No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 03 March 2004
Rousseau is known as both exalted democrat and father of totalitarianism. Steven Johnston's book demonstrates that the two interpretations cannot be separated. Johnston evaluates Rousseau's texts hoping that the “costs of Rousseau's virtuous republic, many of them hidden or muted, can be reckoned alongside its accomplishments” (p. x.). Not surprisingly, Rousseau's accomplishments are called into question. This elegantly written and forcefully argued book claims that order is the essential ingredient in Rousseau's recipe for democracy. Developing the argument via Nietzsche's tragic perspective, Johnston wonders aloud whether all attempts at democracy will collapse under the weight of their internal contradictions.
Resisting the urge to simply “upbraid Rousseau,” Johnston promises to “rethink and radicalize certain aspects of his thought” (p. 3). His focus highlights tragic elements inherent in Rousseau's theorization of the state of nature, the politics of the founding, the role of government, and the existence of enmity. Describing the “phantasmic life” tragedy enjoys in the “interstices” of Rousseau's work, Johnston claims that tragedy manifests itself at “untimely moments” (p. ix). Marginalization ensues from promises of freedom, domination springs from equality, difference rears its ugly head in the quest for identity, arbitrariness haunts legitimacy, cruelty accompanies virtue, and on these dilemmas continue (p. ix). To characterize this sequence as loss, failure, or unfulfilled promise, however, misses Johnston's point. He argues that tragedy is “inescapable, inevitable, inexorable, and—what is more—commonplace, even banal…. Tragedy lies in wait, an inevitable concomitant to human exertions and projects” (p. 9). If the tragic is all too human, as it were, Rousseau could not do otherwise than to manifest tragic elements in his thought. How, then, does Johnston, radicalize Rousseau? Can he, as he claims, “enlist Rousseau as an ally against himself?” (p. 3).
Johnston's chapter “On Government” aptly illustrates his method. Johnston does well to employ Letter to D'Alembert, Political Economy, Considerations on the Government of Poland, and Constitutional Project for Corsica to “think about the political dicta of The Social Contract in terms of the principles and practices of governmentality that permeate these works” (p. 76). Here he moves from Rousseau's specific examples to consider again his general theoretical exposition. Johnston claims that this approach will “tame the seductive rhetorical powers of The Social Contract” (p. 77). Indeed it does. The way Johnston constructs his argument, with help from a 1978 lecture by Foucault titled “Governmentality,” one might think that Rousseau's dictates on sovereignty and the art and role of government were written expressly to illustrate the dangers governing oneself poses in this newly exposed Foucaultian universe. As Johnston puts it, “Rousseauian practices of government presuppose and engender relations of reciprocal subjugation more than autonomous determination” (p. 89).
How could this happen? Isn't government, in Rousseau's formulation, intrinsically dangerous, mandated to operate merely at the behest and in the service of sovereignty? Were we to read only The Social Contract, we might conclude that Rousseau recognizes the dangers of government and the constant power struggle between the forces of government and sovereignty. Yet even within these pages Rousseau hints at an “algebra of order” in claiming that the “modern age, with its humongous states, does not lend itself to the pursuit of republicanism” (p. 83). The government must be “relatively stronger in proportion as the people is more numerous” (The Social Contract, p. 80; cited by Johnston, p. 84). Political activity in such large states fails to mold citizen behavior and government steps in to fill the void. Johnston's attention to the “specific, the contemporary, the local, the empirical” (p. 100), as Rousseau explores in the essays on Poland and Corsica and Letter to D'Alembert, reveals that the citizen is not formed through the political activity of enacting and engaging in sovereignty. Instead, the citizen is produced “through disciplinary processes centering on the regulation of bodies in public space” (p. 98). Military discipline takes the lead in Considerations on the Government of Poland; in the essay on Corsica, citizens are created through service in the corvée; Letter to D'Alembert illustrates the “panoptical architecture” of the marriage festival (p. 103). “Here the subject-citizen is disclosed as the contrivance of power—an artifice to be constructed more than an essence to be realized…. The art of government rather than the exercise of sovereignty is responsible for its manufacture” (p. 87).
Johnston's argument that Rousseau accomplishes what he appears to least desire is convincing. In the chapter “On Enmity” we discover that the enemy is always within; the “republic's enemies seem to be proliferating at an alarming rate” (p. 139). Thus while Rousseau rightfully fears the encroaching arm of government, he reproduces its tactics in creating and encouraging the art of government to form his citizens. Though he desires a virtuous republic, the battle each citizen must fight within himself (against individual will), against women (effeminacy), and against all signifiers of difference yields an uncompromising totality where freedom requires total submission.
But must the analysis end here? Johnston hints that a “full-bodied democratic politics” may be “newly capable of finessing” the “tragedies of social and political life” (p. 24). Yet the reader is never offered as much as a nod in the direction toward creating this new politics. In fact, we are told the contrary: Any political community is “an arbitrary, contingent artifact;” we are not meant “to live one way rather than another, ruled by this set of values rather than that one” (p. 5). We have learned here that violence, cruelty, and enmity are at the heart of democratic politics. How, then, and why might we be moved to take any political action whatsoever? The intellectual exercise performed by Johnston is a treat to read. Yet this reader wonders where we go from here politically. Rousseau, above all else, insists that we demand attention and commitment to the ways in which a more democratic politics might be theorized and the spaces in which it might be enacted. Despite the valuable insights into Rousseau that Johnston reveals, the limitations of this form of theorizing also lie exposed. A Social Contract completely purged of its seductive power doesn't leave us any space for imagining and enacting new forms of community.
Comments
No Comments have been published for this article.