier works by Lackner, Halliday, and Vitaly Naumkin, author of Red Wolves of Yemen: The Struggle for Independence (Cambridge: Oleander Press, 2004), a classic of “South Yemen studies” initially published in Russian in 1981 and translated by the author into English in 2004. This is clearly an asset.
Brehony's decision to address the disappearance of the PDRY through the concept of a “failed state,” however, lacks any theoretical discussion. This concept, which is included in the title of the book and pops up in the introduction and conclusion, is highly questionable and far from neutral. It emerged in the framework of security studies in the early 1990s, and has essentially been used as a way of legitimizing foreign intervention and disrespect for state sovereignty by Western powers, in particular the United States. In discussing a country like Yemen, and more specifically the former South Yemen, where armed Islamist movements claiming links to al-Qaʿida are active and where American drones are currently waging a deadly war, referring to state failure, even as a purely historical description, is problematic. It may well implicitly encourage the reader to draw parallels between past failures and current incapacities to tackle so-called terrorist groups. This is all the more surprising because Noel Brehony's line of argument aims precisely to keep away from strictly security-oriented matters and to focus the reader's attention instead on the richness and complexity of Yemeni history, something he manages to do brilliantly over the course of the book.
