International loans of artworks are a critical element of cultural exchange and education. But each time an artwork leaves the borders of the nation where it is currently held, there is some degree of uncertainty about whether it will return. In an effort to provide a level of confidence to institutions in lending countries, many nations have passed various forms of legislation that immunize works of art and cultural objects from seizure in a court proceeding—even in the face of claims that the objects may have been stolen or looted from the original owner—each one trying to balance a moral and legal imperative (the return of stolen property) with a cultural and societal privilege (the exchange of timeless treasures).
In State Immunity and Cultural Objects on Loan, a thorough and well-researched compendium of immunity from seizure legislation and significant legal cases from around the world, Nout van Woudenberg, an external researcher at the University of Amsterdam and Legal Counsel at the International Law Division of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Kingdom of the Netherlands, investigates the current state of affairs for international loans of cultural property. By examining “relevant State practice and motivation, jurisprudence of national and international courts, views and discussions in literature, and instruments of international law,” Van Woudenberg sets out to answer the following questions:
Does a rule of customary international law exist, to the effect that cultural objects belonging to foreign States are immune from seizure while on temporary loan to another State or foreign museum for an exhibition? If such a rule does not yet exist, is it emerging? Further, if such a rule does exist or is emerging, what is the scope of this rule, and what are its limitations?
Each chapter of Van Woudenberg's book explores the situation in a different country, including the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, and the Netherlands, to name a few. In some, the cultural object is automatically immune from seizure, and no action is required from the borrowing institution. Other nations only grant immunity after the institution applies for immunity pursuant to an administrative process and notice is published.
Van Woudenberg devotes a considerable portion of his book to the United States' approach to immunity from seizure, which is fitting since, in 1965, the United States became the first country to enact immunity from seizure legislation for cultural objects, and much of the jurisprudence in the field has been developed by U.S. courts. Indeed, Van Woudenberg extensively discusses two significant U.S. cases, United States v. Portrait of Wally Footnote 1 and Malewicz v. City of Amsterdam, both of which our firm handled for the claimants.
For the most part, Van Woudenberg provides a fair and balanced analysis of the decisions and legislation regarding immunity from seizure for cultural property, and he thoughtfully explores the tension between immunity from seizure and immunity from jurisdiction and how these issues correlate.Footnote 2 Thus, while antiseizure legislation may protect works of art or cultural objects that are imported into a foreign country for temporary exhibition from being seized or otherwise restrained pursuant to judicial process, such laws do not necessarily immunize the sovereign lenders from being sued.Footnote 3 For example, the United States has adopted a restrictive theory of sovereign immunity since 1952, when the U.S. State Department's Acting Legal Adviser Jack B. Tate issued a letter to the Acting Attorney General, disavowing the absolute theory of sovereign immunity and recognizing a shift in U.S. policy, whereby foreign sovereigns would be immune from suit for their public or governmental activities, but not with respect to private or commercial acts, a shift that was later codified by the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act of 1976. Thus, a sovereign lender will not be automatically immune from suit in the United States, since loaning artworks or cultural objects is considered a commercial, rather than public, act.Footnote 4
Van Woudenberg ultimately concludes that “a relatively young rule of customary international law exists, to the extent that cultural objects belonging to foreign States and on temporary loan for an exhibition are immune from seizure.” But he qualifies this statement, by noting that “this rule is not yet firmly established or well defined in all its aspects, and this rule has certain limitations.” His qualifications of this “relatively young rule,” in the end, negate his proposition that there is such a rule. According to the Restatement of the Law, Foreign Relations Law of the United States, “[c]ustomary international law results from a general and consistent practice of states followed by them from a sense of legal obligation.”Footnote 5 Furthermore, while “[a] practice can be general even if it is not universally followed, … it should reflect wide acceptance among the states particularly involved in the relevant activity. Failure of a significant number of important states to adopt a practice can prevent a principle from becoming general customary law.”Footnote 6 As Van Woudenberg himself demonstrates, the contours of immunity from judicial seizure vary among nations, and even the basic practice has not been universally adopted.Footnote 7
Indeed, there is simply no basis for Van Woudenberg's contention that U.S. practice and “its belief in a legal obligation” contributes to the formation of a so-called rule of customary international law for loaned cultural objects. In the United States, all foreign art loans are subject to seizure, unless the borrowing institution has submitted an application to the U.S. Department of State. If the Department of State certifies that the object is of cultural significance and that its temporary exhibition or display is in the national interest, and notice to that effect is published in the Federal Register, the cultural object is immune from judicial seizure. And while there is a federal immunity statute, there is inconsistency at the state level: only New York, Rhode Island, Tennessee, and Texas have antiseizure laws for cultural objects, and Texas's statute provides an exception for stolen works of art, while the other states do not. Indeed, Van Woudenberg notes that in his conversations with legal representatives of the U.S. Department of State, the U.S. authorities did not wish to rely on a possible rule of customary international law to immunize foreign cultural objects from seizure.
Despite our reservations about Van Woudenberg's principal thesis, we are nonetheless impressed with the extensive research and analysis reflected in this treatise. We think it is significant that, rather than focusing entirely on the United States or Europe, Van Woudenberg also discusses how countries in Asia and Africa are responding to concerns regarding international loans of artwork. While we do not believe that there is a “young” or developing rule of customary international law that provides immunity from seizure for cultural objects on loan, Van Woudenberg's text is nonetheless a helpful encyclopedia of international legislation and jurisprudence on this evolving subject, and will be a worthwhile addition to the libraries of governmental agencies, cultural institutions, attorneys, and other stakeholders in the international art market.
