Just when one might think another book on Darwin and culture would be redundant there appears a strikingly original, probing study that should command the attention and respect of scholars of Darwin and of Victorian scientific culture in general.
Although Darwin and Darwinism feature prominently in the title and pages of Gowan Dawson's book, his real focus is wider. He explores, on the basis of exemplary research in both archival and manuscript sources, the curious relationship that Victorian reviewers and commentators drew between the ideas and advocates of scientific naturalism and the poetry of Swinburne and other Victorian aesthetic authors. More clearly than any other writer of whom I am aware, Dawson delineates the anxiety that haunted Darwin and other scientific writers that their ideas, theories, illustrative examples and subject matter in general might be construed as violating the boundaries of Victorian sexual respectability. He then demonstrates that such anxieties were well founded as he cites numerous reviews that made this connection and other reviews that directly linked the ideas of the scientists to the fleshly school of Swinburne and his followers.
By examining the response to Darwin's Descent of Man (1871), which contained more material on sexual selection than on human nature narrowly construed, Dawson illustrates first that Darwin and his publisher John Murray were aware of the possible sexual innuendoes that could be directed towards the book. Dawson then explores exactly how Darwin's critics, most importantly St George Jackson Mivart, devised strategies for exactly those purposes. In the past, historians saw the Darwin circle's response to Mivart as stemming from his implicit insult to one of Darwin's sons. It is clear from Dawson's analysis that much more was at stake. Mivart, who had trained both as a lawyer and as a scientist, understood exactly how to shape his critique of Darwin and later of other advocates of scientific naturalism to raise doubts about the fundamental morality of Darwin's thought. Early on, reviewers drew a link between the implicit materialism of Darwin and the overt sexuality of contemporary aesthetic poetry. Moreover, Dawson, through superb research, presents the manner in which Charles Bradlaugh and Annie Besant attempted to draw the advanced scientists into their crusade for birth control. The reticence of most of the scientists to have anything to do with them, even if earlier in their lives they may have to one degree or another entertained advanced ideas, is striking.
That reticence stemmed in part, as Dawson's deeply informative chapters on John Tyndall and W. K. Clifford argue, from the reputation of certain of the scientific authors to be particularly flirtatious with young women and to hold advanced views on marriage, birth control and sexuality in general. Tyndall's notorious Belfast Address of l874 linked ancient and modern materialism. He thus opened the way for his version of materialism to be linked to ancient paganism and hence to the sensuality of the ancient world associated with Walter Pater. Dawson explores the manner whereby Clifford's young widow, who became a well-connected minor novelist of women and social issues, worked with his friends to conceal after his death his advanced views on contemporary morality. This chapter indicates the manner in which scholars need to pay much more attention to the wives of scientists and others associated with scientific naturalism.
Dawson concludes his work with a chapter on the manner in which Thomas Henry Huxley and other scientific writers such as Henry Maudsley sharply criticized aestheticism as a decadent or degenerate pathology. The conclusion that follows is that they adopted this strategy in part to dissociate scientific naturalism from the associations that had challenged its respectability. Many conservative reviewers cast scientific naturalism and aestheticism as coequal forces leading society to atheism, sensuality and immorality. Huxley and others were determined to break that alleged connection. Dawson's work implicitly demonstrates that the 1830s-era radicalism explored by Adrian Desmond continued to be a presence in the heyday of Victorian scientific naturalism. As various scientific writers became burned by this association, they tried with different degrees of success to distance themselves from it.
This reviewer, who has worked with the materials Dawson has explored for many years, has not read a recent book that so splendidly and convincingly recasts the landscape of the relationship between late Victorian science and literature. Dawson does so in the most constructive of manners. He allows scholars to think more deeply about the subject in ways that may never have crossed their minds. He allows us better and more clearly to understand the perplexed self-presentation of the advocates of scientific naturalism. He also allows us to see that their conservative opponents attacked them not with an anti-intellectual, hysterical rhetoric but rather with a rhetoric that could prove highly convincing. That rhetoric also could press the debate away from the issues of science towards the issues of morality. Dawson also better than any other writer helps us understand how the supporters of scientific naturalism, often by their exuberance, exaggerated rhetoric and flamboyance, laid themselves open to this strategy. Dawson's book can begin to make one wonder whether the strategy of associating scientific naturalism with immorality was actually stronger and more effective than associating it with irreligion.
All scholars of Victorian science and culture should read and absorb this exceedingly fine, well-crafted volume. It will make all of us think and rethink a variety of subjects with which we may all have become overly comfortable.
