Pierre Hadot, professor emeritus of the Collège de France, has written a remarkably insightful book on the theme of the secrets of nature and their significance for the history of science and ideas about nature. First published in 2004 by Editions Gallimard, it is now available in English through Michael Chase's adept and eloquent translation. Hadot delves into numerous classical, medieval and early modern sources to analyse three interlocking themes: Heraclitus' famous aphorism ‘nature loves to hide’, the idea of the secrets of nature and the image of Nature as Isis/Artemis. These three themes are articulated through two attitudes towards nature. The first attitude is symbolized by Prometheus, and is manifested by human efforts to extract nature's secrets through magic and, ultimately, through science and technology for practical use by humankind – sometimes with disastrous and unforeseen consequences. The second is symbolized by Orpheus, and represents a poetic, aesthetic approach that appreciates nature's secrets as mysterious and ineffable, viewing nature as a poem evincing awe, anguish, terror and wonder. Hadot argues that the Promethean attitude reaches its height during the mechanistic revolution of the seventeenth century, whereas the Orphic attitude emerges most fully in the Romantic era (Rousseau, Goethe, Schelling, Nietzsche), and is continued into the present era by Heidegger, Merleau-Ponty and Wittgenstein. Hadot's own sentiments lie most strongly with the second attitude.
In Hadot's account, the idea that nature harbours secrets that were hidden from the vulgar was intimately bound up with the personification of Nature at least into the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. Consistent with Heraclitus' aphorism, personified Nature was understood as guarding ‘her’ secrets, concealing them under veils that hid the primary causes and workings of the living world, including the divine cause of the cosmos itself. In addition to quoting from a multitude of historical sources, Hadot astutely analyses a series of some eighteen illustrations that depict the unveiling of Nature personified as the fusion of the multibreasted Artemis and the Egyptian Isis, who states, ‘No mortal has raised my veil’. Seventeenth-century science, as heir to the twin legacies of classical mechanics and the occult sciences, set for itself the goal of unveiling the secrets of nature through experimentation and mathematics. Johannes Kepler, Galileo, Francis Bacon, Blaise Pascal, Descartes, Antoni van Leeuwenhoek and others framed much of their thinking in the tradition of uncovering the structures, parts and causes that nature conceals. But the progress of rational science and the dissociation of physics from philosophy ultimately undermined this tradition, with physics coming to focus on physical nature and philosophy on the problem of being itself.
Of particular interest to historians of science will be Hadot's conception of the Promethean attitude and the mechanization of nature. For some scientists, Nature allows herself to be unveiled by experimental science. For others, Nature is viewed as an enemy whose secrets must be torn from her by technology and even violence. Thus Francis Bacon, writes Hadot, ‘declared that Nature unveils her secrets only under the torture of experimentation’ (p. 35; also pp. 93 and 149). Hadot's analysis is significant for its focus on Nature as female both in reality and as metaphor during the Renaissance and early modern era, although he does not probe the idea of the secrets as sexual. Also, there are numerous instances of the Promethean unveiling of nature (for instance, in the unveiling of the secrets of the atom and the nucleus) in the twentieth century that Hadot does not pursue, his primary exemplars being confined to the mechanistic revolution. But whatever view the reader may hold of the rise of science or of the consequences of the Promethean attitude, The Veil of Isis is a rewarding voyage through a multitude of texts, illustrations and historical figures that brings a set of complex and often contradictory ideas into a clear and compelling argument.
