Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T20:14:43.454Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

School cohesion, speed and efficiency are modulated by the swimmers flapping motion

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  13 July 2021

Sina Heydari
Affiliation:
Aerospace and Mechanical Engineering, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA 90089, USA
Eva Kanso*
Affiliation:
Aerospace and Mechanical Engineering, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA 90089, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: kanso@usc.edu

Abstract

Fish schools are ubiquitous in marine life. Although flow interactions are thought to be beneficial for schooling, their exact effects on the speed, energetics and stability of the group remain elusive. Recent numerical simulations and experimental models suggest that flow interactions stabilize in-tandem formations of flapping foils. Here, we employ a minimal vortex sheet model that captures salient features of the flow interactions among flapping swimmers, and we study the free swimming of a pair of in-line swimmers driven with identical heaving or pitching motions. We find that, independent of the flapping mode, heaving or pitching, the follower passively stabilizes at discrete locations in the wake of the leader, consistent with the heaving foil experiments, but pitching swimmers exhibit tighter and more cohesive formations. Further, in comparison to swimming alone, pitching motions increase the energetic efficiency of the group while heaving motions result in a slight increase in the swimming speed. A deeper analysis of the wake of a single swimmer sheds light on the hydrodynamic mechanisms underlying pairwise formations. These results recapitulate that flow interactions provide a passive mechanism that promotes school cohesion, and afford novel insights into the role of the flapping mode in controlling the emergent properties of the school.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2021. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.A pair of swimmers undergoing (a) heaving motions at amplitude $A_{{h}} = 0.3$ and (b) pitching motions at amplitude $A_{{p}} = 15^{\circ }$. Snapshots of the velocity field (grey arrows) and free vortex sheet of the leader (blue) and follower (red) are taken after steady-state swimming is reached at a time instant where both swimmers are flapping downwards. Insets depict the pressure forces acting on each swimmer in the pairwise formation in comparison to a single swimmer undergoing the same prescribed motion.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Swimming speed vs. flapping amplitude for single swimmers. (a) Average swimming speed at steady state for a heaving swimmer. (b) Average swimming speed at steady state for a pitching swimmer. At small $A_{{p}}$, skin drag is dominant and the speed scales super-linearly with $A_{{p}}$. For $A_{{p}}>10^{\circ }$, pressure drag is dominant and speed scales linearly with $A_{{p}}$. (c) Experimental data (black symbols) of average swimming speed of a heaving foil (Ramananarivo et al.2016, figure 2); the data collapse when scaled by the heaving frequency $f^{4/3}$ (yellow symbols). (d) Comparing the swimming speed of our heaving swimmer model (blue circles) to the frequency-scaled experimental data shown in (a), on a log–log scale. Both model and experimental results scale super-linearly with heaving amplitude.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Emergence of passive stable formations in a pair of heaving swimmers ($A_{{h}} = 0.3$) and of pitching swimmers ($A_{{p}} = 15^{\circ }$). (a) For heaving swimmers, the follower stabilizes at one of many discrete positions behind the leader where the gap (tail-to-head) distance $d_{{h}}$ is close to integer multiple of the wavelength $\lambda = U/f$ of the leader motion. (b) For pitching swimmers, the follower stabilizes at locations such that the tail-to-tail distance $d_{{p}}$ is close to integer multiples of $\lambda$. Basins of attraction of each the first three equilibria are depicted in gradually more faint shades of grey. (c,d) Linear stability analysis: we perturb the position of the follower about each of these equilibria and compute the total hydrodynamic force $F_x$. We simultaneously sample data from the change in $F_x$ and perturbation strength $\delta x$, and plot $\delta F_x$ vs. $\delta x$. Clearly, $\delta F_x$ acts as a restoring force. Taking the slope of $\delta F_x$, we construct the hydrodynamic potential $V$ on the follower. The potential well is deepest at the first equilibrium where the hydrodynamic interactions are strongest.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Instantaneous swimming performance (time-dependent speed, thrust, input power and cost of transport vs. time) for a single and pair of swimmers undergoing (a) heaving at $A_h = 0.3$ and (b) pitching at $A_p = 15^{\circ }$, respectively. Results are shown after the swimmers have reached steady state. From top to bottom, the swimming speed, thrust force, input power and cost of transport are shown. Solid lines represent the instantaneous values and dashed lines represent time-period averages.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Swimming performance (average speed, thrust, input power and cost of transport) vs. flapping amplitude for a single and pair of swimmers undergoing (a) heaving and (b) pitching motions, respectively. From top to bottom, average values of the swimming speed, thrust force, input power and cost of transport. Left columns (black symbols) in (a,b) show the results for single swimmers. For the pair of swimmers, all of the results are scaled by the corresponding quantity values for a single swimmer. The blue and red symbols represent the results for the follower and leader, respectively. The grey symbols are the school average.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Flow agreement parameter and thrust parameter experienced by a hypothetical point follower undergoing prescribed oscillations in the wake of a single swimmer that does not see the follower. Top row shows flow agreement parameter field in the wake of (a) heaving and (b) pitching swimmers. The grey plates represent the steady-state position of the followers in the first, second and third stable spacings found from solving the system with pairwise interactions (figure 3). In both cases, the distance of the regions with maximum flow agreement from the leading plate is very close to integer multiples of the wavelength ($d_{{{h}}, {{p}}}/\lambda = 1, 2,3$). Bottom row shows thrust parameter as a function of distance. The dashed lines represent the head and tail positions of the heaving and pitching follower, respectively. The negative slopes of plot at the steady-state distances imply linear stability of the follower to in-line perturbations. The prescribed amplitudes are $A_{{h}} = 0.3$ and $A_{{p}} = 15^{\circ }$.

Figure 6

Figure 7.(a) Schematic of the vortex sheet model for a two-dimensional flapping swimmer. (b) Depiction of the different hydrodynamic forces acting on the swimmer.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Hydrodynamic forces on the follower act as restoring forces. Snapshots of pairs of swimmers undergoing (a) heaving and (b) pitching motion during transient and steady-state formation. Green (thrust) and orange (drag) arrows represent period-averaged hydrodynamic forces acting on the follower. Right columns in (a,b) show the instantaneous thrust and skin drag (solid lines) and their period-averaged values (dashed lines) over one flapping period during transient and steady-state formation. The grey dashed lines denote the time instance of the snapshots shown to the left.

Heydari and Kanso supplementary movie

Flow interactions in pairs of heaving, pitching, and simultaneously heaving and pitching swimmers lead to stable formations

Download Heydari and Kanso supplementary movie(Video)
Video 7.7 MB