Perhaps the most powerful thrust of Richard R. John's Network Nation (2010) as a reinterpretation of the development of telegraphy and telephony in the United States lay in his insistence that the history of American telecommunications is at core a political story.Footnote 1 The intertwined but strikingly different trajectories of telegraph and telephone business, John argued, was determined neither by technological inventions nor by timeless economic principles. Instead, they reflected the structuring power of different regulatory regimes, the strategic responses of business leaders to shifting political conditions, and the competition among various Gilded Age ideologies of economic competition and public utility. Notwithstanding notable differences in narrative emphasis, Robert MacDougall's new study of the history of the telephone marches under John's banner and appears under his aegis (as part of the American Business, Politics, and Society series of which John is coeditor).
The People's Network burrows into a portion of John's story and offers a comprehensive and convincing business history of North American telephony, especially during the period between the Bell Telephone-Western Union pact in 1879 and the return of the telephone industry to private hands in 1919 following a brief but consequential federal takeover. Many episodes in the narrative echo Network Nation, and some of the material presented here will be familiar to readers of such scholars as Claude Fischer, Carolyn Marvin, and Lisa Gitelman. Nonetheless, MacDougall has produced a distinctive account of the turn-of-the-century telephone wars, an original guide to the geography of telephone commercialization and expansion in the United States and Canada, and a provocative contribution to the cultural history of telephone use.
Much of The People's Network reconstructs the complex rise of Bell Telephone/AT&T to the position of market dominance that its company historians would later seek to naturalize. MacDougall shows that popular impressions of the “Bell System” as a unifying force in American life, pursuing the technological destiny of the telephone to turn the continent into one big interconnected neighborhood, are mythological constructs. In fact, from 1879 until the beginning of the next century, the company was committed to a very different business model: providing expensive specialty services to an elite clientele. The road to monopoly was circuitous, highly contested, and in many ways ironic. Bell/AT&T benefited from such developments as federal antitrust investigation, the decision of its many independent competitors to embrace the then-controversial principle that competing phone systems ought to interconnect, and even the U.S. government's takeover of the telephone wires at the end of World War I.
This is an important demonstration of the contingent history of communications technologies and the unnatural character of communications monopolies. From MacDougall's perspective, Bell's struggle with its independent rivals also tracks the history of “the incorporation of America”; Bell's eventual apotheosis as an integrated system “offered an argument for the rightness and inevitability of the dawning corporate age” (228). MacDougall tells the story well, but his original contribution lies more in his sustained attention to the thousands of independent telephone companies that proliferated and predominated between 1894 and 1907 and in the critical perspectives that inform his narrative.
First, MacDougall breaks down the history of Gilded Age telephony geographically. Comparisons between the United States and Canada appear throughout, but most prominently in an early chapter that compares the spread of telephone use in Kingston, Ontario; and Muncie, Indiana. The chapter, which fits awkwardly in the book's larger structure, frames MacDougall's major argument: telephones spread quite differently in different places, not simply between the two nations but within them as well. This is part of what MacDougall means by his early and frequent insistence on the “local” character of early telephone history. Localism does significant conceptual work in MacDougall's account, which emphasizes not only that local conditions determined the course and character of telephony, but also that telephones, rhetoric about annihilating space notwithstanding, were devices and networks situated in particular places. Perhaps the most significant references to localism, however, relate to the history of the independent telephone companies in the Midwest. The independents, which prospered in what MacDougall presents as a golden age of competition, low prices, expanded service, and increased participation, were locally owned and oriented. Their subscribers (like those of the Bell companies) made mostly local calls. Most crucially, for MacDougall, the independent movement thrived in political contexts framed by franchise agreements with local governments. In regions and nations with weaker municipal governments, both competition and usage lagged. As state and federal authority over municipal franchising expanded during the Progressive Era, the independent movement suffered.
Although MacDougall privileges the decisive role of political structures and environments in shaping the outcomes of business competition and the spread of telephone use, this is also a book about culture. Occasionally he refers to vague differences in outlook between regions or between the United States and Canada, but the book's more energetic engagement with ideas relates to competing visions of telephony itself. Gardiner Hubbard, Alexander Graham Bell's patron and father-in-law, favored the path of government control pursued by most European countries, in part because he envisioned the telephone as a mass-communications device suitable for a postal system. But this minority view was quickly displaced at National Bell (along with Hubbard himself) by investors and executives who saw the telephone as a business-to-business convenience. Independent phone companies and their users championed other social functions for telephone service, including group conversation and musical performance. Often these visions of telephony expressed political ideals. Populism figures prominently in The People's Network, primarily as a language for legitimating competition or promoting business interests that were typically entrepreneurial rather than agrarian. But the competing rhetorics of populism, nationalism, public service, and system usefully track the players in this story and help make sense of its denouement. MacDougall is deeply interested in the relationship between political structures and political ideals, and in the proposition that “political economy shaped not only commercial outcomes but rhetoric and even culture” (122), but the book underscores and illuminates the rhetorical and cultural dimensions of telephone history.
Among the most resonant features of that history, especially in an age when the telephone is a ubiquitous instrument and symbol of interconnectedness, is the role of pricing in reinforcing ideas about proper telephone use. Even more than in earlier accounts, MacDougall substantiates the importance of the flat service plans offered by independent telephone companies in producing a modern culture of phone use. The Bell ideal of measured service suited the phone's intended function as a business device (such plans were also designed to discourage use and limit network size), but the independents and their customers favored unlimited calling and helped redefine the telephone, especially in the Midwest and West, as an appropriate way to interact with neighbors, relatives, and local merchants. As later developments in the history of telecommunications confirm, the question of how much a phone call or a telegram or a letter or an e-mail costs and how such variables as frequency, volume, and distance are assessed, is as crucial to shaping norms and expectations of long-distance contact and mass participation as the technological capacities of the devices themselves. Robert MacDougall demonstrates that, in the case of the telephone, such reckonings have a rich political history.
