The question whether miracles can — or indeed do — occur has been central to many modern debates between critics and apologists of Christianity. It is a question worth considering, at least for a moment, before engaging with Giselle De Nie's Poetics of Wonder; for De Nie treats miracles, as ‘occurring’ in the late antique Christian Latin texts which she interprets, not merely as literary elements within these texts, dating from an era long gone by, but as expressions of actual human experience which can be shared even today. In order to argue this case De Nie makes use of some modern and post-modern models of perception, imagination and the transforming power of images, which some modern theologians have already adapted for the interpretation of the miraculous in the Christian experience.
The general attitude towards miracles in the earliest (that is, second- and third-century) Christian writings is that they were powerful and numerous in the time of Jesus and the apostles, but that they somewhat waned in the subsequent periods. Then, during the fourth century, the attitude began to change. Emperors converted to Christianity, cults of martyrs and relics emerged, holy men and women exercised spiritual authority, which included the working of miracles. By the end of the fourth century a predominant notion had emerged that ‘the miracles of ancient times are renewed’ (49).
De Nie develops in eight chapters the various ways in which this new attitude of making miracles — that is presently occurring miracles (not miracles from a distant past) — was established as an essential part of the public discourse on Christian faith. Her time frame is, roughly, the fifth century, from Ambrose's appropriation in the a.d. 370s and 380s of the martyr cult in Milan to Bishop Perpetuus’ intensification from the 450s of the cult of Saint Martin in Tours. Ch. 1 attests to the tensions caused by the new attitude at the time around a.d. 400. There were on the one hand enthusiastic promoters of the martyr cult such as Ambrose of Milan and Victricius of Rouen, but there was also a strong and widespread opposition to it, particularly in Gaul, as becomes evident from Jerome's notorious polemic against Vigilantius. Obviously, Jerome did not want to be associated with that opposition, yet nor was he as fanatical about the miraculous powers of material remains of martyrs — mainly bones and blood — as, for example, Victricius of Rouen.
Ch. 2 deals with evidence of contemporary criticism against Martin of Tours’ working of miracles and Sulpicius Severus’ defence of Martin. De Nie finds in the Life of Martin descriptions that are apparently reminiscent of shamanic practices as recorded by modern-day cultural anthropologists in some Native American cultures, experiences or phenomena such as being filled, pushed or shaken by some physical power, being surrounded by a ring of flames, shaking, trembling, passing out and falling into a state of trance. The chapter concludes with the outlines of a christological hermeneutic of Sulpicius’ approach, which puts at its centre ‘the saint himself as a shining figure in the dreamvision … reflecting the glorified Christ’ (181). Ch. 3 develops this aspect in a study of Paulinus of Nola's Natalicia for Saint Felix of Nola. The fact that these texts are poems adds a further ‘divinatory’ aspect: ‘Paulinus’ imaginative explorations’, De Nie concludes in this chapter, ‘are an elaborate demonstration not only of Jung's synchronistic or “psycho-physical” events, and possibly Drewermann's innate patterns, but also of Barth's “divination and poetry”’ (223).
Ch. 4 moves on to Augustine. In comparison with the creative writings discussed in the first three chapters De Nie finds Augustine's lengthy expositions ‘tiresome’ (275), but she acknowledges that his purpose, too, ‘was to open the eyes of the “heart” or imagination to “see” the manner of God's love creating and transforming everything’ (ibid.). The next two chapters stay in Africa. Ch. 5 studies an anonymous sermon from early fifth-century Uzalis, De miraculis sancti Stephani, and ch. 6 returns to Augustine analysing his sermons about the martyrs.
Ch. 7 returns to poetry and describes how Sedulius Scottus’ Carmen paschale presents a miracle as a sacrament which the reader or hearer consumes in a mystical act. Ch. 8 finally describes how the ‘once-eccentric’ Saint Martin of Tours was ‘re-presented’, fifty years after his death, in the time of Bishop Perpetuus, as ‘a saint for our times’, a new era, according to De Nie, for whom the discourse of miracles was no longer tentative or controversial, but had become a ‘living, compassionate poetics [De Nie's emphasis] of the divine “mysteries” that … were constantly embodied in the visible world’ (486). In the conclusion De Nie is keen not to force this developmental aspect of her dissertation. Her aim, she insists, was to let each of the authors, ‘each distant voice’, speak for himself, ‘to let its “poetics of wonder” speak to us today’ (489).
Yet despite this disclaimer, which puts the emphasis more on the literary aspects of this study, the fact that it deals more, as the subtitle states, with literary ‘testimonies’ rather than historical developments, the book does give an impression of social and cultural change during the late fourth and through the fifth century, from a society ruled by rational order to one permeated by a miraculous mystique. The texts studied by De Nie are seminal in explaining this development and her techniques of employing modern and post-modern methods of psycho-social and literary study to interpret her sources open up some new and interesting perspectives for the student of late antique religion and culture.
