Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T01:45:23.842Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Sedimentation of spheroidal bodies near walls in viscous fluids: glancing, reversing, tumbling and sliding

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 May 2015

William H. Mitchell
Affiliation:
Department of Mathematics, University of Wisconsin – Madison, 480 Lincoln Drive, Madison, WI 53706, USA
Saverio E. Spagnolie*
Affiliation:
Department of Mathematics, University of Wisconsin – Madison, 480 Lincoln Drive, Madison, WI 53706, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: spagnolie@math.wisc.edu

Abstract

The sedimentation of a rigid particle near a wall in a viscous fluid has been studied numerically by many authors, but analytical solutions have been derived only for special cases such as the motion of spherical particles. In this paper the method of images is used to derive simple ordinary differential equations describing the sedimentation of arbitrarily oriented prolate and oblate spheroids at zero Reynolds number near a vertical or inclined plane wall. The differential equations may be solved analytically in many situations, and full trajectories are predicted which compare favourably with complete numerical simulations. The simulations are performed using a novel double-layer boundary integral formulation, a method of stresslet images. The conditions under which the glancing and reversing trajectories, first observed by Russel et al. (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 83, 1977, pp. 273–287), occur are studied for bodies of arbitrary aspect ratio. Several additional trajectories are also described: a periodic tumbling trajectory for nearly spherical bodies, a linearly stable sliding trajectory which appears when the wall is slightly inclined, and three-dimensional glancing, reversing and wobbling.

Information

Type
Papers
Copyright
© 2015 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic of a prolate spheroid near an infinite plane wall located along the $xy$-plane. The body, with centroid a distance $h$ from the wall, is rotated through an angle ${\it\phi}$ about the $\hat{\boldsymbol{z}}$ axis and is pitched at an angle ${\it\theta}$ about its lateral axis. The dimensionless force due to gravity acts at an angle ${\it\beta}$ relative to the wall, $\boldsymbol{F}=\cos {\it\beta}\hat{\boldsymbol{x}}-\sin {\it\beta}\hat{\boldsymbol{z}}$, with ${\it\beta}$ set to zero in the illustration above.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Trajectories of prolate spheroidal bodies sedimenting near walls, as determined by full numerical simulation: (a) symmetric glancing; (b) symmetric reversing; (c) periodic tumbling (the distance travelled along the wall has been scaled by a factor of 100); (d) stable sliding near an inclined wall. The white markers on the tumbling body illustrate the rotation. Initial data and body shapes in each case are given in appendix C.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Three-dimensional glancing (a,b) and reversing (c,d) of prolate (a,c) and oblate (b,d) bodies near a vertical wall. The black rectangle in the background of each frame represents a strip of the wall, $\{(x,y,0):-2\leqslant y\leqslant 2\}$. Gravity is parallel to the wall, i.e. vertical on the page; the horizontal axis is the $y$ direction. The lateral movements are plotted to scale, while the movements in the $x$ direction have been greatly reduced for visualization purposes. Animations of these four trajectories are included as supplementary data available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2015.222. The initial data used to generate these trajectories are given in appendix C. The movies, along with movies of periodic tumbling and wobbling of nearly spherical prolate and oblate bodies, are included as supplementary data.

Figure 3

Table 1.Parameter definitions for the prolate and oblate cases in the Faxén laws (4.6) and (4.7) and the general system (A 1)–(A 10), from Kim & Karrila (1991). Of these, only $X^{A}$ and $Y^{A}$ appear directly in (A 1)–(A 10) because we have exploited the relation $Y^{H}/Y^{C}=\pm e^{2}/(2-e^{2})$. The quantity $\pm (X^{A}-Y^{A})$ is negative for both body types.

Figure 4

Figure 4.The gap size for which a body with ${\it\theta}=0$ does not rotate as a function of particle eccentricity, which distinguishes the transition from glancing to periodic tumbling. The results of full numerical simulations are shown as symbols and those according to (5.4) as lines. The results for prolate and oblate bodies are remarkably similar, with the accuracy of the analytical estimates for both deteriorating for large particle eccentricity where the equilibrium distance is very close to the wall.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Two-dimensional trajectories of prolate spheroids sedimenting near a vertical wall are depicted by plotting the particle–wall distance $h$ against the orientation angle ${\it\theta}$, for (a) $e=0.02$, (b) $e=0.15$, (c) $e=0.30$ and (d) $e=0.80$. Unphysical regions with $h\leqslant \sqrt{\sin ^{2}{\it\theta}+(1-e^{2})\cos ^{2}{\it\theta}}$, corresponding to body penetration through the wall, are shaded. The results of the full numerical simulations are shown as red symbols. For small $e$ we observe periodic orbits near the wall (circles). As $e$ increases, the periodic trajectories are replaced by reversing (squares) and glancing (triangles) trajectories. Arrows indicate the direction of time. The contours of the scalar function ${\it\Psi}$ from (5.9), shown as black lines, give accurate predictions of the full numerical results.

Figure 6

Figure 6.The transition angle between glancing and reversing trajectories for prolate bodies as a function of eccentricity. The solid curve is from the explicit formula (5.12). Numerical results are shown as red circles; at low eccentricity the transition angle is well resolved but at greater eccentricities we report only a range of possible values. The two stars on the right indicate the maximum glancing angle and the minimum reversing angle reported by Russel et al. (1977), who in addition to a numerical study used aluminium wires of aspect ratio $a/c\approx 60$ or $e=0.999861$. Between these angles they reported wall impacts. For oblate bodies, the theory predicts a slightly larger value of ${\it\theta}^{\ast }$ than in the prolate case, but the difference is less than one degree for $e<0.866$.

Figure 7

Figure 7.Three-dimensional trajectories of sedimenting prolate spheroids, from full numerical simulations (symbols) and integration of the fourth-order accurate ordinary differential equations (ODEs) from § 4 (lines). (a) Three-dimensional periodic tumbling orbit of a nearly spherical particle near a vertical wall: $e=0.05$, ${\it\beta}=0^{\circ }$. The dynamics is akin to a three-dimensional reversing trajectory that fails to escape from the wall. The analytical prediction captures the shapes and amplitudes of the particle–wall distance $h$ and the orientation angles ${\it\theta}$ and ${\it\phi}$, but with an error in the frequency of oscillation. (b) A reversing trajectory of a more eccentric particle near a vertical wall: $e=0.7$, ${\it\beta}=0^{\circ }$. The body visits the wall and departs, settling to a constant final orientation in both ${\it\theta}$ and ${\it\phi}$ as $h\rightarrow \infty$. (c) The same particle as in (b) near a slightly tilted wall converges to the stable sliding trajectory: $e=0.7$, ${\it\beta}=0^{\circ }$. The particle initially rotates while approaching the wall and then recedes towards a limiting separation distance and orientation, with ${\it\phi}\rightarrow {\rm\pi}$ (the dynamics tends towards the two-dimensional sliding trajectory).

Figure 8

Figure 8.A prolate body near a sufficiently inclined wall cannot escape; it either approaches the wall so closely that particle or wall imperfections or other physics become important, or it assumes a stable orientation at a constant separation distance. In the latter case, the asymptotic separation $h_{0}$ is a function of the wall inclination angle and the particle eccentricity, with contours plotted above. Near the boundary of the escaping trajectories in the $e{\it\beta}$-plane one can find arbitrarily large values of $h_{0}$.

Figure 9

Figure 9.The boundary integral method and the differential equations agree with the expected rate of convergence in the distance from the wall, with errors scaling as $O(h^{-4})$ in the translational velocity and as $O(h^{-5})$ in the rotational velocity. Using ${\it\theta}={\rm\pi}/5$, ${\it\phi}={\rm\pi}/7$, ${\it\beta}={\rm\pi}/100$ and $e=\sqrt{3}/2$, the differences between the computed and analytical translational and rotational velocity vectors in the $\Vert \cdot \Vert _{\infty }$ norm are shown. Both prolate and oblate bodies are considered, using 1972 quadrature nodes for the prolate body and 2281 for the oblate body. This may be viewed either as a validation of the full numerical scheme or as a check of the differential equations.

Figure 10

Table 2.Convergence tests for a resistance problem with an inclined oblate spheroid of aspect ratio 2 or 10 and with centroid at height 1.1 or 1.5, with $N$ the number of nodes used to discretize the body surface.

Figure 11

Table 3.Drag on a sphere of radius 0.1 translating parallel to a wall at six distances using four discretizations, normalized by the value predicted by Stokes’ law for an unbounded fluid. The shaded values were found using the method of stresslet images, as described in § 2.2. These are accompanied by results obtained via regularized Stokeslets, quoted from table 1 in Ainley et al. (2008).

Figure 12

Table 4.Drag on a sphere of radius 0.1 translating perpendicular to a wall at six distances using four discretizations, normalized by the value predicted by Stokes’ law for an unbounded fluid. The shaded values were found using the method of stresslet images, as described in § 2.2. These are accompanied by results obtained via regularized Stokeslets, quoted from table 2 in Ainley et al. (2008).

Figure 13

Table 5.Parameters and initial conditions for the model trajectories depicted in figures 2 and 3 as well as for the prolate and oblate tumbling trajectories shown in the supplementary movie.

Mitchell supplementary movie

Sedimentation near walls in viscous fluids. Six trajectories are shown: three-dimensional glancing and three-dimensional reversing of both prolate and oblate bodies, and periodic tumbling with a lateral wobble of nearly spherical prolate and oblate bodies.

Download Mitchell supplementary movie(Video)
Video 5.7 MB