In recent years, the Anglo-American world has seen a growing interest in the thought and works of the controversial German jurist Carl Schmitt. William Hooker's new book is an excellent contribution to the burgeoning literature. Hooker sees Schmitt as one of the twentieth century's most profound theorists of international order and maintains that his Nomos of the Earth in the International Law of the Jus Publicum Europaeum (1950) deserves a place in the canon of essential reading in international relations. However, Hooker also argues that “for all its analytical depth and vast ambition, Schmitt's international thought represents a failure” (p. 3). He asserts that “Schmitt's eschatological-historical position results in a sterile conundrum in which Schmitt was torn between an ultra-reactionary defence of the flawed state form, and a breathless anticipation of an apocalyptic world unity” (p. 4); throughout the book under review, Hooker attempts to establish “the degree to which such talk of apocalypse is a metaphor” (ibid.). He contends that Schmitt's pessimism regarding the fate of the Westphalian system and the prospects of the state as a political form derives from his “historical method.” He then moves on to claim that the two devices that Schmitt creates to theorize post-1945 world order—namely, “Grossraum” and “the Partisan”—ultimately fail.
Among the many books on Schmitt published in the past decade, Hooker's contribution stands out for a number of reasons. Firstly, and most importantly, it focuses almost exclusively on Schmitt's understanding of the international and tries to relate it to contemporary debates on global politics. It has been noted that the nexus of “the state and IR” is crucial to the discipline and yet is still understudied; this renders Hooker's work a valuable addition not only to the literature on Schmitt but also to the literature on international relations. Secondly, this book examines in great depth the writings by Schmitt (such as Land and Sea [1954], Nomos of the Earth and Theory of the Partisan [1963]) that have so far attracted limited attention in the Anglo-American literature. Thirdly, it proposes a novel way of viewing and assessing the contribution of Schmitt to political theorizing.
In Chapter 1, Hooker introduces the themes addressed in his work and offers his readers guidance on how to navigate the volume. In Chapter 2, he convincingly demonstrates that “international concerns are present in Schmitt's political theory from the outset” (p. 12). Echoing Stephen Holmes's claim that, for Schmitt, “the only politics is international politics,” Hooker shows that “for Schmitt politics is by definition a pluriverse and hence international or inter-something” (p. 12). He highlights Schmitt's interest in the problematic aspects of international law and order in late modernity and recognizes his unique understanding of the relationship among order, security, and peace. In Chapter 3, Hooker explores Schmitt's writings on the history of political authority, focusing on religious and eschatological themes. He ably elucidates the development of Schmitt's concepts of power and authority and the hidden debate between Schmitt and the giants of earlier political thought, most notably Thomas Hobbes.
In Chapter 4, Hooker considers an important historical dynamic in Schmitt's political thought: the history of spatial consciousness. This chapter is particularly thought provoking and engages with Schmitt's Land and Sea; for Hooker, “Schmitt's critique of the dialectic or dialogism of land and sea is part of his wider critique of the intellectual and historical processes of modernity” (p. 101). He moves on to expound and appraise Schmitt's conceptual response to the crisis of late modernity and his attempt “to conceive and identify the contours of the coming age.” In Chapter 6, Hooker discusses Grossraum and addresses the question of whether Schmitt achieves some degree of novelty in his discussion of this concept; then, in Chapter 7, he discusses the Partisan, which he sees as Schmitt's final effort to find “a new theoretical path away from world unity, deterritorialisation and eschata” (p. 155).
Hooker's verdict is that the concepts of Grossraum and Partisan are “failures.” As for the former, Hooker accuses Schmitt of developing “a theory of a new politics of large spaces that was essentially a fudge” (p. 200). With regards to the latter, he contends that “Schmitt is still rehearsing his attachment to the state and his regret at its passing” (p. 201). For Hooker, Schmitt's main failure was that he did not separate his study of order from his study of the history of the state.
In the literature, there exists a debate between Schmitt's detractors, who in particular remind us of his Nazi past, and his supporters, who try to rehabilitate him. Hooker contributes to this debate without affiliating himself with either side. On the one hand, he joins the camp of Schmitt enthusiasts by ascribing to the German jurist a profound understanding of the notion of global order, a remarkable ability to foresee the future of world politics, and special competence and erudition in a range of fields varying from political philosophy to history, from theology to international law, from geopolitics to linguistics. He also shares the admiration voiced by many for Schmitt's clarity of concepts and style of delivery. Above all, he praises Schmitt for his legacy of political categories that are ever relevant in the contemporary study of international politics. Conversely, Hooker also supports Schmitt's critics insofar as he points out the failure of his conceptual innovations and stresses that his contribution to international theorizing lies in his historical critique. According to Hooker, the two devices introduced by Schmitt to theorize post-1945 world order, namely, Grossraum and the Partisan, ultimately fail.
Hooker's line of criticism against Schmitt and, in particular, his claim that Schmitt failed is predicated on the tenet that Schmitt saw it as his task to envisage a new political order or create new political forms. It is not clear, however, if this is an accurate representation of his intentions. For example, Schmitt points out that the Westphalian system grew out of the European way of life and was an indirect product of European rationalism, rather than the result of the conceptualization of philosophers. Moreover, for Schmitt, Hobbes did not invent the Leviathan and the sovereign state; Hobbes's genius lay in his grasp of the state's importance, his understanding of its essence, his formulation of its form and function. Similarly, it could be argued that Schmitt's insight lay in grasping that in the twentieth century, there were new political forms beside the state, forms such as the political party, the Grossraum, and the terrorist group. He felt that it was his business as a political theorist to recognize the fact that the “political” and the state no longer coincided, that the “total party” in particular was the new political form of the early twentieth century, and that terrorism was its future.
Rather than understanding these conceptualizations as proffered solutions to world order, they can be understood as historical phenomena that Schmitt witnessed and studied. Some, then, may disagree with Hooker's analysis of what Schmitt intended to do and take issue with the verdict that Schmitt failed as an international theorist. Certainly, though, this does not diminish the value of Hooker's admirable work.
