The Mexican Constitution of 1857 established the principle of free labor. Whereas in England, up until the revocation of the Master and Servant Acts in 1875, workers faced penal sanction if they left their employment, Mexican employers at mid-century were limited to suing for monetary damages if workers deserted before the end of their contract. In this outstanding book, William J. Suarez-Potts traces the liberal character of Mexican labor law, and the role of the courts in defending and extending this body of law into the early 1930s. The book challenges common perceptions of Mexican history and political economy. The country may have had a higher share of agricultural laborers than the period's industrial leaders, and semi-coercive employment practices existed widely in some rural areas, but its body of labor law was in no way backwards.
Mexico's legal system reflected an amalgam of influences. Roman legal concepts inspired legal education and practice. Following the French model, the main source of written law was the legislature. But American influences were also present. The 1857 and 1917 constitutions established a federal system of government, granting the federal judiciary and judiciary in each state a decisive and formative role. The court system and leading jurists, the real heroes in this story, emerged as agents of reform, actively engaged in the resolution of individual and group conflict until the advent of strict federal guidelines and social legislation.
The narrative is chronological but the author skillfully situates key episodes and actors in the book's larger themes. After relating the historical and intellectual origins of Mexican law, the early chapters describe the high court's defense, between 1875 and 1910, of the inherent rights of poor agricultural laborers demanding relief against the arbitrary decisions of employers and local authorities. Although the dictator Porfirio Díaz was attacked for his corruption, and subordinating judicial and legislative branches to executive diktat, his regime maintained constitutional and legal forms of rule. The concept of free labor remained operational. Countervailing pressures acted as a backstop. Based on European ideas, the Mexican legal community advanced an agenda of social legislation to supplement civil law. It also provided legal interpretation and a roadmap of how reform could best be achieved in the federal context. In 1904 the legislature of the state of Mexico enacted the country's first workers’ compensation law, which coincided with the adoption of similar laws elsewhere in the Atlantic world. The short-lived presidency of Francisco Medero (1911–1913) established a labor department and initiated the institutionalization of industrial relations, which also coincided with the inception of labor departments in the industrialized core.
The second part of the book relates the story from the revolution to the enactment of the Federal Labor Law of 1931. Despite the revolution's many twists and turns, Suarez-Potts maintains that the basic concepts in the 1857 constitution were preserved. The dominant revolutionary faction drafted a new constitution that included a section (Article 123) dedicated to workers’ entitlements, which ratified the rights of free labor and prohibited peonage. More radically, Article 123 stipulated a system of profit sharing, the fixing of a minimum wage, and made employers responsible for work-related accidents and occupational illnesses. The article was a mixed blessing as it reflected a revolution whose outcome was uneven and problematic. While it instituted labor boards to adjudicate labor-capital conflicts, it also delegated jurisdiction to the states and weakened federal power. The result was a void which was filled by an activist Supreme Court.
In the book's most definitive chapters, Suarez-Potts demonstrates how the federal judiciary came to uphold workers’ rights embodied in boards of conciliation. The culmination of the court's work was the 1931 passage of the federal labor law. The provisions of Article 123 were to be applied uniformly across the country, but it also limited the discretion of the labor boards, severely circumscribed the right to strike, and transformed the constitutional right of profit sharing into a savings scheme. After 1934 the status of the court was downgraded, and it became more dependent on the whims of executive power.
The book is grounded in exceptionally rich archival and other primary sources. Economic historians may chaff about the failure to integrate developments in the Mexican economy and labor law. Comparisons with other New World countries sharing many of the same features could be enhanced. Notwithstanding, this book's overarching conclusions are important in at least two respects. First, Suarez-Potts renders unhistoric the popular practice of coding countries as civil or common law regimes. Secondly, he contests the crude characterization of latecomers as politically exclusive and economically extractive. On these two scores, this book is well worth consulting.
