In her new book, Empires of Coal: Fueling China's Entry into the Modern World Order, 1860–1920, Shellen Wu argues that the discovery of a massive coal field in the north China plain in the late nineteenth century was a watershed moment in Chinese history. The discovery, by a German explorer—and the subsequent efforts by various Western agents of empire to gain access to coal and later to various minerals critical for industry—happened at a moment of crisis for China's last dynasty, the Qing, as it appeared to face dissolution at the hands of the imperial powers. Western activities in various resource-rich sites in China prompted late-Qing officials to see the production of various natural resources as “the essential ingredients for a country's standing in the world” (p. 28). In the end, Wu argues, this realization ushered in revolutionary changes in technology, industry, and the law that resonated well beyond the Qing period.
At the center of Wu's narrative is a complex, productive tension between Qing reformers and the agents of Western empires. The narrative arc of the book, which centers around German agents in particular, begins with the 1868 voyage to China by explorer and geographer Ferdinand von Richthofen. His subsequent assertion that the province of Shanxi sat atop coal reserves rivaling any other coalfield in the world helped spawn a global competition to access the tottering Qing empire's coal as well as other natural resources. The discovery served to draw in Western “missionary translators,” hired by Qing reformers to translate Western mining canon into Chinese, as well as Western engineers who were called upon to serve as technical advisers to new mining enterprises. The second half of the book focuses on the growing concerns of Qing elites regarding the intentions of the imperial powers in the dynasty's waning years. Fearing that foreign-funded mining enterprises were the vanguard in an effort to seize Qing territory, these elite reformers undertook an ultimately successful campaign to craft new mining laws modeled on those in the West and Japan, as well as to promote the development of geological sciences and a geological community in the late Qing and early Republican period.
Drawing heavily on archival documents from German archives as well as published material in German, Wu's work reveals a new, ground-level perspective on agents of Western empire. Chapter 4 in particular, which relies heavily on material from Berlin's Bundesarchiv, teases out the complex loyalties of German mining engineers and, in doing so, offers a refreshing look at the practice of empire and the Western colonial project in the late Qing period that is not mired in either Orientalist or Chinese nationalistic narratives. Yet, in this ambitious work of transnational history, the Qing side of the “global web of ideas” that Wu undertakes to reveal is surprisingly underdeveloped (p. 2). In stark contrast to the colorful humanity of the agents of Western empire and Wu's detailed descriptions of the development of Western scientific disciplines, the Chinese side of this transnational equation consists largely of vague sketches, with only a few exceptions. While we learn a great deal about American translator Daniel Jerome Macgowan in chapter 3, for example, his partner in the Jiangnan Arsenal translation enterprise, Hua Hengfang, registers, but only barely. Even prominent Qing reformers like Zhang Zhidong and Kang Youwei, who played active roles in spearheading the revolutionary transformation of ideas about natural resources, lack the personal detail found in depictions of their Western counterparts. To some extent, the relative weakness of the sections on the Qing dynasty are a product of the comparatively poorer access to archives in China. But the unfortunate consequence is that the Western agents of empire appear as the sole engine of change in the late nineteenth century. In Wu's narrative framework, Qing and early Republican figures appear to be largely reactive, doing little more than simply importing these new ideas about coal and industrial production wholesale from the West.
None of this is to discount the importance of Wu's larger findings regarding the revolutionary transformation in ideas about natural resources and their connections to state power in the late nineteenth century. Indeed, the formation of a nexus between mining, industrial production, and national prestige continues to resonate in China today. Like its counterparts in the Republic, and the early People's Republic, the Chinese Communist Party continues to defend its legitimacy in terms of industrial production and the achievement of economic production benchmarks. Wu reminds us that this shift was not a product of 1950s big-push planning, as one might have previously suspected, when Chinese Communist Party planners measured national success in terms of tons of iron mined, coal coked, and steel produced. Instead, this monumental change was a product of ideas imported in the late nineteenth century by a set of reformers desperate to save the Qing empire.
