Numerous books have been written over the last two decades that discuss the history of hominid palaeontology or how different conceptions of biological evolution have influenced theories of human evolution. The question of human phylogeny – the attempt by palaeoanthropologists to reconstruct the human evolutionary family tree – is sometimes discussed in these works but only tangentially. Richard Delisle has made phylogenetic reconstruction the central focus of his book, and uses its history as a means to examine the broader history of palaeoanthropology. While Delisle analyses the ideas of a great many scientists, the broad intent of the book is to argue several general claims. One is to show that palaeoanthropology has been a remarkably unified discipline because it has accepted as its basic principle the idea of biological evolution. Delisle downplays the significance of the fact that over the last century and a half there have been several competing theories of how evolution operates, rejecting the argument that differing conceptions of biological evolution have fundamentally shaped particular human evolutionary phylogenies.
He also suggests that traditional histories of palaeoanthropology that focus on unilinear versus multilinear conceptions of human evolution have distorted the record, and more significantly have ignored models of human evolution that were based on parallel and polyphyletic conceptions of human phylogeny. A great deal of attention is devoted here to examining the full variety of phylogenetic hypotheses that were proposed over the last century and a half. Furthermore, Delisle argues that historians have exaggerated the influence of the hominid fossil record in the development of palaeoanthropological theory while not sufficiently recognizing the impact that studies of living and fossil non-human primates have had on shaping human phylogenies. Indeed, Delisle convincingly demonstrates that during the first half-century after Darwin proposed his theory of evolution it was evidence drawn from studies of the comparative anatomy of human and non-human primates, rather than the hominid fossil record, that contributed most to the phylogenies formulated at the time. As a result, Delisle not only explores the various models of human phylogeny proposed over the last century and a half, but also examines models of primate phylogeny, and the ways these two reconstructive endeavours were related to one another.
Delisle argues that there has been a distinct and theoretically significant cumulative increase in the empirical content of palaeoanthropology over time, largely driven by the discovery of increasing numbers of hominid and other fossils during the twentieth century. He conceives of the history of palaeoanthropology as being divided into several distinct periods, the first extending from 1860 to 1890, the second from 1890 to 1935, and the last from 1935 to the present. He sees the initial period as characterized by phylogenetic questions generated by Darwin's theory of evolution, but also by long-standing debates over monogenism and polygenism – whether the human races share a single origin and are one species or have separate origins and belong to different species. Also, the lack of hominid fossils led to a reliance on comparative anatomy as well as on observations drawn from historical linguistics regarding the relationships existing between living human populations. The conditions present at this time led to the formulation of numerous and often very different human evolutionary trees. The period from 1890 to 1935 is marked, Delisle argues, by the discovery of new fossils that expanded the empirical base of palaeoanthropology but also drew the study of human phylogeny even closer to the study of non-human primate phylogeny. However, Delisle shows that the larger number of hominid fossils did not lead to a reduction in the number of proposed human phylogenies during this period, largely because the fossil record was still too limited and too ambiguous to support one model over another. This situation changed, according to Delisle, after 1935 as the number of hominid fossils dramatically increased and as the australopithecines were gradually recognized as being ancestral to modern humans. This latter period is also marked by the rejection of polyphyletic conceptions of human evolution and the increasing convergence of most proposed hominid phylogenies.
The large number of scientists, works and theories examined in this book makes for a broad and thorough portrait of the major ideas and debates within hominid phylogeny and palaeoanthropology since 1860. The great breadth of the material surveyed often means that particular individuals or theories are discussed only cursorily. The account Delisle gives sometimes lacks clarity because of the way he organizes material within the chapters, and because a great deal of the scientific and historical context is not presented to the reader but is assumed. This difficulty with the book is compounded by poor editing, to the extent that there are not only stylistic improvements that could have been made but numerous grammatical errors that remain.
But considering the book's scholarly contribution, Delisle makes several interesting and potentially important arguments about the development of palaeoanthropology and the accounts of that history presented in recent historical scholarship. Among the strongest is his assertion that hominid phylogenies were not strongly influenced by the conception of biological evolution held by different anthropologists. Delisle does not, however, convincingly demonstrate this contention, on which additional research is needed. The value of Delisle's book lies, then, not only in its comprehensive analysis of the role of hominid phylogenies within palaeoanthropology, but in the many new research questions it raises.
