To have a representative sample at a national scale of some 70,000 individuals who lived in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries with nominative information on a wide range of demographic, social, and economic characteristics such as their marital status, residence, profession, property, and assets at their death is surely an economic historian's dream. This book by three members of the team behind this quite exceptional research project describes in detail how the dream came true in France.
The TRA Survey is a unique historical micro data base. TRA holds for the three first letters of the names selected for the sample (Travers, Trajan, Traversier, etc.), patronymes chosen for their representativeness in all regions of France. The project draws its origin from the so-called «3,000 families» survey by Jacques Dupâquier, one of the founders of historical demography in France, in the early 1980s. His objective was to reconstitute the genealogy of 3,000 French couples who married between 1803 and 1832 and whose names began with the three letters TRA. With this large-scale national sample, Dupâquier wished to elude the constraints of local studies and monographs. For example, in the classic methods of family reconstitution, families that migrate must be left out. His survey could follow individuals moving throughout the country.
A few years later, a second phase was launched by Denis Kessler and his research unit at the CNRS to compile the estate at death of the heirs of these 3,000 «TRA» couples. Because the sources were to be found in the local offices and departmental archives, the research had to be conducted throughout the country. A very large number of people were involved from students and researchers in demography to civil servants to an army of volunteer local genealogists. They collected this decentralized information on each person whose name began with TRA and who died between 1800 and 1939. Their sources were the TSA (tables in which deceased individuals were identified alphabetically and chronologically) and the RMD (Registers of Transfers by Death), the latter a highly complex type of document.
Unsurprisingly for those who are familiar with the French state system, the civil and fiscal records used for the TRA Survey are typical products of a highly bureaucratic and controlling state. Particularly interesting is the discussion in chapter IV of the influence of the French Revolution and its fundamental principles of universality and equality on the fiscal and administrative systems. The idea was to set up a system to be applied to all French citizens. Hence, the Fiscal Administration from 1799 had to be notified of every death. Each office had to make sure that all estates were subject to declaration of wealth: either there was none to declare or if there was, the assets of all types had to be evaluated. One might argue that since this wealth was to be taxed, there was an incentive to escape reporting. The authors reply that this problem was mitigated by two factors: the low tax rate (typically 1 percent or less) and the benefit for the heirs of having their rights recorded and thus official. Still, the reporting was a daunting task well described in chapter V but produced material that has no equivalent in comparable countries, where typically wealth at death was subject to probate records on a voluntary basis.
The book thoroughly explains in great detail how the state proceeded to collect its data and how the research teams had to manipulate that data in order to match the diverse data sets and to follow these individuals over time and space. Non-specialists in historical demography will probably find that there are too many details. On the other hand, the authors clearly want potential users to be fully informed and aware of all data issues. As one can read in the Conclusion, they wish to keep the proximity to the sources.
The authors very carefully expose the bias and weaknesses of their sources such as the unequal quality between the regions and localities, especially at the beginning of the period, that is, in the early nineteenth century. For all kinds of reasons (laziness, intellectual capacity, willingness), mayors—the magistrates responsible for the declarations—did not all do a good job at compiling information. With all these caveats in mind, users will be able to investigate very interesting issues such as the evolution of economic inequalities and of wealth concentration over that period of modernization and industrialization.
In conclusion, the TRA Survey belongs to an international movement of historiographical renewal based on micro-data. In the case of France, it is the only comprehensive survey of that type, and therefore a very useful public good made available (CD Rom included) to researchers who after reading this book will be well informed about the strengths and weaknesses of the data they will use. This book covers the nineteenth century, more precisely 1793–1902; a second tome will follow on the first two thirds of the twentieth century.
